Care home and housing at James Towers Way, Broughton, Preston

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by Preston Planning Committee on 4 Dec 2025.

06/2025/0519Refused

What was proposed

The application sought access-only outline permission for housing, a care home, a community building, school land, landscaping and green infrastructure.

“Land to the south of Whittingham Lane and west of James Towers Way, Broughton, Preston…”

“Outline planning application seeking approval for access only from Whittingham Lane (all other matters reserved) for the erection of a care home (up to 4,700sqm), a community building (up to 400sqm), residential development (up to 167no. dwellings) and land reserved for primary school with associated works to include landscaping and green infrastructure.”

Officer report

The site

The site comprised open fields outside Broughton’s settlement boundary, within open countryside and an Area of Separation, with part allocated for housing.

“Location The application site relates to a series of open fields measuring 21.5 hectares which run north to south for a distance of approximately 0.8km on land to the west of the Broughton Bypass (James Towers Way). On its eastern boundary the site is bound by the Broughton and District Club to the north with a new residential development for 129no. homes (approved at appeal under application ref 06/2017/0097) and the Marriott Hotel located further south.”

“The application site is located within the open countryside outside of the defined village settlement boundary of Broughton, and within an area of separation, as identified on the Policies Map of the Preston Local Plan. The whole of the application site lies within the Broughton Neighbourhood Development Plan area, and it is partially allocated for residential development under Policy RES1.”

Officer report

Earlier applications

An earlier application for 81 homes was refused, while nearby housing applications included one approved and one allowed on appeal.

“Relevant planning history 06/2021/0423 - Outline planning application seeking approval for access only for residential development for up to 81no. dwellings with associated works (all other matters reserved). Refused 05/10/2021.”

“06/2017/0097 - Outline application for residential development for up to 130 houses with access considered. Refused and allowed at appeal 03/04/2018 (ref APP/N2345/W/17/3179177).”

Officer report

What officers recommended

Officers recommended refusal because the proposal conflicted with countryside and separation policies and lacked sufficient transport evidence and sustainable travel provision.

“Reasons for refusal 1. The application site is located in the open countryside as shown on the policies map of the Preston Local Plan 2012-2026 (Site Allocations and Development Management Policies). The proposed development would be contrary to the hierarchy of locations for focussing growth and investment at urban, brownfield and allocated sites, within key service centres and other defined places.”

“The site is located within an Area of Separation between the urban area of Preston and the village of Broughton. The proposed development would result in the loss of a valuable part of this Area of Separation and would consequently have an unacceptable detrimental impact on the open countryside character of the area to a degree that would materially compromise the function of the Area of Separation in protecting the identity and distinctiveness of Broughton as a village,…”

Officer report

What consultees said

National Highways and county highways raised transport concerns, education sought school-place contributions, and several consultees had no objection subject to conditions.

“Consultation responses National Highways – National Highways (NH) originally commented on the application on 19 th June 2025 and raised several issues with the details included within the applicant’s transport assessment. NH confirmed that they were not currently in a position to form a final view on these proposals because the information presented with the application is non-policy compliant in terms of the impact on the Strategic Road Network (SRN) and the M55 and…”

“County Education – Object to the application in terms of school space provision but confirm their objection would be withdrawn if financial contributions were secured through the proposed development for the provision of 63 primary school places and 25 secondary school places.”

Officer report

What people said

The parish council supported the scheme for its community benefits, while four objectors cited infrastructure, traffic congestion and loss of greenspace.

“Publicity – Four letters of objection were received and the following concerns raised: • Broughton does not have the infrastructure to support more housing development at this scale. • Proposals will result in increased traffic congestion in the area. • Proposals will result in more loss of greenspace around Broughton.”

Officer report

The main planning concerns

Officers found the development fundamentally conflicted with the development plan, harmed the separation between Broughton and Preston, and lacked adequate transport information.

“The application site directly adjoins the eastern boundary of Broughton with the next nearest settlement to the south being the Preston urban area approximately 0.9km away. The proposals would have a clear impact on the effectiveness of the existing gap between the settlement of Broughton to the north and the main urban area of Preston to the south, given the amount of land the proposed scheme would cover.”

“Core Strategy Policy 1 and Local Plan Policy EN1 are up-to-date policies and the conflict with these policies should be given significant weight. Core Strategy Policy 1 and Local Plan Policy EN1 are not policies which address landscape and visual impact, but are spatial policies which are central to the development plans’ aims to deliver sustainable patterns of development, concentrating development in the most sustainable locations and resisting development in the least…”

Officer report

The committee vote

All 10 members voted in favour of the resolution to refuse the application.

“The application is located in close proximity to the M55, which form part of the Strategic Road Network (SRN). In the absence of sufficient trip generation and trip distribution data as well as suitable traffic and operational assessments the applicant has failed to demonstrate the proposals would have an acceptable impact on the SRN.”

“All Members (10) voted in favour of the resolution.”

Minutes

The decision

The committee refused the application because it would expand the village into open countryside, harm the Area of Separation and fail to demonstrate acceptable transport impacts.

“The application site is located in the open countryside as shown on the policies map of the Preston Local Plan 2012-2026 (Site Allocations and Development Management Policies). The proposed development would be contrary to the hierarchy of locations for focussing growth and investment at urban, brownfield and allocated sites, within key service centres and other defined places.”

“4 December 2025 2. The site is located within an Area of Separation between the urban area of Preston and the village of Broughton. The proposed development would result in the loss of a valuable part of this Area of Separation and would consequently have an unacceptable detrimental impact on the open countryside character of the area to a degree that would materially compromise the function of the Area of Separation in protecting the identity and distinctiveness of…”

Minutes

Councillors at the meeting

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.

Sources

  • Preston Planning Committee minutes, 4 December 2025
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of Preston's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Council
Preston
Date
Thursday 4 December 2025
Recommendation
Officers recommended refusal
Committee decided
Refused
Councillors
11Labour 6Lib Dem 4Conservative 1Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)

This committee's year

27 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 2 against officer advice.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →