25 apartments and commercial units at Site Of Royal Clarence Hotel, Cathedral Yard, Exeter
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Exeter Planning Committee on 19 Jan 2026.
What was proposed
The scheme would reconstruct and extend the site, providing 25 apartments above public house and restaurant uses on the ground and basement floors.
“Description of development The proposal is for reconstruction and extension of the building, including partial demolition and repair of the remaining building fabric to provide ground floor/basement food and beverage units (Class E(b)) and 25 apartments on the floors above. This is two more than the previous scheme. It is envisaged the basement/ground floors will be occupied by a public house and restaurant.”
“Basement Level – Public house cellars, storage and plant rooms, residential plant room, and restaurant function room and toilets.”
Officer report
The site and its setting
The site contains fire-damaged listed buildings beside Cathedral Green, surrounded by listed buildings, a scheduled monument and the Central Conservation Area.
“The buildings that formed the hotel and adjoining public house suffered a significant fire in 2016 resulting in the loss of the majority of the building fabric on site. The remaining building structures on site were made safe, and salvage/recording operations associated with the necessary partial demolition of unsafe remains carried out under listed building consent ref. 17/0783/LBC.”
“The remains of the hotel and nos. 16 and 17 Cathedral Green are each Grade II listed, and it is surrounded by a number of other protected historic assets. The site is bounded by nos. 39-45 High Street and 11-13 Martin’s Lane to the north, which are all Grade II listed with the exception of 40, 41 and 42 High Street, which are Grade II* listed. To the east is Martin’s Lane with the Grade II listed Ship Inn and 1 and 2 Catherine Street, also Grade II listed, facing the site.”
Officer report
Earlier permissions
Earlier permissions covered post-fire stabilisation, a hotel reconstruction and a similar residential and commercial redevelopment scheme.
“17/1360/FUL Reconstruction and extension of building (including partial demolition and repair of remaining building fabric) following extensive fire damage to create 74 bedroom hotel PER 05.12.2017 17/1361/LBC Reconstruction and extension of building (including partial demolition and repair of remaining building fabric) following extensive fire damage to create 74 bedroom hotel PER 05.12.2017 18/1167/LBC Three elements proposed for demolition or alteration; i) Areas of the…”
“PER 25.08.2023 22/0237/LBC Reconstruction and extension of building (including partial demolition and repair of remaining building fabric) following extensive fire damage to create commercial food and beverage units at ground floor and residential units from first to fifth floor. PER 25.08.2023 9.0 List of constraints • Building remains onsite are Grade II listed.”
Officer report
Why officers supported it
Officers considered the heritage harm less than substantial and outweighed by restoration, regeneration, housing, commercial and wider public benefits.
“The revisions to the scheme during the assessment of the application have reduced the harm to the historic fabric through a reduction in demolition to the Well House and adopting a more sensitive approach to structural repair of in situ aspects. This has been supported by a proportionate and robust justification, with demolition primarily occurring on more modern additions. Whilst there is overall harm, it is considered to be less than substantial.”
“It is therefore concluded that the harm to the historic fabric is outweighed by the overall benefits of the scheme, subject to the conditions outlined in this report, and that there is less than substantial harm in line with NPPF and development plan requirements.”
Officer report
What consultees said
Historic England and the heritage officer withdrew objections after revisions, while several heritage organisations continued to object or requested further detail.
“Historic England: Originally objected. Supportive of bringing this important site back into beneficial use, however further information was required to justify design choices, the demolition of the Well House and understanding of impacts to historic fabric. The objection was withdrawn following submission of revised and additional information. The revised approach has reduced the level of demolition, and a robust justification of the works has been submitted.”
“Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings: Initially raised objections to the proposal due to demolition of interior and parts of the exterior of the buildings, leaving very little remaining. Raised the need to protect the remaining historic fabric, lack of justification for the changes from the approved scheme and insufficient detail. Further comments continued the objection.”
Officer report
The committee decision
The committee delegated permission subject to a legal agreement, a deferred contributions mechanism, the listed financial contributions and conditions.
“RESOLVED to delegate to the Head of Service (City Development) to GRANT permission subject to completion of a legal agreement under section 106 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 (as amended) to secure the following:”
“Subject to a Deferred Contributions Mechanism:”
Minutes
Councillors at the meeting
- Paul KnottChairLab Co-op
- Gemma RolstoneLabour
- Marina AsvachinLabour
- Yvonne AtkinsonLabour
- James BanyardGreen
- Jakir HussainLab Co-op
- Michael MitchellLib Dem
- Liz PoleLabour
- Matthew WilliamsLabour
- Carol BennettSubstitute for KetchinGreen
Apologies Zoë Hughes Independent, Andy Ketchin Green
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Exeter Planning Committee minutes, 19 January 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Exeter's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Committee
- Exeter Planning Committee
- Council
- Exeter
- Date
- Monday 19 January 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Approved
- Vote
- Unanimous
- Councillors
- 10Labour 5Green 2Lab Co-op 2Lib Dem 1Show councillors
- Public speakers
- None
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Exeter committee decisions →
This committee's year
10 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.