Mixed-use development at Land 60 Metres North Of 1 Fettes Row, Edinburgh

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by Edinburgh Development Management Sub-Committee on 17 Dec 2025.

25/01899/FULRefusedAgainst officer advice

What was proposed

The application proposed 315 homes, 593 student bedspaces, about 530 square metres of commercial space, landscaping, parking and access works.

“The proposal is for a mixed-use development comprising residential, purpose-built student accommodation, commercial uses, with associated landscaping, public realm, car and cycle parking, and access arrangements.”

“The residential properties are a mix of private residential and mid-market rent (MMR) flats and there are a total of 315 units proposed. This is broken down to 108 MMR flats and 207 private residential units. There are 593 student bedspaces proposed.”

Officer report

The site

The cleared 2.37-hectare site lies in the New Town Conservation Area beside Fettes Row, Royal Crescent, Dundas Street and King George V Park.

“To the north of the site are residential and commercial properties on Eyre Place. To the south, the site is bound by Fettes Row and Royal Crescent which comprise predominantly residential properties. To the east and northeast is King George V Park. To the west of the site is Dundas Street, which comprises a mix of residential and commercial properties.”

“The site is mainly level, although there is an area of the site to the south which is approximately 6 metres above the rest of the site. This lies behind a stone retaining wall. Royal Crescent/Fettes Row to the south of the site lie at a much higher level than the site itself. In the north of the site, Eyre Terrace rises slightly to adjoin Eyre Place.”

Officer report

Earlier permissions

Earlier permissions covered demolition, mixed-use development, residential development, park works and tree works, while several main applications had non-material variations.

“14/01177/PPP 7, 11, 13 Eyre Terrace Edinburgh EH3 5ER Planning permission in principle for mixed use development. Retail (class 1); financial, professional + other services (class 2); food + drink (class 3); business (class 4); hotels (class 7); residential (class 8, 9 + sui generis), car parking, access + other works, approval of siting + maximum height of principal building block, points of vehicular/pedestrian access + egress. Granted 7 January 2021”

“20/03034/FUL 34 Fettes Row Edinburgh EH3 6RH Demolition of existing buildings and erection of mixed-use development comprising residential, hotel, office, and other commercial uses, with associated landscaping / public realm, car parking, and access arrangements. Granted 1 September 2021”

Officer report

Officers’ main reasoning

Officers accepted a housing shortfall of about 10% and student accommodation, concluding that the proposal complied with the development plan and lacked overriding adverse considerations.

“The site is allocated for housing in the LDP. The proposed housing element of the proposal does not quite meet the estimated number of housing units contained within the plan. It represents a shortfall of approximately 10%. However, this is acceptable as it does not compromise the spatial strategy of the plan, due to the wider redevelopment proposals.”

“The proposals are acceptable in relation to other matters such as transport, drainage, sustainability, archaeology. This is subject to conditions and a legal agreement. The proposal therefore complies with the development plan. There are no other material considerations which outweigh this conclusion.”

Officer report

What people said

The community council and residents objected to the student focus, housing shortfall, height, design, heritage effects, amenity, transport and infrastructure impacts.

“New Town and Broughton Community Council objects to the application. Summary below:”

“− Frustrated at lack of progress on the site. − Current proposals erode previous mixed-use development and provides a single PBSA model. − Proposals will not foster neighbourhood resilience with a transient population. − Overall height − Blocks too high and bulky and not reflective of stepping down along Dundas Street − Access from Fettes Row should be restricted. − Available amenity space − Lack of sustainability credentials − Lack of office space proposed.”

Officer report

The committee vote

The committee voted on a division to refuse planning permission because the proposal was contrary to housing, student accommodation and amenity policies.

“25/01899/FUL – Report by the Chief Planning Officer To REFUSE planning permission as it was contrary to Local Development Plan Policies Hou 1, Hou 5b and Env 26 and Env 33. (On a division)”

Minutes

The members' reasons

The members' reasons are quoted from the minutes above, under “The committee vote”.

Sources

  • Edinburgh Development Management Sub-Committee minutes, 17 December 2025
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of Edinburgh's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Council
Edinburgh
Date
Wednesday 17 December 2025
Recommendation
Officers recommended approval
Committee decided
Refused, against officer advice
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)
Application
The application (council website)

This committee's year

172 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 5 against officer advice.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →