Land Off Swinderby Road South Scarle Data via plota.co.uk

25/01914/PIP - Permission in Principle Refused

Proposal

Application for permission in principle for residential development for a minimum of two dwellings and a maximum of two dwellings. Data via plota.co.uk

View original council record ↗Last checked

Application progress

✓
Received
4 Nov 2025
✓
Validated
5 Nov 2025
✓
Consultation
5 Feb 2026
✗
Refused
13 Feb 2026
Appeal
Not lodged

Refused on 13 Feb 2026 · Planning Committee · Last checked 16 Oct 2026

Planning committee

Decided by Newark and Sherwood Planning Committee on 12 Feb 2026.

Refused by 8 votes to 3

Against officer advice: officers had recommended approval.

  • Officers advised approval because two dwellings were acceptable in principle despite the countryside location and housing land supply position.
  • Residents and the parish council raised concerns about countryside development, highway safety, flooding, character, services and nature.
  • The committee refused the application, citing unsustainable development and open countryside, after approval was defeated in the first vote.
Read how the committee decided The proposal, site history, officers’ assessment, objections, speakers, committee debate, vote and reasons for refusal.

Source: Plota analysis of Newark and Sherwood's committee minutes of 12 Feb 2026.

Documents 52

Consultation & comments 38

PDF FINAL COMMENTS Appellant`s Case · 7 Aug 2026 View ↗ PDF FINAL COMMENTS - APPENDIX Appellant`s Case · 7 Aug 2026 View ↗ PDF INTERESTED PARTY COMMENTS Appeal Correspondence · 23 Jul 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 2 Feb 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 30 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 26 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 20 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 19 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 19 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 18 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 18 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 12 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 11 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF SOUTH SCARLE PARISH Consultee Comment · 7 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 6 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF NCC HIGHWAYS Consultee Comment · 5 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 3 Jan 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 31 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF CONSERVATION Consultee Comment · 16 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 5 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 3 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 3 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 2 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF PARISH COUNCIL COMMENTS Consultee Comment · 2 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF NCC RIGHTS OF WAY Consultee Comment · 2 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 1 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 1 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF NCC HIGHWAYS Consultee Comment · 1 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 27 Nov 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 26 Nov 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 26 Nov 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 26 Nov 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 24 Nov 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 24 Nov 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 23 Nov 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 23 Nov 2025 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 20 Nov 2025 View ↗
IMG Commenter’s name hidden Show Neighbour or Public Comment · 20 Nov 2025 View ↗

All documents on the council site ↗

Site constraints 3

Agricultural land, grade 2
Best and most versatile land (grades 1, 2 and 3a). Source: the Predictive Agricultural Land Classification Map (Defra and Natural England, 2025; the Welsh Government's Predictive ALC Map 2 in Wales), a model rather than a site survey. Natural England's Provisional ALC map (1:250,000, 1970s), which most planning maps still show, had this area as grade 3. The predicted grade is Defra's current estimate; only a site survey settles it.
Where development of farmland is needed, policy prefers poorer land over the best and most versatile (grades 1, 2 and 3a). Three sources: Natural England's post-1988 field surveys, which are definitive where they exist; the Defra predictive map for England (2025) and the Welsh Government predictive map, modelled from the soil map with 3a and 3b split; and the 1970s provisional map, which planners and other services still show, coarser and with grade 3 undivided. Where the provisional and predicted grades disagree, treat the predicted grade as the current estimate and expect an application to carry its own survey.
5 listed buildings within 150 m
Nearest: Yew Tree Cottage, Grade II, 53 m away · 5 Grade II
The site itself is not listed. Listed building consent is needed for work that affects the special interest of a listed building, inside or out, on top of planning permission. Setting can be a consideration for buildings nearby; there is no fixed radius.
Show all 5 with distances
Historic England ↗
Conservation area 22 m away: South Scarle
The edge of the area; work outside it can still affect its setting.
The council must give weight to preserving or enhancing the area's character and appearance. Not every council has published its boundaries as open data.
Council document ↗
Not affected
Outside flood zones 2 and 3 · Not green belt · No scheduled monument at the site

Checked on 2 November 2026. Historic England, the Environment Agency, Natural England and council datasets, Open Government Licence. A boundary can run through a site and the council holds the definitive record: confirm with the council before relying on this.

Work with planning data?

Every application in Newark and Sherwood - and every UK council - as a live feed, an API, or a bulk CSV export.

About Plota's data service

Important details

Application type
Permission in Principle
Received
4 Nov 2025
Validated
5 Nov 2025
Ward
Collingham
Parish
South Scarle
Case officer
Show
Target decision
10 Dec 2025
Decision
Application Refused
Decision date
13 Feb 2026
Decision level
Planning Committee
Applicant
Show
Agent
IBA Planning Ltd - Mr Nick Baseley

How this decision compares

Decided in 100 days from validation, 37 days slower than Newark and Sherwood's median of 63 for new homes. Refused, as 14% of new homes here are.

38%decided within 8 weeks
86%approved
16%go to committee

Plota live figures for new homes decided by Newark and Sherwood in the last twelve months, from validation. Newark and Sherwood decision record →

Public comments

11comments received
11 objecting

100% object · above the UK average of 74%

23 neighbours consulted · Last counted 16 Oct 2026

Read the comments on the council site ↗

Consultation & key dates

Consultation
5 Feb 2026
Statutory expiry
10 Dec 2025
Env. assessment
No
Newark and Sherwood
Planning Authority Score
3.9/10
Below average
#198 of 296 councils
Relevant to this application:
Householder decisions

Newark and Sherwood is slower than most councils at deciding householder applications, ranking #241 out of 296. 54% of applications have the time limit extended, above the 41% national average. Householder applications are slightly more likely to be approved here (96%) than the national average (90%).

Slower than most councils
for householder decisions
These figures are council-wide context, not a prediction for this application. View full council performance
Newark and Sherwood decision statistics
Based on MHCLG data, the year to March 2026
92%
Overall approval rate
Above avg (87%) #88 of 296
96%
Householder approved
Above avg (90%) #55 of 296
50%
Decided in 8 weeks
Below avg (63%) #241 of 296
54%
Extended time limit
Above avg (41%) #244 of 296
80%
Minor dwellings approved
110 decided (1-9 homes)
88%
Major dwellings approved
25 decided (10+ homes)
82%
Change of use approved
33 decided
767
Total decisions
63 refused in the year to March 2026