10-home steading conversion at Tillycairn Steading, Tarves, Ellon
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Aberdeenshire Formartine Area Committee on 29 Sept 2026.
What was proposed
The application sought to convert a steading into six homes and build four homes while changing visibility-splay and access conditions.
“Planning permission is sought for the conversion of a steading to form 6 dwellinghouses and the erection of 4 dwellinghouses without compliance with Condition 1(b) (Visibility Splays) and Condition 2 (Access) of planning permission reference APP/2020/1056 at Tillycairn Steading, Tarves.”
“The applicant requests for Condition 1(b) to be amended to vary the visibility splays reducing the north direction from measuring 2.4m x 215m as required by the condition to 2.4m x 160m. The south direction visibility splay would remain at 2.4m x 215m. Condition 1(b) states the following:”
Officer report
The site
The rural site lies about 2.2 kilometres west of Tarves, with an access track and open fields around it.
“The site is located in a rural area, approximately 2.2km west of Tarves. It is partially intersected by an access track from the north-west which extends south, through the western portion of the site.”
“This application has been submitted in tandem with APP/2026/0086 to form a turning area at the existing access to this site.”
Officer report
Earlier applications
The original ten-home permission was granted in 2021, while an earlier attempt to remove the adoptable-road condition was refused in 2024.
“APP/2023/2104 Section 42 application for conversion of steading to form 6 dwellinghouses and erection of 4 dwellinghouses without compliance with condition 2 (Adoptable Road) of Planning Permission Reference APP/2020/1056. Refused 30 April 2024.”
“The above application is refused on the grounds that the condition had been attached to the original consent for reasons of safety related to provisions for use of the road by school transport and refuse lorries, rather than them pulling into a junction from what was a very busy road.”
Officer report
What officers recommended
Officers recommended approval because Roads Development considered the amended visibility splays and removal of the access condition acceptable for road safety.
“The key issue under consideration relates to whether the amendment to the conditions would be acceptable in terms of road safety for the development. Both Policy 18 Infrastructure first of the National Planning Framework 4 (NPF4) and Policy RD1 Providing Suitable Services of the Aberdeenshire Local Development Plan (ALDP) 2023 address this issue and seek to ensure that the safe provision of infrastructure is an integral part of development.”
“Although the Community Council's objection contains a material planning consideration (road safety), the non-compliance with Conditions 1(b) and 2 satisfies Aberdeenshire Council’s Roads Development Team with regards to safe access and standards the development must meet. Whilst Policy RD 1.6 notes the requirement for adoptable roads, this is a should rather than a must subject to consultation with the Roads Development Team.”
Officer report
Consultation responses
Roads Development had no objection, but Tarves Community Council objected over road safety, visibility standards and the adoptable-road requirement.
“Environment and Infrastructure Services (Roads Development) has no objection. Roads Development did not request Condition 2 as per the response to APP/2020/1056 dated 17/08/2020 and therefore have no objection to the variation of the condition.”
“Tarves Community Council objects to this application on the grounds of road safety. They agree with the previous committee decision in relation to requiring an adoptable road to serve the development, that ALDP policy requires six or more dwellings to be served by a road suitable for public adoption, plot four (APP/2024/0650) was approved on the basis that the access road was to be adopted and the junction visibility does not meet standards in a junction area with a history of accidents.”
Officer report
Local support
Eight valid representations supported the application, citing improved visibility and safer views after the hedge was removed and access improvements were made.
“A total of 8 valid representations (8 support) have been received as defined in the Scheme of Governance. All issues raised have been considered. The letters raise the following material issues:”
“Visibility is improved now with the hedge removed and access is safer. • Safer views at the cross roads since improvements were implemented.”
Officer report
Who spoke
The Senior Planner introduced the applications, and the committee heard a late request to speak from a representative of Tarves Community Council.
Members’ debate
Members questioned the original road assessment, adoptable-road area, maintenance responsibilities, junction visibility and school-bus access.
“During discussion Members asked which road was considered when the original steading application had been approved; sought clarity on the size of area to be of adoptable standard, noting that the plans did not accord with the area shown at the site visit; and queried who would be responsible for the maintenance of the proposed turning circle and visibility splays.”
“Members asked about the public road to the right of the access, asking if vehicles exiting the junction would affect visibility; queried the definition of a low volume junction; and queried the potential size of school bus that may require to pull into the bellmouth.”
Minutes
The decision
The application was refused because the visibility splays did not meet the Local Development Plan standard and the safety condition lacked significant assurance for removal.
“Councillor Hassan, seconded by Councillor Nicol, moved as an amendment, that the application be refused due to concerns relating to the visibility splays as they did not meet the standard required under the Local Development Plan, and so the application was therefore contrary to Policy RD1.6 of the Local Development Plan. The condition had been attached on the grounds of safety, and no significant assurance had been given that it should be removed.”
“Therefore, the application was REFUSED due to concerns relating to the visibility splays as they did not meet the standard required under the Local Development Plan, and so the application was therefore contrary to Policy RD1.6 of the Local Development Plan. The condition had been attached on the grounds of safety, and no significant assurance had been given that it should be removed.”
Minutes
Councillors at the meeting
- Iain TaylorChairConservative
- Andrew HassanVice-ChairLib Dem
- John CrawleyReform UK
- Alastair ForsythSNP
- Paul JohnstonIndependent
- Gordon LangConservative
- Louise McAllisterSNP
- Jenny NicolSNP
- Gillian OwenIndependent
- Derek RitchieConservative
- Anne StirlingLib Dem
Apologies Isobel Davidson Lib Dem
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Aberdeenshire Formartine Area Committee minutes, 29 September 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Aberdeenshire's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- Aberdeenshire
- Date
- Tuesday 29 September 2026
- Committee decided
- Approved
- Councillors
- 11Conservative 3SNP 3Independent 2Lib Dem 2Reform UK 1Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Aberdeenshire committee decisions →
This committee's year
17 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 6 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.