Temporary agricultural workers dwelling at Harling Farm, Bere Alston

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by South Hams West Devon Development Management and Licensing Committee on 12 May 2026.

0335/25/FULRefused

What was proposed

The application sought a further three-year temporary consent to retain a mobile home as an agricultural worker’s dwelling while the business was established.

“Site Description: The application site is located within the open countryside, c. 1.15km south of Bere Alston and hosts a mobile home. The wider site of Harling Farm contains a large modern agricultural barn, another mobile home (unauthorised), a storage container, another timber building and a timber building with associated pen area for cats. There are further dwellings in third party ownership to the north east of the wider site.”

“The Proposal: The current application seeks consent for the retention of the mobile home on site since being given consent under application 0685/20/FUL for 4 years in 2020. The current application proposes a further 3 year temporary consent.”

Officer report

Earlier permissions and applications

A four-year temporary permission was granted in 2020, while a later application for a permanent agricultural worker’s dwelling was withdrawn after it was not supported.

“Background In 2020 the applicant was given approval for the siting of a caravan / mobile home to be used as an agricultural worker’s dwelling; this permission was temporary for a period of four years to allow sufficient time to establish the associated agricultural business. The previous consent was granted in June 2020 meaning the four years would have lapsed in June 2024. Whilst the description of development for the current application indicates a renewal of a consent.”

“Relevant Planning History – Application Site Application Number: 1859/24/OPA Proposal: Outline planning permission with some matters reserved, access & layout, for a permanent rural worker dwelling to replace the current temporary consent Decision: Withdrawn Decision Date: 06/11/2024”

Officer report

Why officers recommended refusal

Officers found that the business did not demonstrate the financial or functional need for an agricultural worker’s dwelling, despite the time already available.

“The proposal has previously been reviewed by the Council’s Agricultural Consultant, to assess the financial and functional needs for a residential unit to be on the site to support the agricultural enterprise. In summary he indicates that, he has assessed this farm in the past and could not support a permanent dwelling on the site but recommended a temporary consent to provide time for the applicants to establish their agricultural business.”

“Officers would stress that the current application is assessed in terms of the functional and financial circumstances that would justify an agricultural worker’s dwelling on the site. The Agricultural Consultant has confirmed that neither of these tests have been satisfied, as the current requirements of the business do not justify living on site and the business itself is not profitable enough to support the dwelling.”

Officer report

Landscape and planning balance

Officers considered the isolated location and harm to the National Landscape significantly outweighed the benefit of providing one additional dwelling.

“In this case it could be argued that the proposal provides one additional dwelling which would meet the aim of the government to increase housing numbers, however the site is isolated and is therefore not in a sustainable location. The presumption in favour is for…”

“The site is also located within the Tamar Valley National Landscape and impacts on the National Landscape which is referred to in Footnote 7 of the NPPF as being an area where part(i) of Para 11d applies.”

Officer report

Who spoke

The agent supported the application and cited Covid delays and business diversification, while the parish council described diversification as necessary for the small farm’s survival.

What members discussed

Members discussed the agricultural need, other business activities, the tilted balance and whether extra temporary time could be allowed.

“Committee Debate: The Head of Planning stated that it was necessary for Officers to advise Members on whether or not the harm to the environment and the agricultural justification outweighed the ‘tilted balance’ (as identified in the NPPF 2024 paragraph 11(d)).”

“Policy SPT2 was then specifically debated by a Member as to provision of facilities and a sustainable economy with business growth. Policy TTV1 prioritised growth in smaller villages and Policy TTV2 sustainable development, which supported the vitality of rural communities. Policy DEV15 supported the rural community and the proposals were only felt to be contrary to Policy TTV26 (i.e. the need to meet the need of an agricultural worker).”

Minutes

The committee vote

The officer recommendation for refusal was proposed, seconded and carried at the vote.

“After the debate, the officer recommendation for refusal was PROPOSED and SECONDED and, when put to the vote, declared CARRIED.”

Minutes

The decision

The application was refused because essential agricultural need was not demonstrated and the mobile home harmed landscape character in the Tamar Valley National Landscape.

“The siting of the mobile home and its use as accommodation for an agricultural worker is not supported by an essential need and is therefore contrary to the provisions of SPT1, SPT2, TTV1, TTV2, TTV26 and DEV15 of the Plymouth and South West Devon Joi9nt Local Plan (2014-2034) and the guidance contained within the National Planning Policy Framework, most notably paragraph 84a; and…”

“The siting of the mobile home does not respond positively to the local building vernacular to the detriment of landscape character, thus failing to fulfil the statutory purpose for the conservation and enhancement of the natural beauty of the Tamar Valley National Landscape, contrary to the provisions of TTV26, DEV20, DEV 23, DEV25 of the Plymouth and South West Joint Local plan (2014-2034), E1 of the Bere Peninsula Neighbourhood Plan and the guidance contained within the…”

Minutes

The members' reasons

“A Member also felt that there was justification for the applicant to be given extra time in order to provide satisfactory evidence of agricultural need.”

Minutes

Source: the council's minutes, quoted word for word.

Councillors at the meeting

Also attending Mark Renders Independent

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.

Sources

  • South Hams West Devon Development Management and Licensing Committee minutes, 12 May 2026
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of South Hams's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Council
South Hams
Date
Tuesday 12 May 2026
Recommendation
Officers recommended refusal
Committee decided
Refused
Councillors
10Conservative 4Independent 4Green 1Lib Dem 1Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)
Application
The application (council website)

This committee's year

6 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 1 against officer advice.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →