Self-build affordable home at Land at SX 549 523 Paddock Drive, Brixton

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by South Hams Development Management Committee on 10 Jul 2025.

3633/24/OPAApproved

No officer report was published for this decision; this summary is from the committee minutes.

Outline plan for a self-build home

The application is an outline proposal, with some matters reserved, for a self-build affordable dwelling.

“Development: Outline planning application with some matters reserved for proposed self-build affordable dwelling…”

Minutes

Affordable housing against the Open Gap

Officers weighed the tilted balance for an extra dwelling and the provision of affordable housing against the neighbourhood plan's Open Gap requirement, finding no other concerns outstanding.

“The Case Officer summarised the key issues, namely: • Additional dwelling-tilted balance. • Provision of affordable housing.”

“Meeting NP requirement for development in Open Gap area. • Local connection secured. • Meets several sustainability measures. • No concerns regarding drainage, carbon, landscape character, ecology- details to be confirmed at RM stage. • Short walk with no footway. • Exceeds some sustainability measures.”

Minutes

Policy and housing need explained

Members were told the affordable reduction exceeded the local connection requirement, that policy allowed support for this dwelling, and that the Affordable Housing Team confirmed a need for it in the village.

“In response to questions raised by Members, it was reported that: • The 30% reduction for the affordable home was greater than the local connection. • The two main issues from the appeal related to the location, sustainability and impact on the landscape character. • There were key differences between the decision that was dismissed at appeal and the current decision. Policy TTV27 allows us to support dwellings which we would not normally support.”

Minutes

Open Gap protection against housing need

After hearing objectors, supporters, the Parish Council and the Ward Member, some members called the house essential despite the Open Gap, while another felt it was inappropriate and unnecessary.

“Another Member felt this was an inappropriate proposal and doubted this site would bring forward an affordable house. Overall tending to go against the officer recommendation of approval because they felt it did not meet the neighbourhood plan provision and would not deliver essential affordable local housing in a sensitively located site. They supported the clearly expressed views made by the Parish Council and they felt this house was not essential on that site.”

Minutes

A motion against officers, then withdrawn

A motion to refuse against officer advice was moved on Open Gap grounds, challenged by officers over the council's declared housing crisis, and then withdrawn.

“It was then moved to go against the Officer’s recommendation of approval on the basis that it did not meet the local plan provision for the Open Gap. The Open Gap should be protected and the affordability whilst relevant did not sufficiently outweigh the need to maintain other developments and on balance the local neighbourhood plan should have precedent.”

“Officer added that this council has declared a housing crisis particularly relating to affordable housing and therefore any affordable housing was essential. The statement from the Housing Team was read out to the Committee.”

Minutes

Approved with a section 106 agreement

The committee gave conditional approval requiring a section 106 agreement to secure an open market discount, local connection and mitigation for the Tamar protected site.

“Recommendation: Conditional approval subject to completion of S106 to secure open market discount and local connection in perpetuity, as well as financial mitigation towards the impacts on the Tamar EMS.”

“Committee Decision: Conditional approval subject to completion of S106 to secure open market discount and local connection in perpetuity, as well as financial mitigation towards the impacts on the Tamar EMS.”

Minutes

Conditions on design and drainage

Conditions cover reserved matters, self-build compliance, space standards, parking, a construction management plan, drainage details and removal of permitted development rights.

“Conditions: Standard time limit Submission of reserved matters Accord with plans Self-build compliance Details of how the proposal meets NDSS and external space standards to be provided Parking provision to be submitted with reserved matters Construction Management Plan to be submitted with reserved matters Surface water drainage details to be submitted with reserved matters DEV32 compliance to be submitted with reserved matters Removal of PD rights Unsuspected contamination…”

Minutes

The members' reasons

“During the debate, some Members felt that the Open Gap was a well meant and should be protected but every affordable house was essential because there were so few, and a single house would be essential.”

Minutes

Source: the council's minutes, quoted word for word.

Councillors at the meeting

Also attending Denise O'Callaghan Lib Dem, Ged Yardy Lib Dem

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.

Sources

  • South Hams Development Management Committee minutes, 10 July 2025
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of South Hams's committee minutes. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Council
South Hams
Date
Thursday 10 July 2025
Recommendation
Officers recommended approval
Committee decided
Approved
Councillors
10Lib Dem 4Conservative 3Green 2Independent 1Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)
Application
The application (council website)

This committee's year

12 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 2 against officer advice.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →