Primary electricity substation at Proposed Development East Of Guardbridge Primary, Guardbridge
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Fife Planning Committee; West and Central Area Planning Committee; North East Planning Committee on 19 Aug 2026.
What was proposed
The application proposed a primary electricity substation, transformers, switchgear, a smaller substation, fencing, lighting, landscaping and acoustic screening.
“This application is for the formation of a primary electricity sub-station and associated works. The proposed substation would be located directly to the south of the existing substation building and would include various plant and machinery including 2 x transformers (33/11kv 32 MVA Low Noise Midel filled), switchgear and batteries.”
“A smaller secondary substation is also proposed within the south-western part of the site. The substation equipment would be located within a metal cabinet unit and would measure approximately 4 metres wide x 2 metres deep x 2.5 metres high. Floodlights measuring approximately 5 metres high would also be located within the compound between the switchgear building and transformer equipment.”
Officer report
The site and surroundings
The site was a mostly hardstanding parking area near homes, a primary school, the Eden Campus, a listed building and protected natural areas.
“The application site measures approximately 2760 square metres and is located on Main Street (A919 Distributor Road) within the Guardbridge Settlement Boundary as designated within the Adopted FIFEplan Local Development Plan (2017) (LDP). The site is currently a parking area which was historically used by the former papermill to the east and is covered mostly in hardstanding.”
“The Guardbridge to Leuchars Core Path (Path Code: P038/04 – Guardbridge to Leuchars) runs along Main Street to the east of the site. The Eden Estuary Local Nature Reserve, Firth of Tay and Eden Estuary Special Protection Area, Eden Estuary SSSI and Firth of Tay and Eden Estuary Ramsar Site are located between approximately 75 and 110 metres to the north and east of the site.”
Officer report
Earlier planning history
Earlier permissions covered housing, temporary storage, an existing substation and redevelopment of the former papermill site for university and business uses.
“- Full planning permission (16/00848/FULL) for erection of substation building, transformer and installation of underground electricity cable was approved with conditions on 11th May 2016. The underground cable connected the substation to an area within the former papermill site to the east which is now the Guardbridge Energy Centre. This substation has been built and would be located to the north of the proposed substation compound. A non-material variation…”
“- Planning permission in principle (14/01933/PPP) for the redevelopment of former papermill for university (class 10) and business-related uses comprising ongoing industrial, storage, distribution and office uses, with research and development (class 4), and associated access, infrastructure, open space and ancillary works associated with the University of St Andrews Sustainable Power and Research Campus was approved with conditions on 27th October 2014.”
Officer report
Why officers recommended approval
Officers considered the proposal acceptable in principle and concluded its impacts on amenity, roads, flooding, heritage, nature and sustainability could be managed.
“The report further advises that Site 1 would have resulted in greater environmental and amenity impacts, including the loss of existing vegetation and increased visibility from surrounding public areas.”
“As the proposal is located within the Guardbridge Settlement Boundary, as defined by the LDP, there is a presumption in favour of this development in principle, subject to satisfactory details and subject to the overall proposal being compliant with the relevant policies for this location.”
Officer report
Consultees and residents
Most consultees had no objections, while Environmental Health supported approval subject to noise conditions and the Community Council objected.
“Natural Heritage, Planning Services No objections TDM, Planning Services No objections Land And Air Quality, Protective Services No objections subject to a condition regarding contaminated land. Scottish Environment Protection Agency Advised to review SEPA’s Standing Advice Note.”
“Scottish Water No objections Environmental Health (Public Protection) No objections subject to condition relating to noise rating levels. Community Council Object…”
Officer report
The decision
“Decision The committee refused the application on the grounds that the proposed development was contrary to Policies 14 and 23 of National Planning Framework 4 (NPF4) (2023) and Policies 1 and 10 of the Adopted FIFEplan Local Development Plan (2017) – as the proposed development would result in an adverse impact on the residential amenity of the occupants of the nearby residential properties due to potential noise disturbance not currently experienced. Councillor Kennedy-Dalby returned to the meeting following consideration of the above item. 333.”
Minutes, 19 Aug 2026
The members' reasons
The members' reasons are quoted from the minutes above, under “The decision”.
Councillors at the meeting
- Jonny TeppChairLib Dem
- John Andrew CaffreyLib Dem
- Al ClarkDeclared an interestLib Dem
- Fiona CorpsLib Dem
- Sean Frazer DillonLib Dem
- Alycia HayesSNP
- Gary HoltLib Dem
- Louise Kennedy-DalbyDeclared an interestSNP
- Allan KnoxLib Dem
- Robin LawsonDeclared an interestConservative
- Jane Ann ListonLib Dem
- David MacdiarmidSNP
- Ann VernerSNP
Apologies Margaret Kennedy Lib Dem, Donald Lothian Lib Dem
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from Democracy Club.
Sources
- Fife Planning Committee; West and Central Area Planning Committee; North East Planning Committee minutes, 19 August 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Fife's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Committee
- Fife Planning Committee; West and Central Area Planning Committee; North East Planning Committee
- Council
- Fife
- Date
- Wednesday 19 August 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Refused, against officer advice
- Councillors
- 13Lib Dem 8SNP 4Conservative 1Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Fife committee decisions →
This committee's year
41 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 2 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.