Up to 40 homes at Land Adj To Melrose, Church Road, Mabe Burnthouse, Penryn

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by Cornwall West Sub-Area Planning Committee on 12 Oct 2026.

PA26/01235RefusedAgainst officer advice

The site and surroundings

The site comprises two agricultural fields beside Mabe Burnthouse, with housing proposed in the northern field and open space in the southern field.

“The application seeks outline planning permission (with all matters barring access to be reserved) for the development of up to 40 dwellings on a parcel of land to the south of, and adjoining, the settlement of Mabe Burnthouse. The site currently comprises two agricultural fields, the northern one of which is intended to…”

“Information Classification: PUBLIC accommodate residential development (based on indicative plans provided), while the southern field is intended to provide open space (type 2 – natural space).”

Officer report

Earlier advice

Earlier pre-application advice considered residential development on the northern field potentially supportable as a rural exception site.

“PA24/00680/PREAPP - Pre application advice for development of the site for up to 30 residential dwellings, with associated access from church road, landscaping and open space. Proposals would include policy compliant level of affordable housing. – advice given 27.09.2024”

“The above pre-application suggested that residential development on the northern field could potentially be supported as a rural exception site, given it would not accord with policy 3 of the Cornwall Local Plan.”

Officer report

Why officers supported it

Officers accepted conflict with housing policies but gave significant weight to housing need, the 3.9-year supply, accessibility and proposed mitigation.

“However, the conflict with the development plan identified above must be considered alongside the current position in respect of housing land supply. Cornwall Council is currently unable to demonstrate a five-year supply of deliverable housing sites, instead demonstrating only a 3.9-year supply. This is a substantial shortfall.”

“Paragraph 2 of Annex A of the NPPF advises that development plan policies should not be given reduced weight simply because they were adopted prior to the publication of the NPPF. However, it also confirms that policies which are materially inconsistent with national decision-making policies should be given very limited weight.”

Officer report

Who spoke

Three speakers opposed the application, one speaker supported it, and the electoral division member submitted a statement while unable to attend.

What members debated

Members focused on pedestrian safety, the narrow footpath, crossings, historical road-safety evidence and the inability to secure a safer continuous route.

“It was acknowledged that there was some challenging highway network and a section of footpath that was not full width along the road beside the site, but it was noted that traffic calming and a new 20mph zone had been introduced to help with that situation; 2. Members questioned why there was no virtual pavement in that area, but Officers suggested that it would be of little benefit in that location.”

“Members considered that there were no major issues with the actual proposed development. However, they did have concerns for pedestrian safety in the area; 2. There could be up to 80 people per day walking along that road, and this was a safety concern; 3. It would be preferable to have improved safety measures put into the application, and that should include an improved footpath; 4.”

Minutes

The committee decision

The committee refused the application by 8 votes to 3, with no abstentions, because safe pedestrian access to settlement facilities was not demonstrated.

“Arising from consideration of the report and debate it was moved by Councillor Ball, seconded by Councillor O’Connor, and on a vote of 8 votes in favour, 3 against and 0 abstentions, it was:-”

“RESOLVED that Application No. PA26/01235 be refused because the development fails to demonstrate a priority for pedestrian safety having failed to demonstrate safe access to facilities provided within the settlement, given the lack of continuous footway to said facilities, and therefore fails to take into account sustainable transport options, contrary to policy 27 of the Cornwall Local Plan Strategic Policies, policy T1 of the Climate Emergency Development Plan Document…”

Minutes

The members' reasons

“Members felt dismayed that they could not influence a safe footpath.”

Minutes

Source: the council's minutes, quoted word for word.

Councillors at the meeting

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.

Sources

  • Cornwall West Sub-Area Planning Committee minutes, 12 October 2026
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of Cornwall's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Council
Cornwall
Date
Monday 12 October 2026
Recommendation
Officers recommended approval
Committee decided
Refused, against officer advice
Vote
8 for refusal, 3 against
Councillors
11Lib Dem 4Independent 3Reform UK 2Independent 1Restore Britain 1Show councillors
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of the minutes.

This committee's year

29 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 6 against officer advice.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →