23-bedroom HMO and dwelling at 31, 33 Spring Gardens, Edinburgh
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Edinburgh Development Management Sub-Committee on 21 Oct 2026.
What was proposed
The application would create one dwelling, a 23-bedroom HMO, new dormers, rooflights, a rear extension and a widened access.
“Planning permission is sought for the separation of the dwellinghouse within 31 and 33 Spring Gardens into a dwellinghouse at 33 Spring Gardens and an HMO at 31 Spring Gardens. The latter will result in the creation of a single 23-bedroom HMO within an internally connected 27 to 31 Spring Gardens which represents an increase of six to the existing 17-bedroom HMO at 27 and 29 Spring Gardens.”
“Physical works include the formation of a 1.5 storey extension to the rear elevation of 33 Spring Gardens, the addition of slate clad dormers with timber sash and case windows to the principal and rear elevations of both properties and the formation of rooflights (one to the principal of 33 Spring Gardens and three to the rear of 31 Spring Gardens). No material alterations are proposed to either curtilage except the widening of an access to 33 Spring Gardens.”
Officer report
The site and surroundings
The site comprises a dwellinghouse at 31 and 33 Spring Gardens and an existing HMO at 27 and 29 Spring Gardens within a residential terrace.
“The site is a 2-storey (with converted attic) dwellinghouse (Class 9) formed by the amalgamation of 31 and 33 Spring Gardens and a 2-storey (with converted attic) house in multiple occupation (HMO) (sui generis) formed by the amalgamation of 27 and 29 Spring Gardens.”
“Within the immediate surroundings there are examples of residential institutions (Class 8) and non-residential institutions (Class 10) with 'Elsie Inglis Nursing Home' and 'Bright Horizons Elsie Inglis Early Learning and Childcare' respectively located at Spring Gardens (no number) and 1 Waverley Park.”
Officer report
The officers’ recommendation
Officers recommended approval because the proposals complied with the Development Plan and no compelling material considerations justified refusal.
“- Any allegation made in regard to the potential operator at 27 and 29 Spring Gardens or the management of any other properties they are said to operate. - Any reference to legislation that is not relevant to whether proposals are in accordance with the Development Plan (e.g. Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 and Housing (Scotland) Act 2006). - Any reference to the existing or potential behaviour of tenants.”
“The proposals are in accordance with the Development Plan and there no compelling material considerations for not approving them.”
Officer report
Issues raised by residents
The objections included concerns about design, flood risk, drainage, waste collection, the planning history and the principle of the proposals.
“- Design and impact on the character and appearance of the surroundings. - Drainage and flood risk - 'global climate and nature crises'. - Principle of the proposals and planning history. - Waste and collection arrangements - 'global climate and nature crises'.”
Officer report
The committee’s debate
Members considered whether to continue the application for a hearing before deciding between granting permission and refusing it.
“26/00873/FUL should be granted. A vote was taken for and against whether to continue the application for a hearing. Voting For Continuation - 2 Against Continuation - 7 (For continuation: Councillors Cowdy and McNeese-Mechan Against continuation: Councillors Booth, Key, Mattos Coelho, McKay, Mitchell, Osler and Staniforth) Decision 1 To REFUSE the request for a hearing.”
“Amendment To REFUSE planning permission as it was contrary to: 1) Local Development Plan Policy Hou 6 (Inappropriate Uses in Residential Areas). 2) Local Development Plan Policy Env 33 (Amenity).”
Minutes
The members' reasons
The resolution gives these reasons:
Minutes
- The development is contrary to Local Development Plan Policy Hou 6 (Inappropriate Uses in Residential Areas) as the proposal will introduce an intensification of use to the detriment of residential amenity.
- The development is contrary to Local Development Plan Policy Env 33 (Amenity) as the impact on the amenity of neighbouring properties will be adversely affected. (Reference – report by the Chief Planning Officer, submitted.)
- Unit 6 219 High Street, Edinburgh, EH1 1PE Details were provided regarding a proposal for the change of use (retrospective) from residential to short term let accommodation (sui generis) -
Source: the council's minutes, quoted word for word.
Councillors at the meeting
- Hal OslerChairLib Dem
- Max MitchellVice-ChairConservative
- Chas BoothGreen
- Christopher CowdyConservative
- Joan GriffithsLabour
- David KeySNP
- Martha Mattos CoelhoSNP
- Amy McNeese-MechanSNP
- Tim PogsonLabour
- Alex StaniforthGreen
- Kevin McKaySubstitute for LangLib Dem
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Edinburgh Development Management Sub-Committee minutes, 21 October 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Edinburgh's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- Edinburgh
- Date
- Wednesday 21 October 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Refused, against officer advice
- Councillors
- 11SNP 3Conservative 2Green 2Labour 2Lib Dem 2Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Edinburgh committee decisions →
This committee's year
253 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 6 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.