Residential garden and polytunnel at Smithy House, Penny Bridge, Ulverston
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Westmorland And Furness South Lakeland Local Area Planning Committee on 22 Oct 2026.
What was proposed
The application sought retrospective permission to change a pony paddock into a residential garden and retain a polytunnel.
“SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATION 1.1 Full planning permission is sought for the retrospective change of use of land from pony paddock (Use Class Sui Generis) to residential garden (Use Class C3) and erection of polytunnel. The site comprises of a sloping field to the rear of residential properties now being laid out as a garden for domestic use with a polytunnel constructed and sited to the rear of an adjacent dwelling, Piper Hill.”
Officer report
The site and surroundings
The sloping site lies behind homes, with the polytunnel close to Piper Hill, whose conservatory is at a lower level.
“The polytunnel consists of metal hoops fixed to the ground and translucent polythene sheeting with green windbreak netting fitted to the lower sections of the east and west elevations. SITE DESCRIPTION 3.1 The application site lies to the rear of residential dwellings lying along the main road on the edge of the settlement of Penny Bridge. The land slopes from the west down towards residential properties along the eastern boundary with the A5092.”
“The application site is broadly a ‘L’ shaped piece of land with part of the land running directly behind a two-storey dwelling to the southern boundary known as Piper Hill. This property has a conservatory extension to the rear and sits at a slightly lower level than the application site. A conifer hedge which has been reduced in height separates the application site from Piper Hill.”
Officer report
What officers recommended
Officers recommended refusal because the polytunnel’s location, height, appearance and elevated position would create an overbearing effect on Piper Hill.
“Due to the difference in levels/height between the application site/location of the polytunnel and the rear of Piper Hill, the polytunnel can be seen in close proximity to the rear elevation and conservatory from Piper Hill. Whilst there is a conifer hedge on the boundary that belongs to Piper Hill, this does not override the need to still consider the effect of the development/polytunnel on the nearby residential property.”
“Due to the use of the opaque sheeting material, it is accepted that there is no direct overlooking or loss of privacy from overlooking between the polytunnel and Piper Hill with a possible similar level of use to a pony paddock/the last use.”
Officer report
Consultation and public views
The parish council had no objections; four letters supported the proposal and one objected to the polytunnel’s position, height and amenity impact.
“CONSULTATIONS 5.1 Egton-with-Newland, Mansriggs & Osmotherley Parish Council have no objections.”
“REPRESENTATIONS 6.1 Four letters of support and one letter of objection have been received. In summary: 6.2 In support: letters from Meadow View, Church Hill House, Crake View House and Flass View Farmhouse, all in Penny Bridge - - support the applicant with self-sufficiency. - do not find the polytunnel obtrusive. - applicant enters local horticultural show with produce from the polytunnel. - significant improvement to land likely to become overgrown.”
Officer report
Who spoke
The applicant and the agent spoke in support of the application, and the applicant answered members’ questions about screening and the hedge.
Members’ discussion
Members supported the change of use but debated the polytunnel’s prominent location, screening, limited alternative siting and the level of harm.
“Members noted their support for the change of use but highlighted that the tunnel was in a prominent location in relation to the neighbouring property. It was clarified that there were no permitted development rights in the field and that the polytunnel was not a moveable structure.”
“Members debated the application, noting that whilst they supported the application overall, they recognised the need for screening to limit harm caused by its location and size.”
Minutes
The committee’s decision
The committee approved the application, finding limited intrusive harm that did not outweigh its benefits, subject to landscaping and removal of permitted development rights.
“A motion to approve the application was received with the following reason given: the proposal was not overbearing to the neighbour but did cause some harm due to its intrusive nature. However, the limited harm did not outweigh the benefit of the proposal and the proposal was considered acceptable subject to a landscaping condition to mitigate the visual intrusion and a condition for the removal of permitted development rights.”
“(1) Planning permission be granted as the Committee felt that that the proposal was not overbearing to the neighbour but did cause some harm due to its intrusive nature. The limited harm did not outweigh the benefit of the proposal and therefore, the proposal was considered acceptable subject to a landscaping condition to mitigate the visual intrusion and removal of permitted development rights.”
Minutes
The members' reasons
“A vote was taken and it was RESOLVED, that:- (1) Planning permission be granted as the Committee felt that that the proposal was not overbearing to the neighbour but did cause some harm due to its intrusive nature.”
Minutes
Source: the council's minutes, quoted word for word.
Councillors at the meeting
- Philip DixonChairLib Dem
- Rupert AudlandVice-ChairLib Dem
- Tim BloomerLib Dem
- Jenny BoakLib Dem
- Judy FilmoreIndependent
- Vicky HughesLib Dem
- Helen IrvingConservative
Apologies Doug Rathbone Lib Dem
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Westmorland And Furness South Lakeland Local Area Planning Committee minutes, 22 October 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Westmorland And Furness's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- Westmorland And Furness
- Date
- Thursday 22 October 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended refusal
- Committee decided
- Approved, against officer advice
- Councillors
- 7Lib Dem 5Conservative 1Independent 1Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Westmorland And Furness committee decisions →
This committee's year
37 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 4 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.