Replacement dwelling at Corner Cottage Chalets, Higher Town

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by Full Council on 15 Oct 2026.

P/26/073/FULApproved

What was proposed

The application proposed demolishing two chalets and building a single-storey, two-bedroom replacement dwelling with landscaping and sustainability measures.

“Information Classification: PUBLIC Purpose of the report 1. This application has been brought before Full Council following a call-in request from the local St Martin's Councillor. The purpose of this report is to assess the proposal, having regard to the Development Plan and all other material planning considerations, and to provide Members with a recommendation on an application seeking the demolition of two existing chalets and the construction of a replacement dwelling…”

“The proposed dwelling would comprise a single-storey building positioned broadly on the footprint of the existing chalets, as shown in the extracted plans in Figure 1 below. The amended proposal would provide approximately 90m² of gross internal floor area and comprise two bedrooms, open-plan living accommodation and ancillary domestic facilities. The building would be constructed using a timber frame with dark-stained timber cladding and a natural slate roof.”

Officer report

The site and its setting

The site is a screened plot within Higher Town’s settlement boundary, the Conservation Area and the Isles of Scilly National Landscape.

“Figure 2 Amended Elevations Site Description 7. The application site comprises two existing chalet buildings and associated garden land at Corner Cottage Chalets, Higher Town, St Martin's, as shown in figure 2 below. The two chalets are flat roof buildings, roughly square with a shared outside WC, constructed in the 1960s. The site is located within the settlement boundary of Higher Town and is accessed from the adjoining public lane.”

“Figure 3 View of the existing chalets 8. The site lies within the Conservation Area and Isles of Scilly National Landscape. Nearby heritage assets include the Grade II listed Corner Cottage, Evergreen and Melinda Terrace and North Farmhouse. The site is not affected by any statutory ecological or flood risk designations.”

Officer report

Earlier permissions and use

Earlier records include permissions for chalet accommodation and a replacement dwelling, but the existing chalets’ precise historic status and occupancy remain unclear.

“The planning history also indicates that outline planning permission was previously granted under reference P2828 in 1989 for the demolition of chalets and their replacement with a permanent dwelling at "Ginny's Chalets", Higher Town, St Martin's.”

“Consequently, whilst there is evidence of historic planning permissions relating to chalet accommodation on the site and a previous consent for replacement with a dwelling, the precise planning status and historic occupancy of the existing chalets remains unclear from the available records. It is assumed and it is highly likely that the chalets were primarily used as holiday letting accommodation.”

Officer report

What officers recommended

Officers recommended approval subject to conditions and a legal agreement restricting occupation to people meeting local housing criteria in perpetuity.

“The applicant has provided additional information demonstrating the intended occupation of the dwelling in connection with existing employment and business activities on St Martin's and has agreed to enter into a Section 106 Agreement to secure occupation in accordance with the Council's Local Housing Need policies.”

“Information Classification: PUBLIC 109. That Members (1) approve planning permission for application P/26/073/FUL for the reasons set out in this report, subject to: I. the planning conditions set out in Appendix A; and II.”

Officer report

The main planning issues

The assessment considered local housing need, loss of visitor accommodation, design and landscape effects, heritage, amenity, ecology, archaeology and drainage.

“Information Classification: PUBLIC 36. The assessment below considers the proposal against the relevant provisions of the Development Plan, national planning policy and all other material considerations, having particular regard to the principle of replacing existing chalet accommodation with a permanent dwelling, local housing need and occupancy restrictions, the loss of visitor accommodation, design, scale and appearance, effects on the Isles of Scilly National Landscape,…”

“As noted above, Policy LC7 supports new homes on the off-islands where they meet a Local Housing Need specific to that island, whilst Policy LC8 supports replacement dwellings subject to considerations of scale, sustainability, site capacity and design. In addition, Policy WC5 seeks to support a sustainable visitor economy and requires consideration of proposals resulting in the loss of visitor accommodation.”

Officer report

What people said

The representations included twelve objections, one supporting letter and two comments, covering housing, precedent, infrastructure, drainage and local character.

“Highlights the shortage of housing and available land on St Martin's and considers that opportunities for new homes should prioritise local housing need and staff accommodation. Suggests restrictions should be imposed to secure permanent occupation. [name withheld] how a non-resident has obtained access to land to construct what is perceived to be a second home. Refers to the housing shortage on the Isles of Scilly and concerns regarding precedent.”

“Information Classification: PUBLIC home. Raises concerns regarding precedent, the siting of the proposed foul drainage infrastructure in relation to the North Farm Borewell, and the potential impact on established access arrangements serving the borewell. 14. Overall, a total of 12 objections, 1 letter of support and 2 comments have been received.”

Officer report

What members discussed

Members discussed whether the proposal complied with local policy and how the local-occupancy legal agreement would be monitored.

“The Chief Planning Officer replied that once the Section 106 agreement was in place the application would be compliant with local policy.”

“Councillor Mrs A Mumford said that St Martin’s were in need of local accommodation and there were many issues raised in the representations, among them from the previous Chairman of Council Christine Savill, who believed that the application was not compliant with the Local Policy.”

Minutes

The committee vote

The recommendations were proposed, seconded and passed.

“The recommendations in the report were proposed by Councillor LB and were seconded by the DM and were passed Resolved:”

“That members APPROVE the application for the reasons set out in the report SUBJECT to: I. The conditions set out in Appendix A; and II. The completion of a Section 106 legal agreement, within 6 months of the date…”

Minutes

The decision

The application was approved subject to the listed conditions, completion of the legal agreement within six months and delegated authority for related arrangements.

“Resolved: 1. That members APPROVE the application for the reasons set out in the report SUBJECT to: I. The conditions set out in Appendix A; and II. The completion of a Section 106 legal agreement, within 6 months of the date…”

Minutes

Councillors at the meeting

Proposed by Councillor Lynn Blackwell, seconded by Councillor Harry Legg.

Apologies John Peacock Independent, Tim Dean Independent, Robert Dorrien-Smith Independent, Stuart Nixon Independent, Alex Sandford Independent

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.

Sources

  • Full Council minutes, 15 October 2026
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of Scilly Isles's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Committee
Full Council
Date
Thursday 15 October 2026
Recommendation
Officers recommended approval
Committee decided
Approved
Councillors
11Independent 11Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)

This committee's year

11 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →