22-bedroom HMO at The Smithfield Hotel, Oswestry
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Shropshire Northern Planning Committee on 16 Sept 2025.
What was proposed
The application sought to change the former hotel into a 22-bedroom HMO, with single occupancy bedrooms, communal facilities and seven parking spaces.
“The submitted application is for the change of use of the former Smithfield Hotel into a large House of Multiple Occupation (HMO) containing 22 bedrooms.”
“During the course of the application the applicant amended the submitted plans to detail that all of the bedrooms would have single beds and confirmed that the premises would have a maximum number of occupants of 22, one per bedroom. It is considered reasonable for the application to be considered on this basis which could then be secured by a condition.”
Officer report
The site
The vacant three-storey Georgian building stands on a prominent town-centre corner and is considered a non-designated heritage asset.
“The application site is the former Smithfield Hotel, a three-storey Georgian building located at the junction of English Walls and Salop Road. Historically known as The Bear Hotel and later the Bullring Bar, the building has been vacant…”
Officer report
Earlier permissions
Permissions were granted for seven apartments in 2017 and 2021, but the apartments were not completed or occupied.
“In 2017 the building had planning permission to be converted into 7 apartments comprising 4 x 1-bed and 3 x 3-bed apartments. A further scheme was approved in 2021 to revise the scheme to 3 x 3-bed and 4 x 2-bed units (21/02940/VAR). This planning permission was implemented by carrying out a small amount of the approved works however for reasons unknown none of the apartments were completed and the building has remained un-occupied.”
Officer report
What officers recommended
Officers recommended approval, finding that the proposal would provide low-cost housing, reuse the building, preserve its future and avoid unreasonable highway harm.
“7 Conclusion 7.1 The proposed development involves refurbishing the existing building to create low-cost residential accommodation intended to help meet the county’s housing needs. The proposal aligns with government policies aimed at increasing the supply of homes, and the site is located within a market town identified as suitable for new housing development in the adopted SAMDev Plan and Core Strategy.”
“The proposed development would bring the building back into an active use having sat unoccupied for a significant number of years; helping to secure its future. The building is a non-designated heritage asset located in the conservation area where if the building remained unused for a sustained period it is likely to lead to its continued deterioration.”
Officer report
Consultees’ views
The town council objected, while highways suggested parking management and ecology and conservation officers raised no objection subject to conditions.
“Members highlighted the following material concerns: - The proposal would result in a large HMO, it is out of keeping for the location, of high density and would represent excessive development; - Lack of sufficient facilities for the management of waste; - The lack of car parking on site and the unsuitability of central car park to provide parking for residents; - Lack of outdoor amenity space; - Suitability of the kitchen provision for the number of rooms; - Little…”
“Conservation- No objection to the proposal from a heritage perspective and subject to a suitable conservation-led conditions which respect the visual contribution the building makes to the CA. It is considered that no harm to the character and appearance of the CA or the adjacent listed building should arise as a result of the proposal.”
Officer report
Who spoke
A member of the public and the town council’s clerk spoke against the proposal, while the applicant’s agent spoke in support.
Members’ concerns
Members recognised the vacant building and housing benefits but questioned the intensity, parking, amenity space, surrounding services and heritage impact.
“During the ensuing debate, Members of the committee acknowledged the benefits of the proposed development, in that it would bring a disused building back into use and it would bring much needed accommodation to the town, however concern was expressed at the intensity of the development, commenting that the buildings previously accommodated 16 bedrooms as a hotel and this would be increased to 22.”
“Having considered the submitted plans and listened to the comments made by all of the speakers, members unanimously expressed their opposition to the proposed development for the reasons outlined above.”
Minutes
The decision
Members unanimously refused permission, contrary to the officer recommendation, because of over-intensification, parking, amenity space and heritage impacts.
“RESOLVED: That planning permission be refused, contrary to the officer’s recommendation. Reason: The proposed development was over intensification of the building, the lack of parking, lack of amenity space, the impact on the Oswestry conservation area and the heritage asset.”
Minutes
The members' reasons
The members' reasons are quoted from the minutes above, under “The decision”.
Councillors at the meeting
- Julian DeanChairIndependent
- Mark OwenVice-ChairLib Dem
- Andy DavisLib Dem
- Rosemary DartnallLabour
- Greg EbbsLib Dem
- Brian EvansReform UK
- Adam FejferLib Dem
- Gary GrovesLib Dem
- Ed PotterConservative
- Rosie RadfordLib Dem
- Carl RowleyReform UK
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Shropshire Northern Planning Committee minutes, 16 September 2025
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Shropshire's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- Shropshire
- Date
- Tuesday 16 September 2025
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Refused, against officer advice
- Vote
- Unanimous
- Councillors
- 11Lib Dem 6Reform UK 2Conservative 1Independent 1Labour 1Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Shropshire committee decisions →