S106 contribution reduction at Land at Cross Nursery, Newgatestreet Road, Goff's Oak
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Broxbourne Planning and Regulatory Committee on 29 Jul 2026.
What was proposed
The application sought to modify the agreement for up to 14 self-build plots by reducing financial contributions, with no other scheme changes.
“SUMMARY 1.1 Outline planning permission ref. 07/22/0147/O was granted on 29 December 2023, for the demolition of existing glasshouse and ancillary buildings and provision of up to 14no. residential self-build plots (with all matters reserved except for access).”
“DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL 3.1 The application seeks a modification to the s106 agreement attached to planning permission ref. 07/22/0147/O to reduce the financial contributions in line with current project viability. The obligation at the time of the signing of the S106 agreement in December 2023 equated to financial contributions of £162,461.50 per dwelling unit.”
Officer report
Site and surroundings
The approximately 2.2-hectare site is on Newgatestreet Road, within the Green Belt, with houses, nurseries, trees, hedgerows, a pond and open fields nearby.
“Site location plan 2.2 The access road into the site is approximately 43m in length. It is straddled to the north and south by detached houses set within extensive grounds. Along this section of Newgatestreet Road there is a ribbon of residential development comprising detached one and two-storey properties. More recent detached houses are situated diagonally opposite to the south-west at ‘Oak Park Farm’, ‘Windy Ridge’ and ‘Woodland House’.”
Officer report
Earlier permissions
Outline permission was granted in December 2023, followed by approvals for reserved matters and several details required by conditions.
“RELEVANT PLANNING HISTORY Application Reference Description of Proposal Decision 07/24/0560/DRC Application for the approval of details reserved by condition no 17 (DCEMP) and 18 (Construction Traffic Management Plan) of planning permission 07/22/0147/O(Outline Planning Permission for the demolition of existing glasshouses and ancillary structures and phased delivery of up to 14 serviced plots for self-build and custom housebuilding) Approved 30/09/2024 07/24/0464/DRC…”
Officer report
Officers’ recommendation
Officers recommended reducing contributions to £50,000 per dwelling because the updated viability assessment indicated a return within the suitable 15–20% range.
“The applicant’s updated proposal reduces contributions to £50,000 per unit producing a return of c.19% on GDV. This return would fall within the range of 15-20% cited by Planning Practice Guidance as a suitable return for developers. All documents are published on the Council website under planning reference 07/26/0076/MOD106.”
“RECOMMENDATION 9.1 That the s.106 agreement is varied to reduce developer contributions from £177,000 per dwelling to 50,000 per dwelling. This should allow the scheme to produce a profit within the suitable return range of 15-20% GDV as set out in Planning Practice Guidance.”
Officer report
Consultation and objections
The county council recognised changed market conditions, while one objection questioned the viability appraisal and warned of harm to local services and facilities.
“CONSULTATIONS AND REPRESENTATIONS 5.1 Detailed below is a summary of the consultation responses received. The full version of each consultation response can be viewed on the Council’s website via public access at the following link: https://www.broxbourne.gov.uk/planning/planning- register/1 using the planning reference: 07/26/0076/MOD106. Publicity The application was advertised by means of a site notice posted on 17 April 2026.”
“Reducing the S106 contributions would have a significant negative impact on education, transport and infrastructure, healthcare and community facilities, and affordable housing. Consultation The following consultation responses have been received: 5.4 HCC Growth and Infrastructure – whilst there is disappointment that the application has been submitted, there is also understanding that market conditions may have changed and consequently impacted on viability.”
Officer report
Viability assessment
The agreed contributions were assessed as producing an approximately 5% loss, while £50,000 per dwelling was assessed as producing an approximately 19% return.
“The applicant’s original FVA concluded that the current level of planning obligations at c.£175,000 per unit are unviable and undeliverable, resulting in an actual return that is negative, i.e. a loss-making scheme. By contrast, a reduced set of contributions in line with nearby similar consents at £77,455 per unit delivers a positive return.”
“With the agreed level of S106 contributions, the submitted appraisal indicates a negative residual land value of -£3,626,018 and a deficit of -£4,726,018 representing an actual loss of c. 5%. The DSP review finds the consented scheme produces the following outcomes: Scheme Residual Land Value Deficit Actual Profit %GDV Agreed level of S106 contributions -£1,004,377 -£1,554,377 7.7 Reduced level of S106 contributions -£139,659 -£689,659 14.3 7.9 The DSP Review states that…”
Officer report
Committee discussion
The Committee considered a request to pool education funding for greater flexibility, and officers indicated that there appeared to be no objection.
“It was noted that if the Committee was minded to grant the application the County Council had asked if the section 106 education funding could be pooled to provide greater flexibility in its application. The officers indicated that there would be appear to be no objection to this request.”
Minutes
Committee decision
The Committee varied the agreement to £77,455 per dwelling and asked officers to allocate funding where possible to serve the Goffs Oak area.
“RESOLVED that; (a) the s.106 agreement is varied to reduce developer contributions to £77,455 per dwelling; and (b) the officers seek to ensure that where possible the section 106 funding should be allocated to serve the Goffs Oak area.”
Minutes
Councillors at the meeting
- Peter ChorleyChairConservative
- A P SiracusaVice-Chair
- Carol BowmanLabour
- Carol CrumpConservative
- Shenis HassanConservative
- Paul MasonConservative
- George NicolaouConservative
- John PerkinsConservative
- Giles HallSubstituteRFM UK
Apologies Giorgio Daniel RFM UK
Also attending Jim Clune Conservative, Mark Perkins Conservative
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Broxbourne Planning and Regulatory Committee minutes, 29 July 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Broxbourne's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- Broxbourne
- Date
- Wednesday 29 July 2026
- Committee decided
- Approved
- Councillors
- 9Conservative 6Labour 1RFM UK 11 otherShow councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Broxbourne committee decisions →
This committee's year
16 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 3 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.