New primary school at St Thomas Church Of England Primary School Clarence Street And Playing Fields Hawkhurst Street Leigh

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by Wigan Planning Committee on 5 Aug 2025.

A/23/96040/MAJORApproved

What was proposed

The application proposed a new school with access, parking, landscaping, sports facilities and solar canopies, while demolishing the existing school and creating open space.

“Development proposed: Erection of part single storey part two storey educational facility (Class F1(a)) at Hawkhurst Playing Fields including new vehicular and pedestrian access, vehicular drop off bay, parking area, hard and soft landscaping, a MUGA, PV canopies, erection of substation and associated boundary treatments. Demolition of existing school buildings at Astley Street and reinstatement of area into open space with new site boundaries.”

“Vehicular access is proposed from Hawkhurst Street and there will be a one-way vehicle route/drop off bay located to the front of the school along with staff car and cycle parking facilities; pedestrian access would be available from the Hawkhurst Street and Edale Road directions.”

Officer report

The site

The proposal covered two sites about 140 metres apart: the existing school site and playing fields used by the school, a football club and the public.

“The existing school site, the ‘southern site’, is bound by vegetation to the north, Astley Street and neighbouring dwellings to the east, an alleyway and Clarence Street to the south and Clarence Street and neighbouring dwellings to the west. The site is occupied by an existing primary school with a capacity for circa 420 no. students and also by St Thomas’ pre-school, housed in a separate small building at the northern end of the site.”

“The eastern part of the Hawkhurst Street site, the ‘northern site’, consists of an existing sports pitch used by St Thomas’ Primary School and East Leigh Junior Football Club (East Leigh J.F.C.), whilst the western extent of the site is currently grassed and open to use by the general public and available as an informal pitch, along with some changing rooms and a small car park.”

Officer report

Earlier applications

The southern site had approvals for fencing and parking, a covered play area, and changes to a public footpath and fencing.

“Application reference A/11/76063: To erect pitch canopy to create covered play area outside the Key Stage 1 reception classroom to the north of the school site. Approved 26 October 2011.”

“Application reference A/10/74637: Change of use of public footpath to school land and erection of 1.55m high fencing. Approved 17 September 2010.”

Officer report

Why officers supported it

Officers considered the replacement school, public open space, sports contribution, highway measures and other mitigation sufficient to meet planning requirements.

“Following a thorough and balanced assessment, Officers consider the proposed development to be compliant with the relevant national and local planning policies, subject to the financial contributions and mitigation measures secured through planning conditions and a Section 106 obligation. The scheme will deliver a modern, fit-for-purpose educational facility to serve the needs of local children, addressing long-standing deficiencies in the existing school infrastructure.”

“Officers acknowledge the statutory objection from Sport England. However, in proceeding to recommend approval of this application to Members, significant weight is given to the delivery of a much-needed new school and the wider community benefits of the scheme.”

Officer report

Advice from consultees

Sport England objected over playing-field loss, while transport, environmental, drainage, ecology, design and heritage consultees raised no objection subject to measures.

“Sport England maintains a statutory objection to the proposal, concluding that the development does not meet any of the exceptions in their Playing Fields Policy, particularly Exception 4. While they acknowledge the proposed financial contribution towards a 3G pitch at Hesketh Meadows, they consider this insufficient to offset the quantitative loss of playing field land. They advise that the application must be referred to the Secretary of State if approved.”

Officer report

What people said

Most representations objected over traffic, green-space loss, amenity, pollution, ecology, heritage, engagement and sports mitigation; four supported the move’s traffic benefits.

“Loss of sunlight, increased overshadowing, and reduced privacy for nearby homes. ▪ Increased noise, light, and air pollution, and risk of flooding. ▪ Loss of wildlife habitat and biodiversity. ▪ Negative impact on residents’ mental health and wellbeing. ▪ Disruption during construction and concerns over emergency access. ▪ Perceived secrecy and lack of public engagement in the planning process. ▪ Inadequate consideration of alternative or brownfield sites.”

“Requests for residents-only parking permits. ▪ Scepticism about children cycling to school and lack of supporting study. ▪ Loss of part of the existing 11v11 pitch, reducing it to 9v9 suitability. ▪ Loss of historic school building and local heritage. ▪ Concerns over Whitfield Street and its suitability for construction traffic. ▪ Need for improvements to the track behind Ennerdale Road. ▪ Public right of way between Edale and Ennerdale Roads must be preserved.”

Officer report

Who spoke

One speaker spoke against the application and one spoke in favour, with four minutes allowed for each.

The decision

“Decision: Approved with Conditions (See minute 9.1) Representations in objection to the application had been received in relation to: highway safety; loss of green space/community asset; impact on neighbouring amenity; risk of flooding; poor design/out of character; impact on wildlife/biodiversity; Sport England have objected/proposed financial migration is inadequate; impact on local heritage; impact on local heritage; application lacks clarity and transparency and poor engagement with local residents; no evidence that future pupils can cycle to school; impact on privacy of local residents from proposed ANPR camera; and no consideration of alternative sites. Representations in support of the application had been received in relation to: the proposal alleviating issues experienced around the existing school site, such as traffic and ad-hoc parking. Conditions 1. T”

Minutes, 5 Aug 2025

Councillors at the meeting

Apologies Paul John Blay Labour, Matt Dawber Labour, John Harding Labour

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors and Democracy Club.

Sources

  • Wigan Planning Committee minutes, 5 August 2025
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of Wigan's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Council
Wigan
Date
Tuesday 5 August 2025
Recommendation
Officers recommended approval
Committee decided
Approved
Councillors
12Labour 9Independent 2Lab Co-op 1Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)
Application
The application (council website)