Fenland planning committee
Councillor Roy Gerstner
IndependentSeen at planning committee from August 2025 to October 2026
- 53%attendance
- 7agreed, no vote against recorded
- 55decisions at their meetings
- 4motions proposed
As at 14 October 2026, according to Plota’s analysis of Fenland’s published minutes, Councillor Roy Gerstner attended 10 of the 19 planning committee meetings whose minutes list them, from August 2025 to October 2026. On 7 other decisions the minutes record no vote against, so Gerstner is counted as agreeing; they are left out of the shares below. Gerstner proposed 4 motions the committee passed and seconded 3.
- Meetings attended
- 10 of 1953%
- Meetings whose minutes list them as present, sending apologies or absent. Minutes that list only those present cannot show an absence.
- Decisions at their meetings
- 55
- Applications decided at the meetings they sat on, as the minutes record them.
- Agreed, no vote against recorded
- 7
- Decisions the minutes record with no vote against and no count. Counted as agreeing, and left out of the shares.
- Proposed or seconded
- 4 / 3
- Motions the minutes say they proposed, then seconded, that the committee passed.
- Declared interests
- 1
- Decisions on which the minutes record them declaring an interest.
Voting record
The minutes we hold do not give each member's vote at these meetings, so no vote is counted for Gerstner and no voting chart is drawn. The minutes do name who proposed each motion.
Motions they proposed
2 of the 4 motions Gerstner proposed were to approve, 2 to refuse.
The outcome of each motion the minutes say Gerstner proposed and the committee passed.
Attendance
53%
10 of 19 meetings whose minutes list them; apologies for 9.
The typical member of this committee attended 84% (the median of 9 members listed at 5 or more meetings).
Every meeting
Each square is a meeting whose minutes list them, oldest first.
Planning Committee: 10 meetings
Show as a table
| Date | Committee | Attendance |
|---|---|---|
| 14 Oct 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 23 Sep 2026 | Planning Committee | Apologies |
| 5 Aug 2026 | Planning Committee | Apologies |
| 22 Jul 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 24 Jun 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 27 May 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 29 Apr 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 1 Apr 2026 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 4 Mar 2026 | Planning Committee | Apologies |
| 4 Feb 2026 | Planning Committee | Apologies |
| 21 Jan 2026 | Planning Committee | Apologies |
| 7 Jan 2026 | Planning Committee | Apologies |
| 10 Dec 2025 | Planning Committee | Apologies |
| 19 Nov 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 12 Nov 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 15 Oct 2025 | Planning Committee | Apologies |
| 17 Sep 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 20 Aug 2025 | Planning Committee | Present |
| 6 Aug 2025 | Planning Committee | Apologies |
Decisions
Every application decided at a meeting they sat on, newest first, with their vote where the minutes give it.
- Land North Of 88A Station Road Manea CambridgeshireUp to nine homes · F/YR26/0498/PIP ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North West Of Wheelhead Farm Turf Fen Lane Doddington CambridgeshireFour dwellings · F/YR26/0490/PIPProposed the motion Refused Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land East Of 13B Bridge Street Chatteris Cambridgeshire9 dwellings · F/YR26/0056/RM Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Site Of Former Colvile County Primary School Church Lane Newton-in-the-isle CambridgeshireSix dwellings · F/YR26/0012/O Approved ForNo vote against recorded
- Land South East Of Manor Farm 344 Main Road Church End Parson Drove Cambridgeshire20-pitch campsite · F/YR26/0011/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land South Of Silverback Kennels Silverback Cottage Whitemoor Road March CambridgeshireOne self-build dwelling · F/YR26/0148/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Garage Site At 87 High Road Gorefield CambridgeshireThree-bedroom dwelling · F/YR26/0464/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Holly Cottage The Chase March CambridgeshireReplacement self-build dwelling · F/YR26/0566/FDL Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land West Of 37 Brewin Avenue March CambridgeshireTwo dwellings · F/YR26/0561/FDCSeconded the motion Refused Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 6 Orchard Close Leverington Wisbech CambridgeshireRoof height variation · F/YR26/0616/VOC Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North Of The Quadrant Primrose Hill Doddington CambridgeshireTwo dwellings · F/YR25/0730/PIP Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land South Of 29 Primrose Hill Doddington CambridgeshireTwo dwellings · F/YR25/0726/PIP Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 63A - 65 Wisbech Road March CambridgeshireShopfront alterations · F/YR26/0222/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North Of Cherrytree House Fallow Corner Drove ManeaFive detached dwellings · F/YR26/0220/F Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land South Of 85 - 95 Knights End Road March CambridgeshireTwo dwellings · F/YR26/0147/OProposed the motion Refused Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Plot 4 Land South Of Field View Mill Hill Lane March CambridgeshireSix-bedroom self-build dwelling · F/YR26/0043/F Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- River Nene South Bank North Of Skate Park City Road March Cambridgeshire15 angling platforms · F/YR25/0810/FDL Deferred Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- South Bank Of River Nene West End Park City Road March Cambridgeshire15 angling platforms · F/YR25/0724/FDL Deferred Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land East Of Highland View Benwick Road Doddington CambridgeshireTwo four-bedroom homes · F/YR23/0115/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land East Of 24 Eastmoor Lane Doddington CambridgeshireFour dwellings · F/YR26/0176/PIPProposed the motion ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Manor Leisure Centre Station Road Whittlesey Peterborough CambridgeshireLeisure centre redevelopment · F/YR26/0179/FDCProposed the motion · Declared an interest Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Somers Court Somers Road Wisbech Cambridgeshire49 retirement flats · F/YR25/0707/F Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 1 - 3 Commercial Road March CambridgeshireInPost locker · F/YR25/0932/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land East Of 190 Wype Road Eastrea CambridgeshireTwo dwellings · F/YR26/0196/PIP ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land West Of 16 Bridge Lane Wimblington CambridgeshireUp to 9 homes · F/YR26/0100/PIP Refused For refusalNo vote against recorded
- Cedar Rose Stables Horsemoor Road Wimblington CambridgeshireSix traveller pitches · F/YR25/0527/F Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land South East Of Ferry Farm London Road Accessed Off Stocking Drove Chatteris CambridgeshireUp to five dwellings · F/YR25/0752/PIP ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land South Of Woodlands 20D Primrose Hill Doddington CambridgeshireTwo self-build homes · F/YR25/0937/PIP Deferred Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North Of Waltoria House Gote Lane Gorefield CambridgeshireTwo self-build homes · F/YR26/0090/O ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Willow View The Chase March CambridgeshireReplacement self-build dwelling · F/YR26/0123/F Refused Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North Of The Chestnuts Roman Bank Newton-in-the-isle CambridgeshireOne self-build dwelling · F/YR25/0967/O ApprovedAgainst officer advice ForUnanimous vote
- Gaultree Farm High Road Guyhirn Wisbech CambridgeshireFour dwellings · F/YR25/0925/F Refused Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North Of Sorrento Fen Road Newton-in-the-isle CambridgeshireDog exercise paddock · F/YR25/0907/F RefusedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land South West Of Woodbury Manea Road Wimblington CambridgeshireThree dwellings · F/YR26/0004/PIPSeconded the motion Refused Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North West Of 16 Westfield Road Manea CambridgeshireUp to nine homes · F/YR25/0957/PIP Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land South Of 88 West Street Chatteris Cambridgeshire21 homes · F/YR23/1033/F Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Land West Of Playing Field Barton Road Wisbech Cambridgeshire42 affordable bungalows · F/YR25/0274/F Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Nene Parade Bedford Street Chase Street Wisbech Cambridgeshire70-apartment extra care facility · F/YR25/0520/RM Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 49 Whittlesey Road March Cambridgeshire12 light industrial units · F/YR25/0526/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land West Of Burnlea House Wimblington Road Manea CambridgeshireSelf-build home and business shed · F/YR25/0698/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land South Of Wenny House Iretons Way Chatteris CambridgeshireDog exercise areas · F/YR25/0530/F Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North Of 1 Gull Road Guyhirn CambridgeshireSix affordable homes · F/YR25/0547/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 222 Lynn Road Wisbech CambridgeshireEight homes · F/YR25/0609/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North Of 96A To 100 Westfield Road Manea CambridgeshireAccess road alteration · F/YR25/0405/VOC Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 28 Broad Street March CambridgeshireIlluminated barber signage · F/YR25/0591/A ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land To The West Of Horseway Farm Byall Fen Drove Manea CambridgeshireAgricultural storage building · F/YR25/0416/F Approved ForNo vote against recorded
- 8 Bramble Walk March CambridgeshireHome extensions · F/YR25/0499/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 46 Elwyndene Road March CambridgeshireGarage annexe · F/YR25/0454/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North East Of 93 Dartford Road March CambridgeshireOne-bedroom bungalow · F/YR25/0396/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Garages At River Drive March CambridgeshireOne self-build dwelling · F/YR25/0404/F Deferred Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Sharman Fabrications Gaul Farm Gaul Road March CambridgeshireDwelling and storage shed · F/YR25/0156/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land North And West Of 47 Fridaybridge Road ElmTen-home residential development · F/YR25/0280/VOC Approved ForNo vote against recorded
- Land South Of 4 - 16 Back Road Gorefield CambridgeshireUp to nine dwellings · F/YR25/0473/O Approved ForNo vote against recorded
- 2 Broad Street March CambridgeshireDemolition and fencing · F/YR25/0149/FDCSeconded the motion ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- 108 High Street March CambridgeshireOne custom-build dwelling · F/YR25/0328/F ApprovedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
No decision matches these filters.
In the minutes
What the minutes record Gerstner moving, seconding, asking or saying on each decision, in the minutes’ own words. Passages that name more than one councillor, or a member of the public, are left out.
Subjects in what the minutes record
- Neighbours and amenity29 Apr 2026, 17 Sep 2025, 14 Oct 2026
- Parking and traffic24 Jun 2026
- Housing need and affordable homes27 May 2026
- Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner expressed the opinion that it is somewhat disappointing that Building Control have not been in touch with the objector and asked if this can be accelerated?”
Minutes, 14 Oct 2026, 6 Orchard Close Leverington Wisbech Cambridgeshire - Asked a question
“Councillor Gerstner asked for an explanation on how this is going to be achieved?”
Minutes, 14 Oct 2026, Land West Of 37 Brewin Avenue March Cambridgeshire - Spoke on neighbours' amenity
“Councillor Gerstner stated that he will ask officers to confirm what the amount of amenity space that is available.”
Minutes, 14 Oct 2026, Land West Of 37 Brewin Avenue March Cambridgeshire - Seconded
“Proposed by Councillor Mrs French, seconded by Councillor Gerstner that the application be refused as per officer’s recommendation, which was not supported on a vote by the majority of members.”
Minutes, 14 Oct 2026, Land West Of 37 Brewin Avenue March Cambridgeshire - Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner stated 30 years ago.”
Minutes, 14 Oct 2026, Site Of Former Colvile County Primary School Church Lane Newton-in-the-isle Cambridgeshire - Asked a question
“Councillor Gerstner asked if there is a problem with refuse lorries transversing unadopted roads?”
Minutes, 14 Oct 2026, Land East Of 13B Bridge Street Chatteris Cambridgeshire - Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner stated that it is known of his views of building on agricultural land and the Council now has a policy in place regarding the loss of Grade 1 or 2 agricultural land. He made the point that members are looking at what is in front of them and it would be wrong to speculate on how this site may be expanded in the future.”
Minutes, 14 Oct 2026, Land North West Of Wheelhead Farm Turf Fen Lane Doddington Cambridgeshire - Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner stated that he cannot support this application and will go with the officer’s recommendation.”
Minutes, 14 Oct 2026, Land North West Of Wheelhead Farm Turf Fen Lane Doddington Cambridgeshire - Moved refusal
“Proposed by Councillor Gerstner, seconded by Councillor Mrs French and agreed that the application be REFUSED as per officer’s recommendation.”
Minutes, 14 Oct 2026, Land North West Of Wheelhead Farm Turf Fen Lane Doddington Cambridgeshire - Declared an interest
“(Councillor Gerstner declared, in accordance with Paragraph 2 of the Code of Conduct on Planning Matters, that he had been lobbied on this application)”
Minutes, 14 Oct 2026, Land North West Of Wheelhead Farm Turf Fen Lane Doddington Cambridgeshire - Asked a question
“Councillor Gerstner asked if the land was being farmed and an indicative idea of how long the field has been agricultural?”
Minutes, 14 Oct 2026, Land North Of 88A Station Road Manea Cambridgeshire - Moved refusal
“Proposed by Councillor Gerstner, seconded by Councillor Mrs French and agreed that the application be REFUSED as per officer’s recommendation.”
Minutes, 22 Jul 2026, Land South Of 85 - 95 Knights End Road March Cambridgeshire - Asked a question
“Councillor Gerstner asked for confirmation that these properties will have solar panels and heat pumps?”
Minutes, 22 Jul 2026, Land North Of Cherrytree House Fallow Corner Drove Manea - Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner stated that as there are only three disabled bays, would consideration be given to including more disabled spaces bearing in mind the number of elderly people that will be living there?”
Minutes, 24 Jun 2026, Somers Court Somers Road Wisbech Cambridgeshire - Spoke on parking
“Councillor Gerstner stated that car park spaces over the years have got smaller and many small cars have got much larger, with disabled people needing more space to get out and, in his opinion, three disabled car park spaces is not enough, with the applicant kindly saying that they would consider introducing more spaces.”
Minutes, 24 Jun 2026, Somers Court Somers Road Wisbech Cambridgeshire - Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner stated that the current swimming pool opened on the 1 May 1966, and whilst it has been a fantastic facility for Whittlesey over the years, it is now becoming rather an old and tired facility and the proposed new facility is a once in a lifetime opportunity for Whittlesey and Fenland as a whole to invest in the town.”
Minutes, 24 Jun 2026, Manor Leisure Centre Station Road Whittlesey Peterborough Cambridgeshire - Moved approval
“Proposed by Councillor Gerstner, seconded by Councillor Mrs French and agreed that the application be GRANTED as per the officer’s recommendation.”
Minutes, 24 Jun 2026, Manor Leisure Centre Station Road Whittlesey Peterborough Cambridgeshire - Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner added that he has not been lobbied on the application and will consider the application with an open mind and is not predetermined.”
Minutes, 24 Jun 2026, Manor Leisure Centre Station Road Whittlesey Peterborough Cambridgeshire - Moved approval
“Proposed by Councillor Gerstner, seconded by Councillor Marks and agreed that the application be APPROVED against the officer’s recommendation.”
Minutes, 24 Jun 2026, Land East Of 24 Eastmoor Lane Doddington Cambridgeshire - Asked a question
“Councillor Gerstner asked whether the land is used at the current time or is it just a spinney or a wood and he questioned whether it is used for any other reason?”
Minutes, 24 Jun 2026, Land East Of Highland View Benwick Road Doddington Cambridgeshire - Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner stated that there are some fishing platforms in Whittlesey and the land is owned by the Council, but the structure partially goes into the river which is where MLC are involved.”
Minutes, 24 Jun 2026, South Bank Of River Nene West End Park City Road March Cambridgeshire - Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner stated that on the negative side, there is some conflict of interest in maintaining these platforms as one piece of grass must not fall in the river because that conflicts with MLC putting anything into the river so maintenance is a major issue.”
Minutes, 24 Jun 2026, South Bank Of River Nene West End Park City Road March Cambridgeshire - Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner referred to the comments at 4.7 of the officer’s report from MLC and there is quite a lot of questions that they are asking the applicant so it is for the applicant to address this with the MLC as they are the one that need satisfying and once MLC are satisfied then members would be in a much better position to approve this application.”
Minutes, 24 Jun 2026, South Bank Of River Nene West End Park City Road March Cambridgeshire - Spoke on the conditions
“Councillor Gerstner stated that even if this was approved today, these platforms would not be installed this year as there are too many conditions to be complied with through MLC and he believes it will be 12 months of negotiations.”
Minutes, 24 Jun 2026, River Nene South Bank North Of Skate Park City Road March Cambridgeshire - Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner stated that Eastrea is a lovely little village and it needs development, with the dwellings being built along here being quality developments. He stated that his concern has always been the use of land, which is good agricultural land that is being built upon.”
Minutes, 27 May 2026, Land East Of 190 Wype Road Eastrea Cambridgeshire - Declared an interest
“(Councillor Gerstner declared, in accordance with Paragraph 14 of the Code of Conduct on Planning Matters, that he is a member of Whittlesey Town Council but takes no part in planning)”
Minutes, 27 May 2026, Land East Of 190 Wype Road Eastrea Cambridgeshire - Asked about highway safety
“Councillor Gerstner asked what the speed limit is on the road?”
Minutes, 27 May 2026, 1 - 3 Commercial Road March Cambridgeshire - Asked a question
“Councillor Gerstner asked how long this locker has been in place?”
Minutes, 27 May 2026, 1 - 3 Commercial Road March Cambridgeshire - Spoke
“Councillor Gerstner noted that the report referred to objections from residents in The Chase but also a comment in favour from a resident of The Chase and asked whether there was a balance in the local views.”
Minutes, 29 Apr 2026, Willow View The Chase March Cambridgeshire - Asked a question
“Councillor Gerstner asked where the applicants were living at present?”
Minutes, 29 Apr 2026, Land North Of Waltoria House Gote Lane Gorefield Cambridgeshire
The 30 most recent of 50 are shown.
How this is worked out
Everything here is read from Fenland’s published planning committee minutes, 19 meetings from August 2025 to October 2026. A councillor is matched across meetings by the council’s own member number where it has one, otherwise by full name.
Each vote shows how it is known. Named in the minutes: the minutes, or the council’s own recorded vote, list each member with their vote. From the count and the names: the minutes give the numbers and name the members in the minority, and every member present is known. All members present in favour: the minutes say every member voted for it and the members present are known. No vote against recorded: the minutes record the decision with no vote against, no abstention and no count, at a council whose minutes print a divided vote when there is one, so each member present is counted for. Unanimous vote: the minutes call the decision unanimous, or give a count with no one against and no one abstaining, and each member present is counted for. From the meeting recording: the vote was heard on the council’s recording of the meeting and closes exactly with the members present. Where none of these holds, the vote is left as “Not recorded” and is not counted.
Votes are on the resolution the committee passed, so a vote for is a vote with the majority. A vote is a decision on the application in front of the committee, not a statement of the councillor’s views. A percentage is shown only with five or more votes, decisions or meetings behind it.
Source: Plota analysis of the council’s minutes. The party is from the council’s own list of councillors.
Also on this committee
- Charlie MarksConservative
- Jan FrenchConservative
- David ConnorConservative
- Ian BenneyConservative
- Sidney ImafidonConservative
- Mark PurserConservative
- Peter MurphyConservative
- Nick MeekinsConservative
- Billy RackleyConservative
- Elisabeth Sennitt CloughConservative