
Brighton and Hove planning committee
Councillor Mark Earthey
IndependentSeen at planning committee from May 2025 to October 2026
- 100%attendance
- 38recorded votes
- 22agreed, no vote against recorded
- 100%with the majority
- 0%against officer advice
As at 7 October 2026, according to Plota’s analysis of Brighton and Hove’s published minutes, Councillor Mark Earthey attended 17 of the 17 planning committee meetings whose minutes list them, from May 2025 to October 2026. Each member's vote is recorded on 38 decisions at those meetings: Earthey voted for the resolution on all 38. On 21 of those votes the officers’ recommendation is known, and none went against it. On 22 other decisions the minutes record no vote against, so Earthey is counted as agreeing; they are left out of the shares below.
- Meetings attended
- 17 of 17100%
- Meetings whose minutes list them as present, sending apologies or absent. Minutes that list only those present cannot show an absence.
- Decisions at their meetings
- 86
- Applications decided at the meetings they sat on, as the minutes record them.
- Recorded votes
- 38
- Decisions where the minutes, the council's recorded vote or the meeting's recording give each member's vote: 38 for, 0 against, 0 abstained.
- With the majority
- 38 of 38100%
- Votes for the resolution the committee passed. An abstention is not counted as with the majority.
- Agreed, no vote against recorded
- 22
- Decisions the minutes record with no vote against and no count. Counted as agreeing, and left out of the shares.
- Votes against officer advice
- 0 of 210%
- Recorded votes where the officers’ recommendation is known: for a resolution that went against it, or against one that followed it.
- Proposed or seconded
- 0 / 1
- Motions the minutes say they proposed, then seconded, that the committee passed.
- Declared interests
- 0
- Decisions on which the minutes record them declaring an interest.
Voting record
Votes by quarter
For the resolution on all 38 recorded votes; the most in Q4 2025 (15).
38 recorded votes, by the quarter of the meeting.
Show as a table
| Quarter | For | Against | Abstained |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q2 2025 | 9 | 0 | 0 |
| Q3 2025 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| Q4 2025 | 15 | 0 | 0 |
| Q1 2026 | 7 | 0 | 0 |
| Q2 2026 | 4 | 0 | 0 |
| Q4 2026 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
Against officer advice
Earthey went against officer advice less often than the committee: 0% of votes, against 4% of decisions.
The share that went against the officers’ recommendation.
The typical member of this committee (the median of 12 members with 5 or more such votes) voted against officer advice on 0% of them.
Agreement with other members
Not drawn: the minutes record no divided vote of this councillor by name. On a unanimous vote every member agrees, so it says nothing about agreement.
Attendance
100%
17 of 17 meetings whose minutes list them.
The typical member of this committee attended 100% (the median of 11 members listed at 5 or more meetings).
Every meeting
Each square is a meeting whose minutes list them, oldest first.
Planning Committee: 17 meetings
Show as a table
| Date | Committee | Attendance |
|---|---|---|
| 7 Oct 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 5 Aug 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 29 Jul 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 1 Jul 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 3 Jun 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 6 May 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 1 Apr 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 4 Mar 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 4 Feb 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 3 Dec 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 5 Nov 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 1 Oct 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 3 Sep 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 6 Aug 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 2 Jul 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 4 Jun 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 7 May 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
Decisions
Every application decided at a meeting they sat on, newest first, with their vote where the minutes give it.
- 25 Drove Road BrightonCommercial equine facility · BH2026/01166 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Brighton And Hove High School Junior Department Radinden Manor Road Hove47-person house in multiple occupation · BH2026/00749 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 1 Barrack Yard Brighton11 temporary flats · BH2025/02689 Approved ForNo vote against recorded
- Flat 9 191 Kingsway HoveAlterations to the existing balcony balustrade and addition of three retractable awnings to existing… · BH2026/01213 Approved ForNo vote against recorded
- 31 Eldred Avenue BrightonErection of four storey 3no bedroom dwelling (C3) adjacent to existing dwelling incorporating new… · BH2025/02058 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- North Cottages Ovingdean Road BrightonFull planning application · BH2025/03102 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Varndean School Balfour Road BrightonSchool fencing · BH2026/00745 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 76 - 79 And 80 Buckingham Road BrightonCondition variation · BH2026/00198 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- King Alfred Leisure Centre (part) And Public Car Park And Lawn West Of Hove Street Kingsway, HoveLeisure centre redevelopment · BH2026/00490 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- St Margarets High Street Rottingdean BrightonInstallation of 1no EE and 1no H3G Antenna Aperture on Valmont frame on plinths, EE and H3G BOBs behind… · BH2025/02913 Refused Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 65 Ladies Mile Road BrightonTwo-bedroom bungalow · BH2026/00234 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Site Of Amex House Edward Street BrightonFull planning application · BH2025/03092 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Site Of Amex House Edward Street BrightonGym use · BH2026/00020 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Homewood College Queensdown Road BrightonTemporary change of use · BH2025/03062 Approved ForNo vote against recorded
- Sussex County Cricket Ground Eaton Road HoveTemporary bar facility · BH2026/00748 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 165 Hollingdean Terrace BrightonNew home · BH2026/00064 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Site Of Amex House Edward Street BrightonFull planning application · BH2025/03081Seconded the motion Approved Not recordedThe minutes give only the count: 8 for, 2 against
- 23 Byron Street HoveFour-bedroom HMO · BH2025/02640 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 267 Old Shoreham Road HoveDrive-through fast-food restaurant · BH2025/00019 Refused Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 8 Windmill Drive BrightonHouseholder planning consent · BH2026/00158 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 19 New England Street BrightonSeven-person HMO · BH2026/00393 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- 63 Hallyburton Road HoveExtended academy hours · BH2026/00046 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 15 Auckland Drive BrightonStudent HMO conversion · BH2025/02981 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 23C Shirley Drive HoveRetrospective house permission · BH2025/00500 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- The Hippodrome 51 And 52 - 58 Middle Street BrightonHippodrome venue changes · BH2025/02723 Approved ForNo vote against recorded
- 2 St Heliers Avenue HoveGym opening-time variation · BH2026/00121 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 2 Richmond Road BrightonRear dormers and front window · BH2025/03024 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 77 Braemore Road HoveRear house extensions · BH2025/03063 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 87 Hove Park Road HoveDormer windows · BH2024/03142 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- 40 Selhurst Road BrightonHouseholder alterations · BH2025/01026 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- 120 Longhill Road BrightonHouse extensions and garden annexe · BH2025/01860 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 62 St Georges Road BrightonSingle dwelling with roof extension · BH2025/01474 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Rockwater Kingsway HoveThree sauna cabins · BH2025/02251 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 80 Overhill Drive BrightonErection of two storey, three bedroom detached dwelling house (C3) to side of existing property, with… · BH2025/01589 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Keasley House 10 Franklin Road PortsladeTwo new homes · BH2025/03004 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 48B Ventnor Villas HoveGarden office outbuilding · BH2025/02302 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 3 Ridgewood Avenue Saltdean BrightonHouse with roof dormer · BH2025/02114 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Basement Flat 99 Buckingham Road BrightonFlat extensions · BH2025/02255 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 21 Chailey Avenue Rottingdean BrightonHouseholder planning consent · BH2025/01886 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- 297 Cowley Drive BrightonSix-person small HMO · BH2025/02379 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- 89 Holland Road HoveNursery capacity increase · BH2025/02344 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- The Pinnacle (formerly Rayford House) 8 School Road HoveControlled gate and blocked access · BH2025/02297 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North Of Swanborough Drive Brighton36 affordable homes · BH2025/00532 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Land East Of 5 Nolan Road BrightonOne two-bedroom dwelling · BH2025/01008 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Garages 1 To 6 Rear Of 187 Kingsway HoveTwo three-bedroom homes · BH2025/01647 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 4 Benett Drive HoveHouseholder alterations · BH2025/01832 Refused Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 70 North Street PortsladeRefurbishment of existing builders merchants including single storey extension to South elevation of… · BH2025/01397 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- 54 Auckland Drive BrightonSix-bedroom HMO · BH2025/02421 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Withdean Sports Complex Tongdean Lane BrightonFull planning application · BH2025/01881 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Saltdean United Football Club And Playing Fields Saltdean Vale Saltdean BrightonCondition variation · BH2025/00834 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Patcham Court Farm Vale Avenue BrightonCondition changes · BH2025/02142 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 28 Herbert Road BrightonLoft conversion with rear dormer · BH2025/02245 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Corn Exchange Church Street BrightonRoof access systems · BH2025/01654 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Corn Exchange Church Street BrightonRoof access systems · BH2025/01655 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 22A Wilbury Crescent HoveTwo-flat development · BH2025/01442 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- First Floor And Second Floor Flat 7 St Johns Place HoveFirst and second-floor flats · BH2025/01793 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- First Floor And Second Floor Flat 7 St Johns Place HoveFirst and second floor flats · BH2025/01792 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 13 - 14 Sydney Street BrightonThree-storey building extension · BH2025/00877 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Site Of Sackville Road Trading Estate Sackville Road HoveAffordable housing scheme · BH2025/01414 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- 12 Nevill Way HoveHouseholder annex · BH2025/00802 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 10 Dukes Lane BrightonRemoval or variation of condition · BH2025/01338 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- BHCC Household Waste Recycling Site Modbury Way HoveRecycling-site pumphouse · BH2025/00747 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Kap Ltd Newtown Road HoveCondition variation · BH2025/01359 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Royal Pavilion Gardens Pavilion Buildings BrightonCondition variation · BH2025/01627 Approved ForNo vote against recorded
- Brighton Dome Church Street BrightonListed building repairs · BH2025/01527 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 7 Saxon Close Saltdean BrightonCondition variation · BH2025/01377 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 295 Dyke Road HoveReserved matters development · BH2025/00936 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land Adjacent To West Stand American Express Stadium Village Way BrightonParking development · BH2025/00899 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- 63 LYMINSTER AVENUE, BRIGHTONRear extension and raised terrace · BH2024/01962 RefusedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- The FreeButt 1 Phoenix Place BrightonBuilding extension and flats · BH2025/00889 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- 9-12 ST CATHERINES TERRACE, HOVE30 flats · BH2023/03293 Approved ForNo vote against recorded
- Brighton College Preparatory School Walpole Lodge 2 Walpole Road And Pre-Prep School Eastern Road, 2 Belle Vue Gardens And 141 And 143 Eastern Road BrightonSchool development · BH2025/00264 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 31 Wanderdown Road BrightonRear and side extensions · BH2025/00150 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Hanover Crescent Enclosure BrightonElectric vehicle charger · BH2025/00363 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 4/4A Church Place BrightonExternal building alterations · BH2024/02796 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 182 Old Shoreham Road HoveShop frontage works · BH2025/00387 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 6B College Place BrightonThree new homes · BH2025/00268 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 3 Merston Close BrightonOne rear dwelling · BH2024/03089 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Imperial House 40 - 42 Queens Road BrightonWindows, deck and seating · BH2025/00222 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 9A Harrington Road, BrightonRoof alterations · BH2024/02554 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 1 And 1A Pembroke Crescent HoveTwo small HMOs · BH2024/02767 Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 9 Princes Square, HoveHouseholder planning consent · BH2024/02834 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Flat 2 Princes Mansions 31 Sussex Square BrightonConservatory glazed roof replacement · BH2024/03122 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- 47 Eastbrook Road PortsladeHMO conversion · BH2025/00230 Approved ForUnanimous vote
- 126 Gloucester Road, BrightonAffordable housing head-term amendment · BH2022/02689 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Royal Sussex County Hospital, Eastern Road, BrightonRegional cancer centre · BH2024/02729 Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
No decision matches these filters.
In the minutes
What the minutes record Earthey moving, seconding, asking or saying on each decision, in the minutes’ own words. Passages that name more than one councillor, or a member of the public, are left out.
Subjects in what the minutes record
- Neighbours and amenity3 Jun 2026, 6 May 2026, 1 Apr 2026, 4 Feb 2026, 4 Feb 2026, 3 Dec 2025
- Parking and traffic29 Jul 2026, 4 Feb 2026, 5 Nov 2025, 1 Oct 2025, 4 Jun 2025
- Design, scale and character5 Aug 2026, 1 Apr 2026, 3 Dec 2025
- Housing need and affordable homes4 Mar 2026, 2 Jul 2025
- Heritage1 Jul 2026
- Spoke
“Councillor Earthey agreed with other councillors and requested that the homeless are not stigmatised.”
Minutes, 7 Oct 2026, 1 Barrack Yard Brighton - Seconded
“Councillor Parrott proposed, and Councillor Earthey seconded, a motion to add the following condition:”
Minutes, 7 Oct 2026, 1 Barrack Yard Brighton - Asked a question
“Councillor Earthey was informed that the application was considered an HMO by the planning team.”
Minutes, 7 Oct 2026, Brighton And Hove High School Junior Department Radinden Manor Road Hove - Spoke
“Councillor Earthey stated they loathed retrospective planning applications; however, they did not want forty-five people to be homeless.”
Minutes, 7 Oct 2026, Brighton And Hove High School Junior Department Radinden Manor Road Hove - Spoke
“Councillor Earthey considered there was more danger from cyclists and dogs being walked when walking along the access track.”
Minutes, 7 Oct 2026, 25 Drove Road Brighton - Asked about design and scale
“Councillor Earthey was informed that the fence height was standard and mesh design was chosen to maintain views.”
Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Varndean School Balfour Road Brighton - Spoke
“Councillor Earthey noted there was a statutory requirement for safeguarding; however, the councillor considered there was no reason to support the application.”
Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Varndean School Balfour Road Brighton - Asked about the conditions
“Councillor Earthey was informed that the windows would be timber framed and further details would be submitted by condition.”
Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, North Cottages Ovingdean Road Brighton - Spoke in support
“Councillor Earthey was in favour of the application as it would add to the housing stock.”
Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, North Cottages Ovingdean Road Brighton - Raised concerns
“Councillor Earthey expressed concerns that the scheme may set a dangerous precedent; however, the councillor supported the application.”
Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, 31 Eldred Avenue Brighton - Asked about parking
“Councillor Earthey was informed that there were two alternatives to access the front door, via the car park or through the building.”
Minutes, 29 Jul 2026, King Alfred Leisure Centre (part) And Public Car Park And Lawn West Of Hove Street Kingsway, Hove - Raised concerns
“Councillor Earthey expressed concerns at the access from the A259. They were satisfied that it was not a good idea to refurbish the existing building.”
Minutes, 29 Jul 2026, King Alfred Leisure Centre (part) And Public Car Park And Lawn West Of Hove Street Kingsway, Hove - Spoke in support
“Councillor Earthey supported the application.”
Minutes, 1 Jul 2026, Homewood College Queensdown Road Brighton - Asked about heritage
“Councillor Earthey was informed by the LPA that the proposals were considered to cause harm to the heritage assets of the conservation area and locally listed building.”
Minutes, 1 Jul 2026, St Margarets High Street Rottingdean Brighton - Spoke
“Councillor Earthey considered that other sites were problematic and the village was a black spot for emergency services.”
Minutes, 1 Jul 2026, St Margarets High Street Rottingdean Brighton - Asked about the conditions
“Councillor Earthey was informed that by condition a noise reduction scheme needs to be submitted and Environmental Health can take action if there are any issues.”
Minutes, 3 Jun 2026, Site Of Amex House Edward Street Brighton - Seconded
“Councillor Earthey seconded the motion.”
Minutes, 3 Jun 2026, Site Of Amex House Edward Street Brighton - Spoke
“Councillor Earthey considered the development to be a good use of the space around the substation.”
Minutes, 3 Jun 2026, 165 Hollingdean Terrace Brighton - Asked about the conditions
“Councillor Earthey was informed that the rear elevation of the nearest neighbours to the south were 40m from the application property and that a condition was proposed whereby the rear terrace would be required to have screening to the sides to protect neighbouring amenity.”
Minutes, 6 May 2026, 8 Windmill Drive Brighton - Asked a question
“Councillor Earthey was informed that the existing floor space would be reduced from 900sqm to 350sqm with 62 full time equivalent jobs.”
Minutes, 6 May 2026, 267 Old Shoreham Road Hove - Spoke in support
“Councillor Earthey supported the case officer’s recommendation to refuse.”
Minutes, 6 May 2026, 267 Old Shoreham Road Hove - Asked a question
“Councillor Earthey was informed that the access to the site was shared with other businesses and was not lockable.”
Minutes, 1 Apr 2026, 2 St Heliers Avenue Hove - Spoke on neighbours' amenity
“Councillor Earthey considered a compromise would be to have an updated noise assessment before making a decision.”
Minutes, 1 Apr 2026, 2 St Heliers Avenue Hove - Asked about design and scale
“Councillor Earthey was informed that the roof will increase by 3m in total height, however, any loss of view was not a planning consideration.”
Minutes, 1 Apr 2026, The Hippodrome 51 And 52 - 58 Middle Street Brighton - Raised concerns
“Councillor Earthey was concerned at the extra 500 patrons as they wanted safety to be put first, however, on balance they supported the application.”
Minutes, 1 Apr 2026, The Hippodrome 51 And 52 - 58 Middle Street Brighton - Spoke
“Councillor Earthey stated they were deeply concerned; however, they trusted the BC team.”
Minutes, 1 Apr 2026, 23C Shirley Drive Hove - Spoke
“Councillor Earthey considered the property to be a rabbit hutch for humans, and they sympathised with the Ward Councillor; however, on balance they supported the application.”
Minutes, 1 Apr 2026, 15 Auckland Drive Brighton - Spoke
“Councillor Earthey considered two new homes to be good and supported the application.”
Minutes, 4 Mar 2026, Keasley House 10 Franklin Road Portslade - Asked a question
“Councillor Earthey was informed that users would change in Rockwater, and the cabins would be a sauna only.”
Minutes, 4 Mar 2026, Rockwater Kingsway Hove - Raised concerns
“Councillor Earthey expressed concerns that there were no changing areas; however, the councillor supported the application.”
Minutes, 4 Mar 2026, Rockwater Kingsway Hove
The 30 most recent of 69 are shown.
How this is worked out
Everything here is read from Brighton and Hove’s published planning committee minutes, 18 meetings from May 2025 to October 2026. A councillor is matched across meetings by the council’s own member number where it has one, otherwise by full name.
Each vote shows how it is known. Named in the minutes: the minutes, or the council’s own recorded vote, list each member with their vote. From the count and the names: the minutes give the numbers and name the members in the minority, and every member present is known. All members present in favour: the minutes say every member voted for it and the members present are known. No vote against recorded: the minutes record the decision with no vote against, no abstention and no count, at a council whose minutes print a divided vote when there is one, so each member present is counted for. Unanimous vote: the minutes call the decision unanimous, or give a count with no one against and no one abstaining, and each member present is counted for. From the meeting recording: the vote was heard on the council’s recording of the meeting and closes exactly with the members present. Where none of these holds, the vote is left as “Not recorded” and is not counted.
Votes are on the resolution the committee passed, so a vote for is a vote with the majority. A vote is a decision on the application in front of the committee, not a statement of the councillor’s views. A percentage is shown only with five or more votes, decisions or meetings behind it.
Source: Plota analysis of the council’s minutes. The party is from the council’s own list of councillors.
Also on this committee
- Tobias SheardLabour
- Carol TheobaldConservative
- Paul NannLabour
- Sam ParrottLabour
- Alison ThomsonLabour
- Joy RobinsonLabour
- Julie CattellLabour
- Sue ShanksGreen
- Kerry PickettGreen
- Maureen WinderLabour
- Josh GuilmantLabour
- Bridget FishleighIndependent
- Ivan LyonsConservative
- Liz LoughranLabour
- Raphael HillGreen
- Ty GalvinLabour