Two affordable houses at Land at Top Lane, Stourton, Warminster

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by Wiltshire Southern Area Planning Committee on 22 Oct 2026.

PL/2026/04386ApprovedAgainst officer advice

What was proposed

The application sought two single-storey, two-bedroom affordable houses with a new access, parking, turning space and private gardens.

“This application is seeking planning permission for the construction of two 2-bed affordable houses with the formation of a new access off Top Lane and associated on-site car parking provision and turning. The proposal would result in the change of use of the existing site from open countryside to residential use.”

“The proposed layout confirms that each dwelling would benefit from three on-site car parking spaces, with turning space and a private accessible garden to the rear.”

Officer report

The site and surroundings

The greenfield site is in open countryside within the Cranborne Chase National Landscape, beside a public footpath and near listed buildings and woodland.

“The application site relates to a greenfield site in the open countryside to the southwest of the National Trust Stourhead estate. The subject site is accessed via Top Lane, which is also a public right of way (PRoW) footpath (STGA2). There are also two other PRoWs to the east of the site (STGA3 and STGA4), but these would remain unaffected by the proposals.”

“The subject site is located within the Cranborne Chase National Landscape, with the Writh Copse ancient woodland located within 100m south, but the proposal is sited outside of the 15m buffer for the woodland and would not be directly impacting it.”

Officer report

Earlier rural housing decisions

A nearby four-home affordable housing scheme was approved by members but later quashed after a judicial review and withdrawn.

“The proposal would therefore result in unsustainable residential development in the open countryside of the AONB landscape; have significant highway and visual implications; and would be unlikely to result in the provision of suitable affordable housing. The proposal would therefore be contrary to Wiltshire Core Strategy Core Policy CP1, CP2, CP44, CP51, and Annex 2(a) of the NPPF 2019 and the guidance for Build to Rent in the NPPG.”

“However, Members resolved to approve the application, subject to the completion of a Section 106 legal agreement. Following the issue of the decision, a Judicial Review was brought by a neighbouring resident. This resulted in the planning permission being quashed by the High Court, meaning the site no longer benefited from planning permission. The application was subsequently withdrawn by the applicant.”

Officer report

Why officers advised refusal

Officers found insufficient evidence of current local need, affordable housing status, lasting eligibility controls and a suitable settlement relationship.

“The PPG encourages the setting of rent levels and eligibility criteria for private affordable Build to Rent units in the S106 Agreement. The Council would therefore expect to restrict the rent to Local Housing Allowance level and to specify a maximum household income within eligibility criteria in order to ensure that the units remain affordable.”

Officer report

What consultees and residents said

The parish council and 27 residents supported the proposal, while highways and housing officers objected and ecology requested further information.

“Stourton with Gasper Parish Council: Supports the application, “as there is a need for affordable housing for local people in the parish. From the outside the buildings are well screened and the council are satisfied with the outside lighting in regard to International Dark Sky Reserve compliance. Internally, accessibility needs have been met for older residents or those with mobility issues.”

Officer report

Who spoke

Three public speakers, a parish councillor and the local unitary councillor spoke in support of the application.

What members debated

Members debated local housing need, allocation arrangements, sustainability, policy compliance, community land trusts and the strength of local support.

“It was noted that the most recent comparable proposals approved by Members had been departures from officer recommendations. Members expressed concern about maintaining compliance with Council affordable housing policy and sought clarification on the implications of proposed changes to tenants' rights legislation.”

“A debate followed where members discussed whether the application was compliant with policy requirements, with reference made to community land trusts established across the country to deliver affordable housing in accordance with legislative and policy frameworks, with the view expressed th at such mechanisms existed for a reason.”

Minutes

The committee vote

The chair moved approval against the officer recommendation, seconded by Councillor Sven Hocking; a waiting-list condition did not gain majority support.

“Following technical questions, the Chairman moved to debate, moving a moti on of Approval against Officer recommendation from the Chair. This was seconded by Cllr Sven Hocking.”

“The Committee considered an additional condition restricting the allocation of suitable tenants to those on the Wiltshire Council housing waiting list. The proposal did not receive majority support and was therefore not pursued as a condition.”

Minutes

The decision

Planning permission was granted subject to a Section 106 agreement, approved plans, a three-year limit and conditions covering construction, drainage, biodiversity, landscaping, lighting and access.

“The Committee agreed that planning permission be granted, subject to the completion of a Section 106 Legal Agreement, to secure affordable housing tenure by the applicant Stourhead Estate, on similar terms to that secured for the Gasper development, and the submitted Allocation policy with authority delegated to officers to complete the agreement.”

“In the event that the agreement was not completed within the prescribed timeframe, authority was delegated to officers to refuse the application. Permission was further subject to standard three-year commencement and approved plans conditions, together with conditions relating to the approval of materials, a Construction Management Plan, a Biodiversity Gain Plan, a Landscape Plan, external lighting to achieve E0 standards, the provision of access and turning areas prior to…”

Minutes

Why the committee approved it

Members gave weight to the local support, the parish’s rural circumstances and the proposal’s intended contribution to affordable housing for local people.

“It was noted that Officers had clearly identified the policy concerns, and questions were raised as to why pre-application advice had not been followed. Concern was also expressed that a Section 106 Agreement alone would not adequately address the issues identified. Members noted the significant level of local support for the proposal and the absence of objections.”

“In considering the balance of planning issues, Members commented that the proposal would provide two modest, energy-efficient homes for local people and noted the strong support expressed by both the local community and Parish Council.”

Minutes

The members' reasons

“Other Members considered that community land trust arrangements were not necessary in this instance, arguing that local communities should be able to pursue solutions to meet their own housing needs without creating additional structures.”

Minutes

Source: the council's minutes, quoted word for word.

Councillors at the meeting

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.

Sources

  • Wiltshire Southern Area Planning Committee minutes, 22 October 2026
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of Wiltshire's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Council
Wiltshire
Date
Thursday 22 October 2026
Recommendation
Officers recommended refusal
Committee decided
Approved, against officer advice
Councillors
10Conservative 4Lib Dem 3Independent 1Independent 1Reform UK 1Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)

This committee's year

7 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 6 against officer advice.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →