Replacement dwelling at 55m east of 29 Clonvaraghan Road, Castlewellan

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by Newry Mourne Down Planning Committee on 27 May 2026.

LA07/2023/2230/OApprovedAgainst officer advice

No officer report was published for this decision; this summary is from the committee minutes.

What was proposed

The application sought outline permission for a replacement dwelling, retaining the original dwelling for storage with associated site works.

“Proposal: Proposed replacement dwelling (with retention of original dwelling for storage purposes) and all associated site works…”

“Power-point presentation: [name withheld] confirmed that the application sought outline planning permission for a replacement dwelling, with retention of the original dwelling for storage and associated site works at a site 55m east of 29 Clonvaraghan Road. She advised that the application had previously been presented to Committee on 15 October 2025 and had been deferred to allow for the submission of a Listed Building Consent (LBC) application.”

Minutes

Earlier consideration and consent

The application was previously deferred so a Listed Building Consent application could be submitted for works to the protected gate lodge.

“[name withheld] confirmed that an LBC application (LA07/2025/1562/LBC) had since been submitted for works to the gate lodge, a curtilage structure of Ballywillwill House protected under Section 80 of the Planning Act (Northern Ireland) 2011.”

Minutes

Why refusal was advised

Refusal was advised because the listed building could be refurbished or converted, while exceptional circumstances for replacement under Policy CTY 3 had not been demonstrated.

“She advised that, while the proposed works under the LBC were considered acceptable, this did not establish the principle of replacement under Policy CTY 3. The submitted refurbishment proposals demonstrated that the building was suitable for conversion, which could be considered under Policy BH 8 without the need for replacement or departure from the established curtilage.”

“[name withheld] stated that the proposal engaged SPPS and Policy CTY 3 of PPS 21. She advised that the LBC supported the case for sympathetic refurbishment rather than replacement. As Policy CTY 3 only permitted the replacement of a listed building in exceptional circumstances, and none had been demonstrated, the proposal was considered unacceptable. She added that approval would set an undesirable precedent and refusal was recommended.”

Minutes

The case for approval

The agent argued that retaining the listed building met Policy CTY 3, HED supported the proposal, and the replacement dwelling was sensitively sited.

Members’ discussion

Members questioned exceptional circumstances, the building’s condition, curtilage and works, while officers maintained that refurbishment was possible and replacement was unacceptable.

“In response to a further question regarding the condition of the existing building and the proximity of the proposed new dwelling, [name withheld] advised that policy relating to listed buildings prohibited their replacement except in exceptional circumstances. She stated that relevant policies, including PPS 6, supported the retention, refurbishment and potential extension of listed buildings, and encouraged their preservation in their original form.”

“Following further discussion, [name withheld] confirmed that it had been the applicant’s responsibility to demonstrate exceptional circumstances and reiterated that, in the Department’s view, none had been established. She advised that the proposal reinforced concerns in respect of curtilage, as it represented an extension of development beyond the established curtilage of the listed dwelling.”

Minutes

The committee vote

Councillors voted seven to zero, with no abstentions, on a proposal to overturn the officer recommendation and approve the application.

“Councillor D Murphy proposed that the Committee overturn the officer’s recommendation to an approval, stating that it had been unfair to place undue burden on young applicants. He emphasised the importance of retaining the building and considered the separation distance between the existing and proposed buildings to be acceptable.”

“The proposal was seconded by Councillor Hanna, who emphasised the importance of maintaining older buildings and stated that refusal would be unduly harsh. He added that appropriate conditions be delegated to officers.”

Minutes

The final decision

The committee approved the application contrary to the officer recommendation and delegated authority to planning officers to impose relevant conditions.

“AGREED: On the proposal of Councillor D Murphy, seconded by Councillor Hanna it was agreed to issue an approval in respect of planning application LA07/2023/2230/O, contrary to officer recommendation as contained in the Case Officer Report.”

“It was also agreed that Planning Officers be delegated authority to impose any relevant conditions.”

Minutes

The members' reasons

The minutes do not record the members' reasons for departing from the officers' recommendation.

Councillors at the meeting

Proposed by Councillor Declan Murphy, seconded by Councillor Glyn Hanna.

Apologies Cathal King Sinn Féin, Áine Quinn Sinn Féin, Jarlath Tinnelly Independent

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from Democracy Club.

Sources

  • Newry Mourne Down Planning Committee minutes, 27 May 2026
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of Newry Mourne Down's committee minutes. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Date
Wednesday 27 May 2026
Committee decided
Approved, against officer advice
Councillors
8Sinn Féin 4SDLP 2Alliance 1DUP 1Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)
Application
The application (council website)

This committee's year

63 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 36 against officer advice.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →