Resubmitted four-bed dwelling at Stokeley Barton Farm, Stokenham

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by South Hams Development Management Committee on 8 May 2025.

3268/24/FULApprovedAgainst officer advice

No officer report was published for this decision; this summary is from the committee minutes.

Resubmitted four-bedroom dwelling

The application is a resubmission for a two-storey, four-bedroom dwelling with a family bathroom.

“Development: Erection of two storey dwelling with 4 bedrooms & family bathroom (resubmission of 3570/23/FUL)”

Minutes

Officers said fundamental conflicts remained

Officers said earlier technical concerns were resolved, but fundamental conflicts remained: the dwelling was not needed to support the business, the location was unsustainable, and there were no exceptional circumstances.

“The Case Officer summarised the key issues, namely: • Previous technical concerns resolved. • Fundamental policy conflicts remain: - Dwelling not required to support the business. - Unsustainable development in the countryside. - No exceptional circumstances as required for UC. - Conflicts with local housing need.”

Minutes

Occupancy and distance to services

Members heard 87% of dwellings in the area were under-occupied or significantly under-occupied, and the site was 800 metres from a farm shop and 600 metres from the nearest facilities.

“In response to questions raised by Members, it was reported that: • The undeveloped coast follows the coastline but also extends to estuaries and further inland. • The Officer provides a professional planning judgement, and the fundamental conflicts remain. • In Stokenham 87% of dwellings were either under occupied or significantly under occupied. • The proposed dwelling would be 800 metres from the farm shop and the nearest facilities 600 metres away.”

Minutes

A local connection condition discussed

Members discussed whether a condition could tie the property to the business or instead restrict occupancy to someone with a local connection if the business failed.

“A Member asked If the Committee were considering approving this application, could a condition be added stipulating that the property could not be sold unless it was with the business? The Head of Development Management responded it would be more appropriate to have a local connection occupancy restriction which means if the business failed the property could still be occupied by someone with a local connection.”

Minutes

Appeal risk weighed against consistency

Asked whether refusing in line with officers risked an appeal, the monitoring officer said consistent decision-making mattered and refusal would not be unreasonable if the previous concerns remained unmet.

“A question was asked if the Committee refused this application in line with the Officer’s recommendation would this leave this Committee vulnerable at any ensuing appeal? The Monitoring Officer explained that it was important for there to be consistency in decision-making. The issue in this case was whether what has come forward meets the concerns that were previously raised and is what you expected to be brought back.”

Minutes

Approved against officer advice

A vote was taken to approve the application against the officer recommendation of refusal.

“A vote was taken to approve (against Officer recommendation).”

Minutes

Approved with delegated conditions

The committee delegated conditional approval to officers, in consultation with the Chair, Vice-chair and the proposer and seconder, to settle the wording of conditions.

“Committee Decision: Delegated conditional approval to the Head of Development Management in consultation with the Chair, Vice-chair, Cllr Hodgson (proposer) and Cllr Rake (seconder) as to the wording of the conditions.”

Minutes

The members' reasons

The minutes do not record the members' reasons for departing from the officers' recommendation.

Councillors at the meeting

Also attending John Birch Lib Dem, Julian Brazil Lib Dem, Samantha Dennis Conservative, Tom Edie Lib Dem, Dan Thomas Lib Dem

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.

Sources

  • South Hams Development Management Committee minutes, 8 May 2025
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of South Hams's committee minutes. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Council
South Hams
Date
Thursday 8 May 2025
Recommendation
Officers recommended refusal
Committee decided
Approved, against officer advice
Councillors
10Lib Dem 5Conservative 2Green 2Independent 1Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)
Application
The application (council website)

This committee's year

5 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 2 against officer advice.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →