5 Montague Street Edinburgh EH8 9QT Data via plota.co.uk
Proposal
Change of use from flat (sui generis) to short-term let (sui generis) and to replace the windows to the front and rear of the property. Data via plota.co.uk
Application progress
Refused on 19 Nov 2026 · Local Delegated Decision · Last checked 20 Nov 2026
Documents 17
Decision & officer reports 1
Statements & assessments 1
Plans & drawings 1
Application forms 1
Consultation & comments 11
Site constraints 3
Show the other 18 with distances
- 12 m7, 9, 11 Montague Street, EdinburghGrade B
- 41 m5, 7, 9 Rankeillor Street, EdinburghGrade B
- 56 m11, 13, 15, 17, 19 South Clerk Street, EdinburghGrade C
- 83 m8, 10, 12 Rankeillor Street, EdinburghGrade B
- 83 m40, 42, 44 Clerk Street, EdinburghGrade B
- 83 mThe Queen's Hall, South Clerk Street, EdinburghGrade A
- 85 m2 South Clerk Street, EdinburghGrade B
- 113 m6, 7, 8 Hope Park Crescent, EdinburghGrade B
- 129 m10, 12, 14, 16, 18 Clerk Street, EdinburghGrade B
- 131 m31 South Clerk Street, EdinburghGrade C
- 134 m12, 14, 16 South Clerk Street, EdinburghGrade C
- 139 m1, 3, 5 Hope Park Terrace, EdinburghGrade B
- 140 mHope Park And Buccleuch Congregational Church, Hope Park Terrace, EdinburghGrade B
- 143 mOdeon Cinema, 7 Clerk Street, EdinburghGrade A
- 147 m130 Buccleuch Street, EdinburghGrade B
- 147 m1, 3, 5 Clerk Street, EdinburghGrade B
- 149 m124 Buccleuch Street, EdinburghGrade B
- 150 m105 Buccleuch Street, EdinburghGrade C
Checked on 2 November 2026. Historic England, the Environment Agency, Natural England and council datasets, Open Government Licence. A boundary can run through a site and the council holds the definitive record: confirm with the council before relying on this.
Every application in Edinburgh - and every UK council - as a live feed, an API, or a bulk CSV export.
Other new applications on this street
Nearby new applications
2F1 7 Rankeillor Street Newington Edinburgh EH8 9JA
Replacement of existing sash windows with new sash windows, custom-fitted with v...
17 St Patrick Square Newington Edinburgh EH8 9EZ
Advertisement of the following types: illuminated fascia box sign and non-illumi...
26 Blacket Place Edinburgh EH9 1RL
Apple tree approx 8 metres, some decay, remove to ground level.
42 Rankeillor Street Newington Edinburgh EH8 9HZ
T1 birch reduction: remove lowest sizeable limb that is interfering with phone w...
20 St Catherine's Place Edinburgh EH9 1NU
Willow tree, full removal of one willow tree including stump.
2F1 44 Rankeillor Street Edinburgh EH8 9HZ
Replacement of existing single glazed windows with look-alike sash and case heri...
Important details
- Council
- Edinburgh
- Application type
- Planning Permission STL
- Postcode
- EH8 9QT
- Received
- 29 Dec 2025
- Validated
- 28 Jan 2026
- Ward
- Southside/Newington
- Parish
- Southside
- Case officer
- Show
- Target decision
- 27 Mar 2026
- Decision
- Refused
- Decision date
- 19 Nov 2026
- Decision level
- Local Delegated Decision
- Applicant
- Show
- Agent
- REM Associates.
How this decision compares
Decided in 295 days from validation, 218 days slower than Edinburgh's median of 77 for changes of use. Refused, as 49% of changes of use here are.
Plota live figures for changes of use decided by Edinburgh in the last twelve months, from validation. Edinburgh decision record →
Public comments
100% object · above the UK average of 74%
97 neighbours consulted · Last counted 20 Nov 2026
Consultation & key dates
- Comments by
- 2 Mar 2026
- Statutory expiry
- 27 Mar 2026
- Env. assessment
- No
Historical activity at this location
25 nearby applications on record - archival context, not part of the live application.
Nearby activity
Track this application
5 Montague Street Edinburgh EH8 9QT
Tracking this application
Not there after a minute? Check your junk folder. It's from alerts@plota.co.uk.
Go to your dashboard →Sign in to view contact details
Applicant and case-officer names are hidden from public view for privacy. Create a free Plota account - or sign back in - and we'll show them, plus you get a dashboard for alerts and tracked applications.