Derbyshire Dales planning committee decisions
54 decisions from the committee's minutes, 8 Jul 2025 to 13 Oct 2026. Each sets out what was proposed, what officers advised, what was said and how the committee decided.
Councillors on the planning committee
1 in 7 decisions went against officer advice
1.5 times the rate across all 389 councils with committee decisions on Plota (9.9%), 66th highest of 273 councils with at least 15 decisions.
- Decisions
- 54
- Approved
- 70.4%
- Against officer advice
- 14.8%
- Unanimous
- 100%
How Derbyshire Dales compares
Share of decisions against officer advice at the 273 councils with at least 15 decisions on Plota. Each dot is a council.
| 64 | Spelthorne | 15.4% | 4 of 26 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 65 | Greenwich | 15% | 9 of 60 |
| 66 | Derbyshire Dales | 14.8% | 8 of 54 |
| 67 | Sutton | 14.7% | 5 of 34 |
| 68 | Fermanagh and Omagh | 14.3% | 10 of 70 |
Source: Plota analysis of committee minutes from 389 councils.
More or less favourable than its officers?
Derbyshire Dales's committee is less favourable to applicants than its officers. Officers recommended approval in 73.5% of these decisions; the committee approved 69.4%, 4.1 points fewer.
Across all 389 councils, committees approve 3.1 points fewer than their officers recommend, and Derbyshire Dales is close to that.
Over the 49 decided applications with a clear officer recommendation.
Source: Plota analysis of Derbyshire Dales's planning committee minutes and officer reports.
What it decides
70.4% approved and 29.6% refused. Of 39 decisions with a recorded vote, 39 were unanimous.
Show as a table
| Month | Approved | Refused | Other |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 25 | 1 | 1 | 0 |
| Nov 25 | 4 | 1 | 0 |
| Jan 26 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| Feb 26 | 4 | 0 | 0 |
| Mar 26 | 4 | 1 | 0 |
| Apr 26 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
| May 26 | 3 | 0 | 0 |
| Jun 26 | 2 | 1 | 0 |
| Jul 26 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Aug 26 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| Sep 26 | 5 | 1 | 0 |
| Oct 26 | 5 | 1 | 0 |
Source: Plota analysis of Derbyshire Dales's planning committee minutes.
When it overrules its officers
8 of 54 decisions went against the planning officers' recommendation.
Which way
What kind of application
From the 7 of 8 with a recorded application type; one application can count under more than one.
Source: Plota analysis of Derbyshire Dales's planning committee minutes and officer reports.
Recent decisions against officer advice
- Eight roof solar panels61 Greenhill Wirksworth DerbyshireOfficers advised refusal because the panels would harm the historic building and Conservation Area, outweighing their limited public benefits.Approved
- Six-home residential developmentCloud Barn Clifton Road Clifton DerbyshireOfficers advised granting up to six homes because the site was acceptable in principle and could accommodate development.Refused
- 75 timber cabinsLand At Farley Moor Farley Lane Farley DerbyshireOfficers advised approval because they considered the economic benefits, mitigation and enhancements outweighed the scheme’s adverse impacts.Refused
- Four glamping podsThe Racecourse Retreat Camp Site Hey Lane Wirksworth DerbyshireOfficers advised refusal because the site lacked suitable public transport and the pods would harm the setting of a listed farm.Approved
- Dwelling extensionsRussets 2B Wyaston Road Ashbourne DerbyshireOfficers advised approval because the amended design and neighbour impacts were considered acceptable on balance, subject to conditions.Refused
- Solar panels16 The Dale Wirksworth DerbyshireOfficers advised refusal because the panels would harm the historic building and conservation area, outweighing their limited public benefits.Approved
Latest decisions
Newest first. Each links to the full write-up: the proposal, the officers' advice, what was said and the vote.
October 2026 6
- Eight roof solar panels61 Greenhill Wirksworth DerbyshireApproved
- Up to five dwellingsMarble Works New Road Middleton By Wirksworth DerbyshireApproved
- Six-home residential developmentCloud Barn Clifton Road Clifton DerbyshireRefused
- 25 homesLand Off Belper Road Ashbourne DerbyshireApproved
- Two-bedroom dwellingMayfield Road Cadet Hut Mayfield Road Ashbourne DerbyshireApproved
- One replacement dwellingNether Hall Farm Hallmoor Road Darley Dale DerbyshireApproved
September 2026 4
- Traveller siteLand West Of Foxholes Lane Tansley DerbyshireRefused
- Up to 45 flatsNorth Block County Hall Smedley Street Matlock DerbyshireApproved
- Hotel conversion and alterationsDerbyshire County Council County Hall Smedley Street Matlock DerbyshireApproved
- Office and residential developmentDerbyshire County Council County Hall Smedley Street Matlock DerbyshireApproved
Other committees nearby
- Amber Valley planning committee
- Ashfield planning committee
- Bassetlaw planning committee
- Blaby planning committee
- Bolsover planning committee
- Boston planning committee
- Broxtowe planning committee
- Charnwood planning committee
- Chesterfield planning committee
- Derby planning committee
- East Lindsey planning committee
- Erewash planning committee
- Gedling planning committee
- Harborough planning committee
- High Peak planning committee
- Hinckley and Bosworth planning committee
- Leicester planning committee
- Lincoln planning committee
- Mansfield planning committee
- Melton planning committee
- Newark and Sherwood planning committee
- North East Derbyshire planning committee
- North Kesteven planning committee
- North Northamptonshire planning committee