Four semi-detached homes at United Services Club, Sale
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Trafford Planning and Development Management Committee on 22 Sept 2026.
What was proposed
Four semi-detached three-storey homes were proposed, with a new access, rear parking, landscaping, bin stores and cycle storage.
“The proposed development is considered to be acceptable in terms of design, residential amenity, highways and parking impacts, ecology, accessibility and other matters. Policy S4 (1) [Principle of development within settlements] of the NPPF directs decision-makers when considering development proposals within settlements to grant planning permission unless the benefits of doing so would be substantially outweighed by any adverse effects, when assessed against the national…”
“The proposal would create a new vehicular access with parking, associated landscaping and bin and cycle storage. The four dwellings would be sited on a corner plot at the junction of Southern Road and Park Avenue. The dwellings would be semi-detached with Plots 1 and 2 sited further forward in the plot, with Plots 3 and 4 slightly set back from the site frontage.”
Officer report
The site
The site was a former bowling green beside the United Services Club, surrounded by residential properties and allocated as Protected Open Space.
“This includes the contribution the scheme will make to the Council’s five-year housing land supply through the contribution of four homes in a sustainable location as well as some economic benefit arising from the construction process. It is considered that, applying the test in Policy S4 of the NPPF, the adverse effects of the development would not substantially outweigh the benefits, when assessed against the decision-making policies in the NPPF.”
“The south side of Southern Road comprises predominantly of terraced properties (2 and 2.5 storeys) and the north side of Southern Road comprises of both semi-detached and detached properties. The site does not contain any listed buildings and is not located within a Conservation Area; however, the former bowling green is allocated as Protected Open Space.”
Officer report
Earlier applications
Earlier proposals for homes were refused because of protected open space, parking and design, neighbour amenity, and highway concerns.
“RELEVANT PLANNING HISTORY 112062/FUL/23- Erection of four semi-detached dwellings along with the creation of new vehicle access, parking and associated landscaping. This application was refused on 12/03/2024 for the following reasons: 1.The proposed development would result in an unacceptable loss of an area of Protected Open Space and outdoor sports facilities and the application has failed to demonstrate that the development would not result in a local deficiency of…”
Officer report
Consultation responses
Most consultees raised no objection subject to conditions, while Strategic Planning sought a £135,000 contribution towards local outdoor sports provision.
“Waste Strategy Statement – 28 th April 2026 Landscape Plan – 28 th April 2026 Design and Access Statement, Rev A, 24 th June 2026 Open Space Assessment – 16 th July 2026 CONSULTATIONS GM Ecology Unit (GMEU) - No objection subject to conditions and informative. Local Highway Authority (LHA) – No objection subject to conditions. Lead Local Flood Authority (LLFA) – No objection subject to conditions and informative.”
“This would help to satisfy the local and national planning policies in relation to Protected Open Space. The Strategic Planning team has concluded that an appropriate contribution would be £135,000. United Utilities - No objection subject to condition. REPRESENTATIONS Letters have been posted to neighbours in the vicinity of the application site. A site notice has been posted.”
Officer report
What residents said
Twenty-three representations objected, citing loss of open space, overdevelopment, parking and highway risks, neighbour harm, pollution, biodiversity and construction impacts.
“The comments are summarised below. Loss of Protected Open Space •Site is designated Protected Open Space and should be safeguarded from development. •Claims it is “surplus” are not proven and based on viability, not community need. •Permanent loss of a valuable community asset with no replacement provision. •Limited alternative open space in the area. •Loss of the potential for community use, as a garden area. •Contrary to local and national planning policies.”
“Safety risks to children and disruption during construction. •Loss of community function. Environment •Contribute to air pollution through traffic and construction impacts. •Loss of biodiversity with no meaningful mitigation; fails biodiversity net gain. •Opportunity for ecological enhancements, for example swift bricks not taken.”
Officer report
Committee consideration
Councillors O’Brien and Hartley left because of declared interests; the committee then considered a motion to refuse permission.
“[Note: Councillor O’Brien declared a Personal and Prejudicial Interest in Application 117646/FUL/25 being a Ward Councillor; he removed himself from the Committee and made representations against the Application. He left the room during consideration of the item.]”
“[Councillor Hartley declared a Personal and Prejudicial Interest in Application 117646/FUL/25, due to discussions with residents and views expressed regarding the Application. He left the room during consideration of this item.]”
Minutes
The vote
The motion to refuse planning permission was moved, seconded and carried.
“It was moved and seconded that planning permission be refused.”
“The motion was put to the vote and declared carried.”
Minutes
The decision
Permission was refused because the proposal would unacceptably lose protected open space without demonstrating surplus land or equivalent accessible replacement provision.
“RESOLVED: That planning permission be refused for the following reasons:-”
“The proposed development would result in an unacceptable loss of an area of Protected Open Space and the application fails to demonstrate that the land would be surplus to requirements and would not result in a local deficiency of recreational open space and facilities or that it would be replaced by an area of equivalent or better provision in terms of quantity and quality in a location which offers comparable or improved accessibility for the community it serves.”
Minutes
The members' reasons
The members' reasons are quoted from the minutes above, under “The decision”.
Councillors at the meeting
- Ben HartleyChairDeclared an interest and left for this itemLabour
- Zak DeakinLabour
- Phil EckersleyConservative
- Daniel JerromeGreen
- Sue MaitlandLabour
- Meena MinnisLib Dem
- Tony O'BrienDeclared an interest and left for this itemLabour
- Shirley ProcterLabour
- Clare SheridanLabour
- Michael TaylorConservative
- Gareth TwoseGreen
- James WrightLabour
Apologies Ulrich Savary Lib Dem
Also attending Nathan Evans Conservative, Sarah Haughey Labour, David Jarman Labour, Julian Newgrosh Lib Dem, Natalie Shalom Conservative, Jennie Wadsworth Green
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Trafford Planning and Development Management Committee minutes, 22 September 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Trafford's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- Trafford
- Date
- Tuesday 22 September 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Refused, against officer advice
- Councillors
- 10Labour 5Conservative 2Green 2Lib Dem 1Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Trafford committee decisions →
This committee's year
40 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 5 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.