Two flats and extensions at 3 The Mall, Surbiton
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Kingston Upon Thames Planning Committee on 16 Jul 2026.
What was proposed
The application sought removal of condition 10, which restricted the two proposed flats from using permitted development rights for HMO conversion.
“25/01980/FUL (Erection of single storey rear and part first floor rear extensions, and rear dormer roof extension to facilitate loft conversion. Conversion of single family dwelling into 2nos. flats.) to allow removal of Condition 10.”
“Plan Type s73 application to remove a condition…”
Officer report
The site and earlier permission
The site is a two-storey semi-detached property, and permission had already been granted for extensions and conversion into two flats.
“The application site is a 2-storey semi-detached property located on the north side of The Mall.”
“The original application was approved by the Surbiton Neighbourhood Committee for extensions to the existing building and conversion of the property into two flats. Following consideration by the Committee, members requested a condition restricting permitted development rights for the conversion of the future flats into HMOs. This was a request of the Committee rather than something that formed part of the original officer recommendation.”
Officer report
Why the condition was added
Members added the condition after concerns that the two flats could be occupied by excessive numbers of residents in HMO accommodation.
“The application was granted subject to a condition restricting the permitted development rights of the created 2 flats for use as a Class C4 small HMO. Such a HMO that falls within a C4 use class permits up to 6 people to live together as a single household. It should be noted that this condition was imposed by members of the Surbiton Neighbourhood Committee and did not form part of the original officer recommendation.”
“The condition was imposed by members in response to concerns of the local community that the two flats may be used by an excessive amount of residents in HMO accommodation. It should be noted that the dwelling house as it is currently arranged is/was used as a HMO.”
Officer report
What officers recommended
Officers recommended approval because the condition was unnecessary, unreasonable and unsupported by evidence of unacceptable harm, while licensing could control HMOs.
“This condition is not considered to be necessary to make the development acceptable in planning terms. There is no substantive evidence that any speculative occupation of either of the approved flats as a HMO would, in itself, result in unacceptable planning harm. The licensing regime that exists for HMOs within the Borough would adequately control any potential change of use and apply strict conditions to any potential use as a HMO.”
“In the absence of any substantive evidence that demonstrates that the restriction is necessary to mitigate an identified planning harm arising from the development as it has been approved, the condition is not considered to satisfy the six tests, when taken as a whole, outlined within the NPPF and PPG. Accordingly, insufficient evidence or robust planning justification to retain this condition has been demonstrated and its removal is Page A153”
Officer report
What residents said
Fifty-three representations objected, citing population density, housing loss, local character, parking, infrastructure and the condition’s planning justification.
“At the time of writing this report 53 representations have been received, with all of the representations being in objection to the proposed development. The issues raised in the representations are summarised as follows:”
“Proposal could see a population increase of 12 people ● Failure to protect existing housing stock ● Would harm local character and context ● Parking stress ● Inadequate infrastructure ● Not consistent with the Finney vs Welsh Ministers decision ● Existing condition meets all the 6 tests…”
Officer report
What members considered
Members considered whether condition 10 met the six required tests and were told the application concerned permitted development rights, not an HMO change of use.
“Whilst Officers noted the significant community interest in this proposed development, there was no substantive evidence available that showed that any such change under permitted development rights would result in unacceptable harm to local amenity. Any impacts relating to noise, general disturbance or anti-social behaviour were speculative and would, in any case, be controlled by Council’s licensing regime.”
“It was stressed that in considering this case, Members should be aware that the proposal was not to consider a change of use of the two flats into HMOs: rather, the relevant test was whether the property should be restricted from utilizing permitted development rights, which was a right that was available to all other dwellings within the local area.”
Minutes
The vote
Five councillors voted for the application, none voted against, and three abstained.
“The conditions set out in the report (with condition 10 being deleted) including such amendments, additions and/or deletions as the Director of Planning and Regeneration, in consultation with the Chair of the Planning Committee considered reasonably necessary.”
“For: Councillors Mark Beynon, Roger Hayes, Stephen Evans, Mark Manners and Olly Wehring (5) Against: None (0) Abstentions: Councillors Ian George, Lesley Heap and Elizabeth Park (3)”
Minutes
Councillors at the meeting
- Mark BeynonChairLib Dem
- Roger HayesVice-ChairLib Dem
- Stephen EvansLib Dem
- Ian GeorgeConservative
- Lesley HeapLib Dem
- Mark MannersLib Dem
- Elizabeth ParkLib Dem
- Olly WehringLib Dem
Apologies Lorraine Dunstone Lib Dem, Ian Manders Lib Dem, Sharukh Mirza Lib Dem
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Kingston Upon Thames Planning Committee minutes, 16 July 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Kingston Upon Thames's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- Kingston Upon Thames
- Date
- Thursday 16 July 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Approved
- Councillors
- 8Lib Dem 7Conservative 1Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Kingston Upon Thames committee decisions →
This committee's year
10 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 1 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.