Vehicle garage workshop at Shire Cars Limited Main Road, Shurdington, Cheltenham

Summary of planning committee decision

Deferred by Tewkesbury Planning on 15 Sept 2026.

25/00925/FULDeferred

What was proposed

The retrospective application sought a vehicle service and MOT station with reception, canteen, five MOT bays, a service bay, signage and associated works.

“The current proposal seeks; “Retrospective application for the demolition of existing garage business building, and the erection of a new vehicle garage workshop & office/reception building with signage and associated works.”

“The proposed building is designed to facilitate a vehicle service and MOT station. The building includes a single storey pitched roof reception area & canteen, a two storey height (single storey internally) MOT area with 5 bays and a single bay service area contained within a projecting northern gable.”

Officer report

The site and its surroundings

The site lies within Shurdington, beside two homes and two highways, outside the Green Belt and Cotswold National Landscape, with surface water flood risk.

“Shire Cars Limited is located at the Shurdington Road (A46) and Leckhampton Lane junction, Shurdington. The site is located within the Shurdington settlement boundary and falls outside of both the Green Belt and the Cotswold National Landscape (formerly the Cotswold AONB). The site is located in Flood Zone 1 and is shown to have areas at high risk of surface water flooding both now and with the impact of climate change.”

“Two residential dwellings adjoin the site, Tynings Reach (to the north) and Mayville (east). Shurdington Road and Leckhampton Lane, both classified highways, adjoin the western and southern boundaries respectively. The wider developments around the site largely consist of dwellings, but with the Bell Inn and a playing field located on the western side of Shurdington Road immediately to the south west of the site.”

Officer report

Earlier permission and demolition

A 2023 permission allowed an extension to the existing garage, but that building was demolished and officers considered the permission could no longer be implemented.

“Previously, planning permission was granted in 2023 on this site for an “extension to the existing garage business” (ref. 22/00362/FUL). The previous permission permitted extensions to the existing building as it stood in 2023 including a segregated reception, staff facilities and waiting area, a main 5 bay garage (MOT area), a rear single bay ‘service area’ and a covered parking area.”

“The Local Planning Authority (LPA) considers that planning permission ref. 22/00362/FUL can no longer be implemented as a result of the building’s demolition. This is because permission ref. 22/00362/FUL authorised a “proposed extension to existing garage business”, whereas the building was in fact fully demolished – this matter is addressed in greater detail later in this report.”

Officer report

What officers recommended

Officers recommended refusal because the building’s mass, height and proximity would cause unacceptable loss of outlook, light and outdoor amenity at Tynings Reach.

“Notwithstanding the applicant’s proposed amendments to the development, having assessed the resulting amenity impact upon the occupants of Tynings Reach, officers consider the proposed building’s mass, height and proximity to the boundary results in an overbearing development which dominates the southern and western elevations of Tynings Reach, reducing outlook, resulting in an overbearing impact.”

“Officers consider that whilst Tynings Reach does benefit from a modest outdoor amenity space to the north and away from the proposed development, a large proportion of its outdoor amenity space, is nevertheless impacted by the effects of the building as set out above.”

Officer report

Who spoke

A local resident spoke against the application, and the applicant’s agent requested deferral for further legal advice about the change in recommendation and the earlier permission’s weight.

What members discussed

Members discussed the earlier permission, the review of residential amenity, the lack of a fallback position and whether further information should be considered privately.

“PL.15.09.26 defer the application based on Officer advice that further consideration was required regarding material considerations in respect of the application. Another Member sought clarification regarding the Legal Adviser’s earlier comment about the potential need to move into exempt session and was advised that Members and Officers had received a letter from the applicant’s solicitors regarding their concerns, which had also been verbally set out by the applicant’s…”

“As set out in the report, a decision in the planning history would normally be given significant weight as obviously that was an indication that the Council found that development acceptable; however, a review had been conducted following receipt of the complaint and Officers had concluded that amenity had not been sufficiently addressed when the decision was issued and it was thought that should also be put before the Members.”

Minutes

Councillors at the meeting

Apologies Thomas Budge Lib Dem, Paul Smith Lib Dem, Philip Workman Independent

Also attending David Gray Conservative

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.

Sources

  • Tewkesbury Planning minutes, 15 September 2026
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of Tewkesbury's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Council
Tewkesbury
Date
Tuesday 15 September 2026
Recommendation
Officers recommended refusal
Committee decided
Deferred
Councillors
8Conservative 3Lib Dem 3Green 1Independent 1Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)

This committee's year

24 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 1 against officer advice.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →