9 homes at Land Off Withybed Lane, Alvechurch
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Bromsgrove Planning Committee on 4 Dec 2025.
No officer report was published for this decision; this summary is from the committee minutes.
What was proposed
Permission in Principle was sought for up to nine dwellings on land off Withybed Lane.
“25/01151/PIP - PERMISSION IN PRINCIPLE FOR UP TO NO9 DWELLINGS. LAND OFF WITHYBED LANE, ALVECHURCH. MR. C. BRAIN”
“Officers presented the report and in doing so highlighted that the application was for Permission in Principle (PiP) for up to 9 dwellings at land off Withybed Lane, Alvechurch.”
Minutes
A Green Belt field
The site was a field in the Green Belt in equine use, bounded by a railway line, a canal and an unclassified lane.
“The site comprised of a field measuring just under 0.5 hectares and was located within the Green Belt. A railway line was situated beyond the site's eastern boundary, and the Worcester and Birmingham Canal formed the sites western boundary. The unclassified road Withybed Lane forms the northern boundary from which vehicular access was proposed.”
“The site contained a number of fairly modest buildings and relatively low fencing. The site was currently in equine use. The buildings were located in close proximity to the site boundaries adjacent to both the railway line and canal, leaving the majority of the site open and laid to grass. Having regard to the modest scale and location of the existing development, the site had a predominately open and rural character.”
Minutes
No objections from key bodies
County Highways, regulatory services, Network Rail, the Canal Trust and archaeology all raised no objections.
“The application itself had received no objections from Worcestershire County Council (WCC), Highways, Worcestershire Regulatory Services and (WRS), Environmental Health concerning contamination and noise. There were no objections from Network Rail or the Canal Trust; and no objections from WCC Archaeology.”
Minutes
Objections received
Nearby neighbours and the Parish Council objected, raising concerns about the impact on the Green Belt and the highway network.
“Officers referred to the objections received from nearby neighbours and Alvechurch Parish Council, with concerns raised on impact on the Green Belt and the impact on the highway network.”
Minutes
Grey Belt classification
Officers considered the site met the new Grey Belt test in national policy, making nine dwellings acceptable.
“The application form sets out that the Agent considered the most appropriate exception to consider was 'Grey Belt' under paragraph 155 of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), details of which were shown on page 74 of the main agenda pack.”
“It was considered that the site was Grey Belt and would meet the requirements of Paragraph 155 of the NPPF and that 9 dwellings was acceptable.”
Minutes
Officers recommended approval
The application was recommended for approval.
“Therefore, the application was recommended for approval.”
Minutes
Who addressed the committee
An objector spoke, the Parish Council's objection was read out, and the ward councillor also addressed the committee in objection.
Landscape and encroachment concerns
Members raised an earlier landscape assessment showing high impact on the area and queried whether the development would encroach on the countryside.
“Members queried as to why a landscape assessment was not required, because a district-wide landscape assessment was undertaken on behalf of the Council by consultants in February 2022. Some Members had referred to their report prior to the meeting commencing. The report had included an assessment of the whole of that strip along the canal…”
“Hence Members having expressed their concerns that no detailed landscape assessment was being undertaken, since the location had a high landscape sensitivity, this site was not a suitable location for such a development. WCC Highways in their letter of 2022 had objected on two accounts, with the access layout being unacceptable and also on sustainability grounds.”
Minutes
Refused against officer advice
The committee refused the application, against the officer recommendation to approve, finding severe harm to the landscape and unacceptable encroachment on the Green Belt with no special circumstances to outweigh it.
“Having reconvened, Councillor M. Marshall proposed an alternative recommendation to refuse Permission in Principle, on being put to the vote, it was…”
“Severe harm to the cultural heritage, natural heritage and distinctiveness of the landscape and consequent encroachment on the countryside representing unacceptable development in the green belt, and no special circumstances existed to outweigh this harm.”
Minutes
The members' reasons
The members' reasons are quoted from the minutes above, under “Refused against officer advice”.
Councillors at the meeting
- H. J. JonesChairConservative
- M. MarshallVice-ChairLabour
- A. BailesIndependent
- J. ClarkeLib Dem
- D. J. A. ForsytheConservative
- E. M. S. GrayLabour
- R. E. LambertConservative
- S. R. PetersIndependent
- RobinsonLib Dem
- J. D. StanleyConservative
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Bromsgrove Planning Committee minutes, 4 December 2025
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Bromsgrove's committee minutes. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Committee
- Bromsgrove Planning Committee
- Council
- Bromsgrove
- Date
- Thursday 4 December 2025
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Refused, against officer advice
- Councillors
- 10Conservative 4Independent 2Labour 2Lib Dem 2Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Bromsgrove committee decisions →
This committee's year
10 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 2 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.