Fenland planning committee

Councillor Ian Benney

Member, Planning Committee

Seen at planning committee from August 2025 to October 2026

  • 84%attendance
  • 10agreed, no vote against recorded
  • 96decisions at their meetings
  • 26motions proposed

As at 14 October 2026, according to Plota’s analysis of Fenland’s published minutes, Councillor Ian Benney attended 16 of the 19 planning committee meetings whose minutes list them, from August 2025 to October 2026. On 10 other decisions the minutes record no vote against, so Benney is counted as agreeing; they are left out of the shares below. Benney proposed 26 motions the committee passed and seconded 9.

Meetings attended
16 of 1984%
Meetings whose minutes list them as present, sending apologies or absent. Minutes that list only those present cannot show an absence.
Decisions at their meetings
96
Applications decided at the meetings they sat on, as the minutes record them.
Agreed, no vote against recorded
10
Decisions the minutes record with no vote against and no count. Counted as agreeing, and left out of the shares.
Proposed or seconded
26 / 9
Motions the minutes say they proposed, then seconded, that the committee passed.
Declared interests
20left for 13
Decisions on which the minutes record them declaring an interest.

Voting record

The minutes we hold do not give each member's vote at these meetings, so no vote is counted for Benney and no voting chart is drawn. The minutes do name who proposed each motion.

Motions they proposed

22 of the 26 motions Benney proposed were to approve, 3 to refuse, 1 to defer.

The outcome of each motion the minutes say Benney proposed and the committee passed.

Approved 22Refused 3Deferred 1

Attendance

84%

16 of 19 meetings whose minutes list them; apologies for 3.

The typical member of this committee attended 84% (the median of 9 members listed at 5 or more meetings).

Every meeting

Each square is a meeting whose minutes list them, oldest first.

PresentApologies
20252026

Planning Committee: 16 meetings

Show as a table
Every meeting
DateCommitteeAttendance
14 Oct 2026Planning CommitteeApologies
23 Sep 2026Planning CommitteePresent
5 Aug 2026Planning CommitteePresent
22 Jul 2026Planning CommitteePresent
24 Jun 2026Planning CommitteeApologies
27 May 2026Planning CommitteePresent
29 Apr 2026Planning CommitteePresent
1 Apr 2026Planning CommitteePresent
4 Mar 2026Planning CommitteePresent
4 Feb 2026Planning CommitteePresent
21 Jan 2026Planning CommitteePresent
7 Jan 2026Planning CommitteePresent
10 Dec 2025Planning CommitteePresent
19 Nov 2025Planning CommitteeApologies
12 Nov 2025Planning CommitteePresent
15 Oct 2025Planning CommitteePresent
17 Sep 2025Planning CommitteePresent
20 Aug 2025Planning CommitteePresent
6 Aug 2025Planning CommitteePresent

Decisions

Every application decided at a meeting they sat on, newest first, with their vote where the minutes give it.

Show
Their vote
Outcome

In the minutes

What the minutes record Benney moving, seconding, asking or saying on each decision, in the minutes’ own words. Passages that name more than one councillor, or a member of the public, are left out.

Subjects in what the minutes record

  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney referred to the presentation screen which highlights a track, which is outside of the red line and members should be looking at what is inside the red line. He expressed the view that to defer this any further at the current time, and considering all the planning changes, in his opinion, it would be far better just to approve this one which is a policy compliant application.”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Land South East Of 76 Station Road Manea Cambridgeshire
  • Declared an interest
    “(Councillor Benney declared that he was not at the meeting where this application was considered previously and took no part in the discussion and voting thereon)”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, South Bank Of River Nene West End Park City Road March Cambridgeshire
  • Declared an interest
    “(Councillor Benney declared that he was not at the meeting where this application was considered previously and took no part in the discussion and voting thereon)”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, River Nene South Bank North Of Skate Park City Road March Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke on design and scale
    “Councillor Benney expressed the view that it is a complex design, and it is a big building but that adds to the beauty of it, with everything being subjective. He added that he has said many times that members want to see nice houses on the way into a town or a village as it sets the scene for that area.”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Land South Of Enfield Burrowmoor Road March Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney added that these are the types of houses that are needed in Fenland as it brings people in and businesses into the area. He added that he knows that the design is subjective, but he thinks it looks lovely and he will support it.”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Land South Of Enfield Burrowmoor Road March Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney expressed the view that there is nothing wrong with the application because there is need, it is in an agricultural area and the sequential test is irrelevant because the dwelling will not be built anywhere else and it needs to be built where the need is.”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Land South Of Gage Villa Sixteen Foot Bank Stonea Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney explained that this application is different to the others which have been determined when considering sequential tests and legal agreements as, in his view, this is more favourable than those two and he sees no reason for this not to be approved today and it would be a travesty if it was refused.”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Land South Of Gage Villa Sixteen Foot Bank Stonea Cambridgeshire
  • Declared an interest
    “(Councillor Benney declared that he was previously Portfolio Holder for Assets but did not work on this actual application and is not pre-determined and will consider the application with an open mind)”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Site Of Former 11 - 12 High Street Wisbech Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke on flooding and drainage
    “Councillor Benney added that he has sympathy for this application, and he recognises the need for this, but he has also seen the report from the Planning Inspector regarding the appeal, with the Inspector being very clear with regards to caravans in Flood Zone 3 and it is only for that reason that he will support the officer’s recommendation.”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Land North Of 486 High Road Newton-in-the-isle
  • Seconded
    “Proposed by Councillor Mrs French, seconded by Councillor Benney and agreed that the application be REFUSED as per the officer’s recommendation.”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Land North Of 486 High Road Newton-in-the-isle
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney stated that when he visited the site, he looked further along and saw that there is development and that is not all linear.”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Land To The East Of 114 Main Road Parson Drove Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney added that the application is not taking it beyond the edge of the village and, in his view, it is filling in that little gap.”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Land To The East Of 114 Main Road Parson Drove Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney stated that consideration has to be given as to whether it makes good use of land and, in his view, there is the need for houses.”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Land To The East Of 114 Main Road Parson Drove Cambridgeshire
  • Moved approval
    “Proposed by Councillor Benney, seconded by Councillor Marks and agreed that the application be GRANTED against officer’s recommendation, with authority delegated to officers to apply conditions.”
    Minutes, 23 Sep 2026, Land To The East Of 114 Main Road Parson Drove Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney stated that Manea Parish Council have stated that they would like £2,000 per unit for this application and he asked officers whether the application is subject to Section 106 contributions as, in his opinion, contributions are for 10 houses and above but he has seen much speculation online that it is five units and he asked for clarity.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, 27B Westfield Road Manea March Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney stated that he would like confirmation that what members have been advised and have received training on means that they are adhering to policy.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, 27B Westfield Road Manea March Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney stated that there is a big misconception as to how Section 106 works and the Head of Planning has now confirmed that the committee have been adhering to policy, which has now been clarified quite clearly.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, 27B Westfield Road Manea March Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney expressed the opinion that this is a policy compliant scheme and the officer’s recommendation is correct.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, 27B Westfield Road Manea March Cambridgeshire
  • Declared an interest
    “(Councillor Benney declared that the agent has undertaken work for Chatteris Town Council and himself personally, but he is not pre-determined and will consider the application with an open mind)”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Land South Of Lavender Mill Close Fallow Corner Drove Manea
  • Declared an interest
    “(Councillor Benney declared that the agent has undertaken work for Chatteris Town Council and himself personally, but he is not pre-determined and will consider the application with an open mind)”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Land East Of 1 Doddington Road Accessed From Bell Gardens Wimblington Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney stated that this this is not in his ward, but when this came to the committee before he did support the application and his opinion has not changed. He made the point that this is a PE16 postcode, which is part of Chatteris, and he knows a number of people who live there, and they are Chatteris people in the main.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Garden Land At Honeybank Second Drove Swingbrow Chatteris Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney stated that he has lived in Chatteris all his life and the road was known to be an accident black spot, but there were unusual circumstances with some of the fatalities, with speeding of vehicles being a contributing factor.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Garden Land At Honeybank Second Drove Swingbrow Chatteris Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke on trees and wildlife
    “Councillor Benney expressed the view that it is harder actually coming out of the main road onto Swingbrow because there are bushes and trees hiding that when you come along but he believes that the visibility splays for Swingbrow are more than adequate.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Garden Land At Honeybank Second Drove Swingbrow Chatteris Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke on highway safety
    “Councillor Benney made reference to the 40-foot bank where there have been traffic lights implemented for a year and, in his opinion, the County Council appear to have forgotten Chatteris and the outstanding and unfinished roadworks.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Garden Land At Honeybank Second Drove Swingbrow Chatteris Cambridgeshire
  • Moved approval
    “Proposed by Councillor Benney, seconded by Councillor Marks and agreed that the application be APPROVED against the officer’s recommendation.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Garden Land At Honeybank Second Drove Swingbrow Chatteris Cambridgeshire
  • Declared an interest
    “(Councillor Benney declared, in accordance with Paragraph 14 of the Code of Conduct on Planning Matters, that he is a member of Chatteris Town Council but takes no part in planning)”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Garden Land At Honeybank Second Drove Swingbrow Chatteris Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney stated that last time he abstained from the vote as he did not feel he was able to reach an informed decision but following the meeting he undertook some research and ascertained that the application had actually been deferred previously before it came before the committee and it was approved.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Land East Of March Airfield Cross Road March Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke
    “Councillor Benney stated that he was not on the committee when the application was first discussed.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Land East Of March Airfield Cross Road March Cambridgeshire
  • Asked a question
    “Councillor Benney questioned why officers did not highlight the lack of sports facilities when the application came before the committee six months ago?”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Land East Of March Airfield Cross Road March Cambridgeshire
  • Spoke on highway safety
    “Councillor Benney stated that the traffic report was produced in 2021 and the traffic numbers dropped dramatically in 2020/21 due to Covid, with the traffic levels now above pre-Covid and in 2021 it is a figure that they have used within Cambridgeshire of 254.4 vehicle movements which is now increased up to 292.6 vehicle movements in 2025.”
    Minutes, 5 Aug 2026, Land East Of March Airfield Cross Road March Cambridgeshire

The 30 most recent of 265 are shown.

How this is worked out

Everything here is read from Fenland’s published planning committee minutes, 19 meetings from August 2025 to October 2026. A councillor is matched across meetings by the council’s own member number where it has one, otherwise by full name.

Each vote shows how it is known. Named in the minutes: the minutes, or the council’s own recorded vote, list each member with their vote. From the count and the names: the minutes give the numbers and name the members in the minority, and every member present is known. All members present in favour: the minutes say every member voted for it and the members present are known. No vote against recorded: the minutes record the decision with no vote against, no abstention and no count, at a council whose minutes print a divided vote when there is one, so each member present is counted for. Unanimous vote: the minutes call the decision unanimous, or give a count with no one against and no one abstaining, and each member present is counted for. From the meeting recording: the vote was heard on the council’s recording of the meeting and closes exactly with the members present. Where none of these holds, the vote is left as “Not recorded” and is not counted.

Votes are on the resolution the committee passed, so a vote for is a vote with the majority. A vote is a decision on the application in front of the committee, not a statement of the councillor’s views. A percentage is shown only with five or more votes, decisions or meetings behind it.

Source: Plota analysis of the council’s minutes. The party is from the council’s own list of councillors.

Also on this committee

All Fenland committee councillors