Five traveller plots at Land North Of 486 High Road, Newton-in-the-Isle
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Fenland Planning Committee on 23 Sept 2026.
What was proposed
The application sought five traveller plots with five mobile homes, five dayrooms and a new access from High Road.
“Agent: [name withheld] Design Land North Of 486, High Road, Newton-in-the-isle…”
“Change of use of land to 5 x gypsy traveller's plots involving the siting of 5 x mobile homes, erection of 5 dayrooms, and the formation of an access…”
Officer report
The site and surroundings
The undeveloped paddock lies outside the settlement, between a water tower and a home, in open countryside and mainly Flood Zone 2.
“The application site is located on land North of 486 High Road, Newton-in-the-isle. The site currently comprises an undeveloped paddock area and is located between a water tower to the north, and a residential property to the south. The site is located approximately 400m north of the edge of the settlement of Newton. The surrounding area is largely open and undeveloped countryside.”
“The site lies predominantly in Flood Zone 2, with a small portion of the northern end of the site falling within Flood Zone 3.”
Officer report
Earlier site history
There was no relevant planning history for the site.
“There is no site history relevant to the determination of the application.”
Officer report
What officers recommended
Officers considered the principle acceptable because the proposal would contribute to the district’s traveller-pitch need, but recommended refusal because of landscape and flood-risk harm.
“The proposal is considered to be acceptable in principle by contributing towards meeting the identified need for gypsy and traveller sites in the district.”
“Further, the site is located within Flood Zones 2 and 3 where Government guidance is clear, in the NPPF (2026), that caravans should not be used for residential accommodation in flood zones. This guidance is significantly different to what was present before and at the time of the application being submitted.”
Officer report
Consultation responses
The Environment Agency, environmental health and highways raised no objection subject to mitigation or a gate condition.
“No objection subject to mitigation measures set out in submitted Flood Risk Assessment…”
“Following the submission of additional traffic speed survey data, no objections to the proposal, subject to a condition ensuring gates are set back from the edge of the carriageway by 10m.”
Officer report
What people said
Fifty-two objections cited countryside, services, character, flooding, highway and site-capacity concerns, while fifteen supporters cited traveller-accommodation need.
“Objecting Comments Officer Response Poor condition of public highway serving site See ‘Parking Provision and Highway Safety’ Site in open countryside See ‘Character and appearance’ Inadequate services and facilities to accommodate development See ‘Principle of Development’ Detrimental to character and appearance of area See ‘Character and appearance’ Site located in flood zone 3 and fails sequential and exception test See ‘Flood Risk and Drainage’ Site too small to…”
“Supporting Comments Officer Response Proposal addresses need for gypsy accommodation in the area See ‘Principle of Development…”
Officer report
Who spoke
An objector, the agent and the applicant addressed the committee, discussing consultation, covenants, flood risk, policy, family needs and the site’s effects.
The vote
The committee agreed a proposal to refuse the application in accordance with the officer recommendation.
“Proposed by Councillor Mrs French, seconded by Councillor Benney and agreed that the application be REFUSED as per the officer’s recommendation.”
Minutes
The decision and reasons
The application was refused because the development would harm countryside character and had not passed the required flood-risk tests.
“The proposed development, by virtue of its nature, scale, form, and overtly domestic appearance, would introduce a visually intrusive and incongruous feature into the open countryside. The design and massing fail to respond sensitively to the rural context or reflect the local vernacular, resulting in the domestication and erosion of the area's open and rural character.”
“Policy LP14 of the Fenland Local Plan 2014 and Policy F4 of the National Planning Policy Framework state that all development should adopt a sequential approach to flood risk from all forms of flooding. Development in areas known to be at risk of flooding will only be permitted following the successful completion of a sequential test and exception test as necessary. The sequential test has not been passed.”
Officer report
Why the committee refused
Members relied on the new policy position and appeal outcome concerning caravans in Flood Zones 2 and 3, despite sympathy for the applicants.
“Councillor Connor drew members attention to the officer’s report, making the point that a Planning Inspector overturned a decision recently which was made by the Council where the applicant wanted a condition removing from a decision which the Council made several months ago, however, on 26 August the National Planning Policy Framework changed, and not only did the Inspector disagree with the appeal, it also dismissed the whole of the approval and members need to be…”
“Councillor Benney added that he has sympathy for this application, and he recognises the need for this, but he has also seen the report from the Planning Inspector regarding the appeal, with the Inspector being very clear with regards to caravans in Flood Zone 3 and it is only for that reason that he will support the officer’s recommendation. He added that the policy is quite definitive and is a new change in policy and for this reason it is the right decision.”
Minutes
Councillors at the meeting
- David ConnorChairConservative
- Charlie MarksVice-ChairConservative
- Ian BenneyConservative
- Jan FrenchConservative
- Sidney ImafidonConservative
- Peter MurphySubstituteConservative
Proposed by Councillor Jan French, seconded by Councillor Ian Benney.
Apologies Roy Gerstner Independent, Mark Purser Conservative
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Fenland Planning Committee minutes, 23 September 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Fenland's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Committee
- Fenland Planning Committee
- Council
- Fenland
- Date
- Wednesday 23 September 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended refusal
- Committee decided
- Refused
- Vote
- Unanimous
- Councillors
- 6Conservative 6Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Fenland committee decisions →
This committee's year
100 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 44 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.