Listed church community hub at Former, Holy Trinity Church, Colchester
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Colchester Planning Committee on 10 Sept 2026.
What was proposed
The application would update listed building approval for a new operator and revised drawings while creating a refurbished community hub in the former church.
“Description of the Proposal 4.1 The proposal is to update the listed building approval ref: 252042 to reflect amendments required for a new operator. The proposal is also to update the existing building drawings, following external stone and roof repairs under application 250384.”
Officer report
The site and its condition
The site contains a Grade I listed former church and graveyard in a conservation area; the vacant building is on the Heritage at Risk Register.
“Site Description and Context 3.1 The site lies within the Conservation Area and comprises the former Holy Trinity Church and its graveyard. The former church is a Grade I Listed Building. Holy Trinity was made redundant in 1956 and was briefly a museum and later, an arts centre and café. The re-use of the building has struggled to achieve long term viability, with the associated graveyard becoming increasingly cut off from the wider community.”
“DC0901MWeV11 3.2 In 2021, Historic England provided an Advice Note which identified a number of defects which were the reason why the church qualified as being ‘at risk’ and was added to the Heritage at Risk Register.”
Officer report
Earlier approvals and changes
Earlier listed building and planning approvals were granted in 2025, after previous permissions and uses including an arts centre and café.
“Relevant Planning History 6.1 252042 Application for listed building consent for the repair and refurbishment of existing former church building to form new Community Hub, including installation of signage, art sculptures to railings (x8), and wall artwork. (Revised Description) Approved 28.11.25”
“252041 Repair and refurbishment of existing former church building previously used as commercial space and storage, to form new Community Hub with Historic Interpretation experience, including installation of signage, art sculptures to railings (x8), and wall artwork plus drainage works – Approved 4.12.25”
Officer report
Why officers recommended approval
Officers considered that limited heritage harm would be outweighed by repairs, public access, interpretation, community use and the building’s long-term future.
“It is considered that the anticipated harm to significance of the listed building has satisfactorily been mitigated. Further mitigation will be secured by the use of suitable planning conditions similar to those applied previously.”
“As concluded on the previous similar approved scheme, the expected outcomes of the project (repairs, use to secure maintenance income, public accessibility and interpretation) are considered to represent significant public benefits that outweigh the identified harm, to meet the test that is set out in Policy HE6 of the NPPF.”
Officer report
専門?
Historic England supported approval subject to detailed conditions, while the Conservation Officer supported the scheme and the Archaeologist requested existing archaeological conditions.
“To summarise and conclude, we remain supportive of the aims and ambitions of the scheme, which would see the building repaired and given a new lease of life. We are comfortable to reiterate our lack of objection to the revised scheme, subject to the development of the above outlined areas of detail.”
“The building is currently included on Historic England’s Heritage at Risk Register and has been the subject of a long-term project by Colchester City Council to secure its future through repair, conservation and the introduction of a viable new use. The overarching aim of the scheme is to safeguard the historic fabric, ensure the building’s long-term sustainability and return a significant heritage asset to public use.”
Officer report
Objections and concerns
One objector questioned the scheme’s viability and raised concerns about the mezzanine, toilets, fire escape, heating, alterations and harm to the listed building.
“However, in section under the heading “Summery of projected Income and Expenditure Primary scenario (from the Business Plan)" the figures presented are critical to the application as they should express the public good that will come from using the building and making it financially viable. • Changes proposed will harm Church’s character, particularly from the introduction of a balcony, free standing toilet and fire escape to the Grade one Listed Building.”
“DC0901MWeV11 attractive windows and demands a fire escape. The fire escape requires cutting a large opening beneath the east window of the north chapel. This balcony provision generates substantial harm to the character both internally and externally to the grade one listed building. No firm demonstration that these changes, which marginally increase floor area, are for the public good.”
Officer report
The committee vote
A councillor recused himself because of his role with the proposed operator, and the application was approved unanimously.
“261277 Holy Trinity Church Colchester Cllr Linghorn-Baker declared a non-pecuniary interest as Director of Amphora and recused himself from the item, The Committee considered an update to listed building approval 252042 to reflect amendments required for new operator, and also update to the existing building drawings, following external stone and roof repairs under application 250384, proposal description remains the same as previous application as follows: Application for…”
“The Committee had before it a report in which all information was set out. The Recommendation was Approval. RESOLVED (UNANIMOUSLY)that: the application be approved as per Officer recommendation.”
Minutes
Councillors at the meeting
- Will Calverley
- James ChildReform UK
- Mark GoacherGreen
- Dave HarrisLabour
- Michael Lilley
- David Linghorn-BakerDeclared an interestConservative
- Sam McCarthyLib Dem
- Kayleigh RippingaleLabour
- Catherine SpindlerLib Dem
- Leigh TateConservative
- Dennis WillettsSubstitute for Robert DavidsonConservative
- Samuel Ian Alexander McLeanSubstitute for Martyn WarnesLab Co-op
Apologies Robert Alec Davidson Conservative, Martyn Warnes Lab Co-op
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from Democracy Club.
Sources
- Colchester Planning Committee minutes, 10 September 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Colchester's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Committee
- Colchester Planning Committee
- Council
- Colchester
- Date
- Thursday 10 September 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Approved
- Vote
- Unanimous
- Councillors
- 12Conservative 3Labour 2Lib Dem 2Green 1Lab Co-op 1Reform UK 12 otherShow councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Colchester committee decisions →
This committee's year
46 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 1 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.