
Derbyshire Dales planning committee
Councillor Neil Buttle
GreenSeen at planning committee from September 2025 to September 2026
- 100%attendance
- 6recorded votes
- 17agreed, no vote against recorded
- 100%with the majority
- 0%against officer advice
As at 13 October 2026, according to Plota’s analysis of Derbyshire Dales’s published minutes, Councillor Neil Buttle attended 9 of the 9 planning committee meetings whose minutes list them, from September 2025 to September 2026. Each member's vote is recorded on 6 decisions at those meetings: Buttle voted for the resolution on all 6. On 6 of those votes the officers’ recommendation is known, and none went against it. On 17 other decisions the minutes record no vote against, so Buttle is counted as agreeing; they are left out of the shares below. Buttle proposed 6 motions the committee passed and seconded 3.
- Meetings attended
- 9 of 9100%
- Meetings whose minutes list them as present, sending apologies or absent. Minutes that list only those present cannot show an absence. 9 meetings as a substitute.
- Decisions at their meetings
- 30
- Applications decided at the meetings they sat on, as the minutes record them.
- Recorded votes
- 6
- Decisions where the minutes, the council's recorded vote or the meeting's recording give each member's vote: 6 for, 0 against, 0 abstained.
- With the majority
- 6 of 6100%
- Votes for the resolution the committee passed. An abstention is not counted as with the majority.
- Agreed, no vote against recorded
- 17
- Decisions the minutes record with no vote against and no count. Counted as agreeing, and left out of the shares.
- Votes against officer advice
- 0 of 60%
- Recorded votes where the officers’ recommendation is known: for a resolution that went against it, or against one that followed it.
- Proposed or seconded
- 6 / 3
- Motions the minutes say they proposed, then seconded, that the committee passed.
- Declared interests
- 1
- Decisions on which the minutes record them declaring an interest.
Voting record
Votes by quarter
For the resolution on all 6 recorded votes; the most in Q1 2026 (2).
6 recorded votes, by the quarter of the meeting.
Show as a table
| Quarter | For | Against | Abstained |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q3 2025 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Q4 2025 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Q1 2026 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| Q2 2026 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
Against officer advice
Buttle went against officer advice less often than the committee: 0% of votes, against 15% of decisions.
The share that went against the officers’ recommendation.
The typical member of this committee (the median of 12 members with 5 or more such votes) voted against officer advice on 9% of them.
Agreement with other members
Not drawn: the minutes record no divided vote of this councillor by name. On a unanimous vote every member agrees, so it says nothing about agreement.
Motions they proposed
3 of the 6 motions Buttle proposed were to approve, 2 to refuse, 1 to defer.
The outcome of each motion the minutes say Buttle proposed and the committee passed.
Attendance
100%
9 of 9 meetings whose minutes list them.
The typical member of this committee attended 89% (the median of 14 members listed at 5 or more meetings).
Every meeting
Each square is a meeting whose minutes list them, oldest first.
Planning Committee: 9 meetings
Show as a table
| Date | Committee | Attendance |
|---|---|---|
| 29 Sep 2026 | Planning Committee | Present as a substitute |
| 8 Sep 2026 | Planning Committee | Present as a substitute |
| 14 Jul 2026 | Planning Committee | Present as a substitute |
| 12 May 2026 | Planning Committee | Present as a substitute |
| 10 Mar 2026 | Planning Committee | Present as a substitute |
| 13 Jan 2026 | Planning Committee | Present as a substitute |
| 11 Nov 2025 | Planning Committee | Present as a substitute |
| 30 Sep 2025 | Planning Committee | Present as a substitute |
| 9 Sep 2025 | Planning Committee | Present as a substitute |
Decisions
Every application decided at a meeting they sat on, newest first, with their vote where the minutes give it.
- Land West Of Foxholes Lane Tansley DerbyshireTraveller site · 25/00665/FUL Refused For refusalUnanimous vote
- North Block County Hall Smedley Street Matlock DerbyshireUp to 45 flats · 25/00275/LBALT Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Derbyshire County Council County Hall Smedley Street Matlock DerbyshireHotel conversion and alterations · 25/00273/LBALT Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Derbyshire County Council County Hall Smedley Street Matlock DerbyshireOffice and residential development · 25/00272/FULSeconded the motion Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Derbyshire County Council County Hall Smedley Street Matlock DerbyshireHomes and office building · 25/00271/OUT Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Former Highfield House Nursing Home 28 Clifton Road Ashbourne Derbyshire12 homes · 25/00566/FUL Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- The Gallows Sign St John Street Ashbourne DerbyshireAshbourne Head museum display · 25/00400/LBALTProposed the motion Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land South Of Ashbourne Green Ashbourne DerbyshireAgricultural lambing shed · 24/00405/FUL Approved ForAll members present in favour
- The Racecourse Retreat Camp Site Hey Lane Wirksworth DerbyshireFour glamping pods · 26/00062/FUL ApprovedAgainst officer advice ForUnanimous vote
- Block B Chatsworth Hall Wellington Street Matlock Derbyshire68-apartment mixed-use development · 25/00508/FULProposed the motion Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Land Off Derby Road Doveridge Derbyshire5 to 6 dwellings · 25/01187/PIPProposed the motion Refused For refusalUnanimous vote
- Lodge Rise Clifton Road Clifton DerbyshireFive dwellings · 26/00049/PIP Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- The Bell Inn 47 The Hill Cromford DerbyshirePub conversion to dwelling · 25/00753/LBALT Approved ForUnanimous vote
- The Bell Inn 47 The Hill Cromford DerbyshirePub to dwelling · 25/00752/FUL Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 35 Beresford Avenue Ashbourne DerbyshireTwo detached dwellings · 25/00128/OUTProposed the motion Deferred Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Congregational Chapel Chapel Lane Middleton By Wirksworth DerbyshireCommunity hall conversion · 24/01027/FUL Approved Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land Opposite Blackwall Grange Blackwall Lane Kirk Ireton DerbyshireThree-stable equestrian use · 25/00722/FULDeclared an interest Approved ForNo vote against recorded
- Land East Of Thurvaston Road Marston Montgomery DerbyshireTwo semi-detached homes · 25/00621/FUL Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Beechmount Pinfold Lane Bradley DerbyshireDriveway widening and treatment plant · 25/00686/FUL Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Lumsdale Mill Lumsdale Road Lower Lumsdale DerbyshireMill conversion and housing · 24/00030/FUL Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Derbyshire Dales District Council Northwood Depot Harrison Way Darley Dale Derbyshire120 roof solar panels · 25/00616/VCONDSeconded the motion Approved ForAll members present in favour
- Middleton Top Camp Site Rise End Middleton By Wirksworth DerbyshireTemporary barn dwelling · 25/00520/FUL Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Russets 2B Wyaston Road Ashbourne DerbyshireDwelling extensions · 25/00527/FUL RefusedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Market Place And Victoria Square Ashbourne DerbyshireReplacement tree and paving condition · 25/00828/VCONDProposed the motion Approved ForUnanimous vote
- Market Place And Victoria Square Ashbourne DerbyshireMarket square works · 25/00827/VCOND Approved ForAll members present in favour
- 9 Greenhill Wirksworth DerbyshireThree-bedroom holiday let · 25/00418/FUL RefusedAgainst officer advice For refusalUnanimous vote
- 8 Greenhill Wirksworth DerbyshireOne-bed holiday let · 25/00426/FULSeconded the motion RefusedAgainst officer advice Not recordedThe minutes do not say how each member voted
- Land East Of 21 Cavendish Drive Ashbourne DerbyshireTwo semi-detached homes · 25/00620/FULProposed the motion Refused For refusalUnanimous vote
- Land South Of Yew Tree Farm Yew Tree Lane Bradley DerbyshireOne dwelling · 25/00308/OUT Refused For refusalUnanimous vote
- Plot 36 Harrison Way Ashbourne DerbyshireIndustrial unit · 25/00315/REM Approved ForUnanimous vote
No decision matches these filters.
In the minutes
What the minutes record Buttle moving, seconding, asking or saying on each decision, in the minutes’ own words. Passages that name more than one councillor, or a member of the public, are left out.
Subjects in what the minutes record
- Heritage14 Jul 2026
- Seconded
“It was moved by Councillor Hughes, seconded by Councillor Buttle”
Minutes, 8 Sep 2026, Derbyshire County Council County Hall Smedley Street Matlock Derbyshire - Moved the motion
“It was moved by Councillor Buttle, seconded by Councillor Dobbs”
Minutes, 8 Sep 2026, North Block County Hall Smedley Street Matlock Derbyshire - Moved approval
“Councillor Neil Buttle moved a motion to accept the Officer recommendation and grant Listed Building Consent, seconded by Councillor Jo Linthwaite.”
Minutes, 14 Jul 2026, The Gallows Sign St John Street Ashbourne Derbyshire - Moved the motion
“It was moved by Councillor Neil Buttle, seconded by Councillor Lucy Peacock”
Minutes, 12 May 2026, Block B Chatsworth Hall Wellington Street Matlock Derbyshire - Moved the motion
“It was moved by Councillor Neil Buttle, seconded by Councillor David Hughes”
Minutes, 10 Mar 2026, 35 Beresford Avenue Ashbourne Derbyshire - Moved the motion
“It was moved by Councillor Neil Buttle, Seconded by Councillor John Bointon”
Minutes, 10 Mar 2026, Land Off Derby Road Doveridge Derbyshire - Seconded
“It was moved by Councillor David Hughes, seconded by Councillor Neil Buttle”
Minutes, 11 Nov 2025, Derbyshire Dales District Council Northwood Depot Harrison Way Darley Dale Derbyshire - Moved the motion
“It was moved by Councillor Neil Buttle, seconded by Councillor Peter Dobbs”
Minutes, 30 Sep 2025, Market Place And Victoria Square Ashbourne Derbyshire - Moved the motion
“It was moved by Councillor Neil Buttle, seconded by Councillor Peter Dobbs”
Minutes, 9 Sep 2025, Land East Of 21 Cavendish Drive Ashbourne Derbyshire - Seconded
“It was moved by Councillor David Hughes, seconded by Councillor Neil Buttle”
Minutes, 9 Sep 2025, 8 Greenhill Wirksworth Derbyshire
How this is worked out
Everything here is read from Derbyshire Dales’s published planning committee minutes, 15 meetings from August 2025 to October 2026. A councillor is matched across meetings by the council’s own member number where it has one, otherwise by full name.
Each vote shows how it is known. Named in the minutes: the minutes, or the council’s own recorded vote, list each member with their vote. From the count and the names: the minutes give the numbers and name the members in the minority, and every member present is known. All members present in favour: the minutes say every member voted for it and the members present are known. No vote against recorded: the minutes record the decision with no vote against, no abstention and no count, at a council whose minutes print a divided vote when there is one, so each member present is counted for. Unanimous vote: the minutes call the decision unanimous, or give a count with no one against and no one abstaining, and each member present is counted for. From the meeting recording: the vote was heard on the council’s recording of the meeting and closes exactly with the members present. Where none of these holds, the vote is left as “Not recorded” and is not counted.
Votes are on the resolution the committee passed, so a vote for is a vote with the majority. A vote is a decision on the application in front of the committee, not a statement of the councillor’s views. A percentage is shown only with five or more votes, decisions or meetings behind it.
Source: Plota analysis of the council’s minutes. The party is from the council’s own list of councillors.
Also on this committee
- Peter DobbsLib Dem
- John BointonConservative
- Peter SlackLabour
- Stuart LeesConservative
- Sue BurfootLib Dem
- David HughesLib Dem
- Dermot MurphyConservative
- David BurtonLib Dem
- Lucy PeacockLabour
- Gareth GeeDerbyshire First
- Laura MellstromGreen
- Nigel Norman Edwards-WalkerDerbyshire First
- Bob ButcherLabour
- Joanne LinthwaiteLib Dem
- Anthony BatesConservative
- Roger ShelleyLib Dem