Single storey dwelling at Baltic Street West, City of London, London EC1Y
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by City Of London Planning Applications Sub-Committee on 28 Oct 2025.
No officer report was published for this decision; this summary is from the committee minutes.
Permission in principle for a dwelling
The application sought permission in principle for a single storey detached dwelling, garage and gardens on open land at Baltic Street West.
“The Sub-Committee considered a report presenting a planning application which sought permission in principle for the erection of a single storey detached dwelling with a single storey detached garage and gardens.”
“The officer confirmed that the presentation would cover the permission and in principle application for the erection of a self-built single storey dwelling with detached single storey garage and gardens at Baltic St West. It was noted that seeking permission via in principle consent was an alternative way of obtaining planning permission for housing-led development, separating matters of principle from the technical detail of a proposed development permission.”
Minutes
Loss of public open space
The site was publicly accessible open space and a designated footway, and officers considered its loss to a private dwelling unacceptable in principle.
“The application sought permission in principle for a single Storey detached dwelling garage and gardens on the site. The site had been constructed as part of the Golden Lane Estate and was an area of publicly accessible land owned and maintained by the Corporation. It had been designated as a City of London public footway and a permissive path, and was considered by Officers to be open space, as defined by the 2015 Local Plan.”
“The proposed change of the land from an area of publicly accessible open space to a private dwelling was considered unacceptable in principle in land use terms.”
Minutes
Harm to nearby heritage assets
Officers found the development would cause less than substantial harm to the setting of the listed Hatfield House and the Golden Lane Estate park and conservation area.
“Members viewed a visual of the site location produced by the City's offices, which showed that the site was immediately adjacent to, but not within, the Barbican and Golden Lane Estate Conservation Area. The Grade 2 listed Hatfield House and the grade two star listed Crescent House were to the west of the site and the Hat and Feathers and Saint Luke's Conservation Areas in Islington were to the north of the site (but not pictured).”
“A full assessment of the impact of the proposed development on the identified heritage assets had been undertaken (as set out in the officer report), and had concluded that it would likely cause a low level of less than substantial harm to the significance of Hatfield House and slight levels of less than substantial harm to the Golden Lane Estate Registered Park and Garden and the Barbican and Golden Lane Estate Conservation Area.”
Minutes
Harm to trees and residential amenity
Officers considered the development would harm two mature trees on site and create poor amenity through overlooking by the taller Hatfield House.
“The Sub-Committee viewed an image of the south-east of the site, showing the two mature London plane trees, which the application form stated were to be retained. The applicants had also stated, in their representation made on 3rd August, that the use of screwjack foundations would prevent any harm to the trees. This was not standard construction for a dwelling house.”
“Referencing comments submitted by Historic England, officers highlighted that the original designers of the Golden Lane Estate, Chamberlain, Powell and Bon, had produced a shadow diagram as part of their plan to avoid overshadowing between blocks. This had shown the proposed development site to be largely covered in shadow, which was reflective of the existing situation.”
Minutes
Road safety and car-free policy
Officers found the proposal would create road safety risks near the car park access and conflict with car-free policy through the proposed garage.
“Also visible in the image was the mouth of the access road junction with Baltic St West. The site’s location abutting the car park access ramp and junction, made it very likely that the development of a single Storey dwelling garage and gardens on the site would have an unacceptable impact regarding road dangers and the pedestrian environment.”
Minutes
Officers recommended refusal
Officers concluded the proposal was unacceptable in principle due to the loss of open space and its location, scale and impact, recommending refusal.
“It was therefore concluded by officers that the proposed development would be unacceptable in principle on the following two grounds:”
“Secondly, that the proposed location and amount of development would be unacceptable as it would likely: o have an unacceptable impact on the character and appearance of the area by failing to respect the urban grain, layout, scale and building lines of the existing street scene;”
Minutes
A member disputed the site being derelict
A member strongly disagreed that the open space, used by the public with a path and two trees, could be described as derelict.
“Referring to a comment within the Applicant’s written submission which described the current condition of the proposed development site as ‘almost derelict’, a member expressed strong disagreement. The land concerned was an open space used by the public, with a path and two beautiful trees, and in their view, it was wrong to consider such spaces as derelict and useless.”
Minutes
Refused by the sub-committee
The sub-committee voted 20 to 0 to refuse permission in principle for the reasons set out by officers.
“No other Members having indicated a wish to speak, the Chair moved to a vote on the officers’ recommendation that the Planning and Development Director be authorised to issue a decision notice refusing permission in principle for the application.”
“Authorise the Planning and Development Director to issue a decision notice refusing permission in principle for the above proposal, as set out in the schedule in Appendix B of the report, for the following reasons:”
Minutes
The members' reasons
The resolution gives these reasons:
Minutes
- The proposed land use of the site as a private residential dwelling with a parking garage would be unacceptable in principle as it would result in the loss of public open space and would fail to be car free, contrary to Policies G4 and T6.1 of the London Plan 2021, Policies CS19, DM16.2 and DM16.5 of the Local Plan 2015 and Policies S14, OS1 and VT3 of the emerging City Plan 2040.
- The proposed location and amount of development would be unacceptable in principle as it would likely: have an unacceptable impact on the character and appearance of the area by failing to respect the urban grain, layout, scale and building lines of
Source: the council's minutes, quoted word for word.
Councillors at the meeting
- Tom SleighChair
- Shravan Jashvantrai JoshiVice-Chair
- Samapti Bagchi
- John Ernest Edwards
- Alison Gowman
- Prem Goyal
- Josephine Hayes
- Jaspreet Hodgson
- Philip Kelvin
- Elizabeth Anne King
- Charles Edward Lord
- Antony Geoffrey Manchester
- Tim McNally
- Sophia Mooney
- Deborah Oliver
- Henry Pollard
- Gaby Robertshaw
- Hugh Selka
- Naresh Hari Sonpar
- Jacqueline Roberts WebsterLabour
Apologies Tana Adkin, Marianne Bernadette Fredericks, Madush Gupta, Simon Pryke, Nighat Qureishi, Matthew Waters
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- City Of London Planning Applications Sub-Committee minutes, 28 October 2025
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of City Of London's committee minutes. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- City Of London
- Date
- Tuesday 28 October 2025
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended refusal
- Committee decided
- Refused
- Councillors
- 20Labour 119 otherShow councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- City Of London committee decisions →