New dwelling and garage extension at Land East of 4 Munro Avenue, Yealmpton

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by South Hams Development Management Committee on 12 Jun 2025.

0512/25/FULRefused

No officer report was published for this decision; this summary is from the committee minutes.

New dwelling and garage work

The application proposes demolishing existing garages, building a new dwelling and extending the garage of an existing dwelling.

“Development: Demolition of existing garages, erection of new dwelling & garage extension to existing dwelling…”

Minutes

Housing balance and drainage concerns

Officers raised conflict with the neighbourhood plan, an imbalance in local housing stock with no identified need, a drainage objection and an unsustainable location.

“The Case Officer summarised the key issues, namely: • Not in accordance with Neighbourhood Plan. • Imbalance in local housing stock with no local need identified.”

“Drainage objection. • No unilateral undertaking information. • Unsustainable location.”

Minutes

A nearby exception site compared

Officers explained a large adjoining development had been granted as a rural exception site requiring affordable housing to offset its unsustainable location, unlike this single market dwelling.

“Head of Strategic Planning clarified what has been granted at Collaton Park. The application on the adjoining site for 125 homes with 46 affordable homes, various commercial business units, boat storage, parking, allotments and improvements to the path was granted in September 2023. That application was considered under Policy TTV27 as an exception site and required affordable housing to mitigate against the unsustainable site location.”

Minutes

Settlement hierarchy and policy explained

Officers and the monitoring officer said the development plan's settlement hierarchy still classed the area as unsustainable, and that the dwelling exceeded minimum size standards contrary to the neighbourhood plan.

“In response to questions raised by Members, it was reported that: • The housing already in place in Munro Avenue was historical and built for army personnel. If this came to committee today would not be granted permission because of the unsustainable location. • The size of the dwelling would conflict with the NP Policy and the policy seeks to deliver housing size to respond to local housing need.”

“The Head of Development Management (WD) provided Members with clarification on sustainable development as outlined in the NPPF and JLP. These policies ensure that development does not happen in an unsustainable location and in this case, the development at Munro Close was a historic and when Collaton Park was granted permission based on the benefits such as 46 affordable homes. If it was later decided this was a settlement this would form part of a review of the local plan.”

Minutes

Weighing the adjacent development's future

Members debated the application, with some questioning whether the adjacent site's future should carry so much weight, while others backed refusal under the local and neighbourhood plans.

“Having heard from speakers in support and the Ward Member. Members debated the application. During the debate, some Members felt the whole picture was not being taken into consideration with the development taking place adjacent to the proposed dwelling. The proposed dwelling would not substantially change the housing mix but did accept if there was no drainage solution should not proceed.”

“Some Members struggled to support the Officer’s recommendation of refusal, whilst other Members felt too much weight was being given to what might happen to the adjacent site in the future and Members were governed by JLP and NP and to consider the other weighty considerations for refusal.”

Minutes

The members' reasons

“During the debate, some Members felt the whole picture was not being taken into consideration with the development taking place adjacent to the proposed dwelling.”

Minutes

Source: the council's minutes, quoted word for word.

Councillors at the meeting

Also attending Samantha Dennis Conservative

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.

Sources

  • South Hams Development Management Committee minutes, 12 June 2025
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of South Hams's committee minutes. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Council
South Hams
Date
Thursday 12 June 2025
Recommendation
Officers recommended refusal
Committee decided
Refused
Councillors
11Lib Dem 5Conservative 3Green 2Independent 1Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)
Application
The application (council website)

This committee's year

8 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 2 against officer advice.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →