Planning appeals in Scilly Isles
Every appeal the Planning Inspectorate has decided against a Scilly Isles planning decision, newest first, with the outcome and a link to the application where we hold it.
3appeals decided in the last 12 months in Scilly Isles
33%allowed
1householder appeals
0enforcement appeals
8 appeals in the last 5 years.
-
Land to South of Lower Town Barns, Lower Town, St Martin's, Isles of Scilly, TR25 0QWAllowed23 Jul 2026
-
Bishops View, Porthloo, St Mary's, Isles of Scilly, TR21 0NFDismissed25 Feb 2026
-
Treskey, Garrison, St. Mary's, ISLES OF SCILLY, TR21 0LSDismissed13 Oct 2025
-
Treskey, Garrison, St. Mary's, ISLES OF SCILLY, TR21 0LSNot recorded13 Oct 2025
-
Westward Ledge, Church Road, St. Mary's, ISLES OF SCILLY, TR21 0NAAllowed5 Oct 2023
-
2 Matthews Field, Church Road, Hugh Town, St Mary's, TR21 0NADismissed11 Apr 2023
-
Land at Lawrences Brow, St. Martin's, Isles Of Scilly, Cornwall, TR25 0QLAllowed14 Jul 2022
-
Westward Ledge, Church Road, Isles of Scilly, Cornwall, TR21 0NADismissed4 Jul 2022
Source: Planning Inspectorate casework database, published under the Open Government Licence and updated when the Inspectorate republishes it. Decisions to 31 Jul 2026. Appeals still in progress are not included. See also planning applications in Scilly Isles.
How planning appeals work
Who can appeal a planning decision?
Only the applicant. In England there is no third-party right of appeal against a permission; an appeal is made to the Planning Inspectorate against a refusal, against conditions, or because the council did not decide in time.
What do allowed, dismissed and split mean?
Allowed means the Inspector granted what the council refused, or quashed the notice. Dismissed means the council’s decision stands; an enforcement notice the Inspector varies (more time to comply, a narrower requirement) and upholds is dismissed, and marked Notice varied. A split decision allows part of what was applied for.
How is an appeal decided?
Most are decided on written representations from both sides and a site visit; more complex cases go to a hearing or a public inquiry. The procedure is shown against each appeal.
Where does this data come from?
The Planning Inspectorate’s casework database, published under the Open Government Licence and refreshed here whenever a new edition appears. It holds decided appeals only, so appeals still in progress do not appear, and the latest decisions can be several weeks behind.