Replacement dwelling at 73 Main Street, Fraserburgh

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by Aberdeenshire Banff and Buchan Area Committee on 15 Sept 2026.

APP/2025/1322Approved

The site

The site contained a Category C listed cottage in the Broadsea Conservation Area, within an established residential area near the coast.

“The application relates to a Category ‘C’ listed building situated within the Broadsea Conservation Area, within the settlement of Fraserburgh. The property is a detached, 1½ storey traditional cottage-style dwelling located within an established residential area. It forms part of a linear grouping of detached dwellings that front the public road along Main Street. To the rear (north) of the dwelling, the land falls steeply towards the sea.”

“The proposal seeks to demolish the existing dwellinghouse. The listing description on HES website indicates that the house dates from the 1960s. The description states that no 73 is “a good example of mid 20th century conservation architecture, closely referencing the scale, form and treatment of the 18th and 19th century single-storey cottages and terraced rows that characterise the Broadsea township.”

Officer report

Earlier applications

Listed building consent for demolition was refused, an earlier demolition application was withdrawn, and two alteration applications were approved.

“APP/2025/1394: Listed Building Consent for Demolition of Dwellinghouse (Refused 26.02.2026)”

“APP/2025/1395: Demolition of Dwellinghouse (Withdrawn)”

Officer report

What officers recommended

Officers recommended refusal because demolition was not justified and the replacement dwelling would conflict with listed-building and design policies.

“The proposal involves demolition of a listed building, resulting in total loss of a designated heritage asset. The applicant has not provided conservation led options appraisal, detailed repair methodology, nor robust evidence demonstrating that reasonable repair and retention is not feasible, nor that demolition is a last resort or that any public benefits outweigh the heritage harm.”

“In addition, the proposed replacement house is not considered to be sympathetic to the character of the Conservation Area. The prominence of the site combined with the increased height, inclusion of wall head dormer windows and overall resultant mass of the proposed dwelling means that the dwelling does not replicate the existing scale of the existing house on the site nor respect the character of the existing house nor the Conservation Area in which it sits.”

Officer report

Support for the proposal

One neighbour supported the redevelopment, citing local connections, future accessibility, conservation requirements and the expected quality of the works.

“A total of one valid representation (in support) has been received, and all matters raised have been fully considered. The representation raises the following material points:”

“The neighbour (53 Main Street) offers full support for the proposal, noting that the applicant has strong local and family connections, along with a respectful understanding of the area’s history and character. • It is acknowledged that, while the proposal involves demolition of the existing dwelling, the neighbour considers that the subsequent redevelopment will remain in keeping with conservation requirements.”

Officer report

Who spoke

The Senior Planner presented the application, followed by the agent and the applicant, who addressed structural, cost, access and heritage matters.

Members’ discussion

Members considered visible cracking, renovation risks and costs, accessibility, environmental standards, the building’s age and the proposed improvement to the area.

“During discussion Members noted concerns that extensive renovation works could risk further damage to the building and considered the site visit had been valuable in allowing them to see the extent of the visible cracking. Members referred to the comparison photographs and considered that the proposed development would enhance the amenity of the area and would be more in keeping with its surroundings.”

“Members further commented that the proposal would provide a more modern and accessible home, improving quality of life, particularly for those with mobility issues. They questioned the significance of the building’s listing status given its relatively recent construction date and considered the construction type and the need to future-proof the property to be important material considerations.”

Minutes

The committee’s decision

The committee granted permission as a departure from the development plans, delegating the decision notice to the Head of Planning and Economy subject to conditions.

“Following discussion, the Committee agreed that planning permission be granted as a departure from the Aberdeenshire Local Development Plan and National Planning Framework 4, with authority delegated to the Head of Planning and Economy to issue the decision notice subject to the imposition of appropriate planning conditions.”

Minutes

Why permission was granted

Members found the demolition evidence insufficient but considered the whole development would enhance the conservation area and provide significant accessibility benefits.

“In reaching that conclusion, Members determined that insufficient evidence had been presented to demonstrate that demolition of the existing building was necessary or justified. This is deemed contrary to the requirements of both NPF 4 Policy 7 Historic Assets and Places and ALDP 2023 Policy HE1 Protecting Listed Buildings, Scheduled Monuments and Archaeological Sites (including other historic buildings).”

“Members also attached significant material weight to the accessibility benefits arising from the proposal, which they considered to be a positive planning outcome in the overall planning balance. Accordingly, Members were satisfied that material considerations warranted the grant of planning permission notwithstanding the identified policy departure.”

Minutes

The members' reasons

“Members noted that one letter of support had been received.”

“Members noted that, had the building been of traditional stone construction, they may have taken a different view.”

“Notwithstanding that finding, Members concluded that the proposed development, when assessed as a whole, would preserve and enhance the character and appearance of the Conservation Area and was consistent with the relevant requirements of Policy P1 (Layout, Siting and Design) of the Aberdeenshire Local Development Plan and Policy 14 of NPF 4 Design, Quality and Place.”

Minutes

Source: the council's minutes, quoted word for word.

Councillors at the meeting

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.

Sources

  • Aberdeenshire Banff and Buchan Area Committee minutes, 15 September 2026
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of Aberdeenshire's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Date
Tuesday 15 September 2026
Committee decided
Approved
Councillors
10Conservative 4Reform UK 2SNP 2Independent 1Lib Dem 1Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)

This committee's year

13 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →