Listed building alterations at Gibson House, Argyle Street, St Andrews
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Fife Planning Committee; West and Central Area Planning Committee; North East Planning Committee on 3 Jun 2026.
What was proposed
The application sought listed building consent for internal and external alterations, partial demolition, extensions and changes to boundary walls.
“This application is listed building consent for internal and external alterations, including partial demolition, erection of extensions and alterations to boundary walls.”
“Proposed external works include the demolition of the existing side and rear extensions, removal of existing rear dormers, the partial down taking of existing window openings to create doorways, the partial downtaking of boundary walls, replacement windows and the erection of replacement side and rear extensions.”
Officer report
The site
Gibson House is a vacant Category B listed building in the Central St Andrews Conservation Area, with residential properties, a road and a car park nearby.
“This application relates to Gibson House, which is a category B listed building, located in the centre of St Andrews. Gibson House occupies a prominent position within the Central St Andrews Conservation Area on the corner of Argyle Street and City Road, and the surrounding area contains a mix of residential and commercial uses. Historically, the application property was a hospital, before being converted into a care home.”
“The application property can be split into 3 constituent parts. The original, historic part of the building was constructed in 1880 and is centrally located within the site. This part of the building is two-storey with attic accommodation, constructed in stugged ashlar with a slated roof. The building features a prominent central entrance tower with ogee roof feature and finial. The principal south elevation faces Argyle Street.”
Officer report
Earlier applications
Earlier consents covered care home alterations and replacement extensions, while a related hotel change-of-use application remained pending.
“99/00463/EFULL - Extension to carpark - Application Approved - 04/08/99 05/02412/ELBC - Erect wall plaque - Application Approved - 04/04/06 11/00841/FULL - Alterations and extension to residential care home - Application Approved - 29/07/11 11/00855/LBC - Listed building consent for alterations and extension to residential care home - Application Approved - 29/07/11 14/01629/FULL - Alterations and extension to residential care home (renewal of 11/00841/FULL) - Application…”
Officer report
Officers’ assessment
Officers considered the proposal finely balanced but acceptable because mitigation reduced harm and the development would secure a viable long-term use.
“Substantial weight is given to revisions made in response to heritage concerns, including the retention of the principal stair and mullioned window, the use of wall nibs and downstands to reflect former subdivisions, the increased retention of fireplaces, and the preservation of cornicing and upper sections of partitions to aid legibility and future reversibility.”
“Overall, this is a finely balanced proposal which has been carefully considered. Whilst the application proposal would result in the redevelopment of two existing poor-quality extensions, the replacement development and internal alterations represent a significantly increased scale of intervention and the concerns raised in this regard are fully acknowledged.”
Officer report
The decision
“Decision The committee approved the application subject to:- (1) the four conditions and for the reasons detailed in the report; and (2) formal notification of the decision to approve to the Scottish Ministers due to the formal objection by Historic Environment Scotland.”
Minutes, 3 Jun 2026
Councillors at the meeting
- Jonny TeppChairLib Dem
- Al ClarkLib Dem
- Sean Frazer DillonLib Dem
- Alycia HayesSNP
- Gary HoltLib Dem
- Margaret KennedyLib Dem
- Louise Kennedy-DalbySNP
- Allan KnoxLib Dem
- Robin LawsonConservative
- Jane Ann ListonLib Dem
- Donald LothianLib Dem
- David MacdiarmidSNP
- Ann VernerSNP
Apologies John Andrew Caffrey Lib Dem, Fiona Corps Lib Dem
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from Democracy Club.
Sources
- Fife Planning Committee; West and Central Area Planning Committee; North East Planning Committee minutes, 3 June 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Fife's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Committee
- Fife Planning Committee; West and Central Area Planning Committee; North East Planning Committee
- Council
- Fife
- Date
- Wednesday 3 June 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Approved
- Councillors
- 13Lib Dem 8SNP 4Conservative 1Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Fife committee decisions →
This committee's year
27 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.