Up to 70 homes at Oxhey Lane, Carpenders Park
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Three Rivers Planning Committee on 22 Oct 2026.
What was proposed
The outline proposal was for up to 70 homes, a new access onto Oxhey Lane and infrastructure, with several matters reserved for later approval.
“Description of Proposed Development 3.1 This application seeks outline planning permission for the; ‘Construction of up to 70 residential dwellings (Use Class C3) with associated access onto Oxhey Lane and infrastructure with Appearance, Layout, Landscaping and Scale as reserved matters’. A new pedestrian and vehicular access onto Oxhey Lane would be implemented which would be sited approximately 67m from the north western boundary of the site.”
“The application is also supported by an illustrative master plan and Land Use Parameter Plan to show how the site could be developed. As all matters regarding appearance, layout and scale are reserved this is for illustrative purposes only.”
Officer report
The site and its history
The 2.7-hectare grazing site lies in the Metropolitan Green Belt beside Watford Heath, homes, heritage assets and protected trees; no relevant planning history was identified.
“Relevant Planning History 1.1 No relevant planning history. 2. Description of Application Site 2.1 The site is approximately 2.7 hectares in area and sited within the Metropolitan Green Belt located adjacent to Watford Heath and the boundary with Watford Borough Council. The site subject to this application predominantly consists of open grazing land with associated low level built form to facilitate the existing grazing of the land.”
“The site adjoins residential properties along the northern and eastern boundaries (both within Watford Borough Council) with the southern boundary adjoins Aubern Mere Residential Home and Woodlands Cottages (sited within Three Rivers). Woodlands Cottages consist of a set of four adjoining two storey cottages where the rear elevations run parallel with the south eastern boundary of the site; the rear amenity spaces adjoins the application site.”
Officer report
What officers recommended
Officers recommended approval because they considered the site Grey Belt, the development sustainable and policy-compliant, with substantial housing benefits outweighing low-level listed-building harm.
“The assessment has considered the scheme in the context of the Three Rivers Local Development Plan and all relevant material planning considerations, including the policies of the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF). The responses from consultees have also been considered, and a list of all consultees is included at section 4 of the Committee report with their full comments provided in Appendix 1 attached to the report.”
“In relation to Green Belt, officers consider that the site is Grey Belt and the proposal accords with NPPF Policy GB7(1).g and meets the Golden Rules as set out within Policy GB8 of the NPPF. In addition, application is considered to meet Policy GB7(1)(h). As such, it is considered that the development is an appropriate form of development in the Green Belt.”
Officer report
Consultees and residents
Most consultees raised no objection, while the Conservation Officer identified heritage harm and 55 public representations objected to the proposal.
“Wafford Rural Parish Council 1.1.1 Objection Three Rivers Development Plans Officer 1.1.2 Comment Herts County Council Archaeology Officer 1.1.3 No objection London Underground 1.1.4 No objection British Pipeline Agency 1.1.5 No objection National Highways 1.1.6 No objection Herts County Council Fire and Rescue 1.1.7 No objection Three Rivers Leisure Officer 1.1.8 No objection Herts County Council Highways Authority 1.1.9 No objection Conservation Officer 1.1.10 Heritage…”
“England 1.1.25 No comments received Network Rail 1.1.26 No comments received Designing Out Crime Officer 1.1.27 No comments received Three Rivers Waste and Environmental Protection 1.1.28 No comments received Environmental Health Officer 1.1.29 No comments received Three Rivers Transport and Parking Officer 1.1.30 No comments received…”
Officer report
Main objections
Objections concerned Green Belt loss, heritage, infrastructure capacity, traffic and safety, neighbour amenity, flooding, wildlife, drainage, parking and cumulative development.
“Loss of Green Belt/impact on character of area and heritage assets: 70 dwellings would be out of character, overdevelopment and would significantly harm Oxhey Lanes residential nature and the surrounding area; Site is where openness and character of the landscape are important; Loss of open land which would cause harm to visual amenity and character of the area; Contrary to Green Belt objectives, purposes and local planning policies; Openness of the field contributes to the…”
Officer report
Who spoke
A county councillor spoke on the application, and a South West Herts Coalition representative spoke against it.
What members debated
Members considered the unchanged proposal, updated national policy, Green Belt purposes, station distance, heritage harm and whether refusal could be defended.
“In response to a question, the Planning Officer confirmed that the proposal was unchanged from that which had been considered by the Committee in August. There was therefore nothing new which sought to address the reasons for refusal given by the Committee. Rather, it was the assessment of the application in relation to the updated NPPF, and whether the reasons for refusal could be justified, which required further consideration by the Committee.”
“Responding to a point raised by a speaker about the distance from Bushey Station, which had also been discussed by the Committee at the August meeting, the Planning Officer confirmed that the site was considered to be within reasonable walking distance of the station. However, officers considered the site to be Grey Belt which fell within policy GB(7)(g).”
Minutes
The vote and decision
Members voted 5 for, 3 against and 1 abstention, approving delegated permission subject to a legal agreement, conditions and an energy-efficiency informative.
“Councillor Price moved, and Councillor Whately-Smith seconded, that an informative be added to encourage the applicant to maximise the energy efficiency of the proposed buildings; and that authority be delegated to the Head of Regulatory Services to grant planning permission, following completion of a S106 Agreement (securing the Heads of Terms set out at section 7.20 of the report including affordable housing provision, travel plan, contributions to infrastructure including…”
“That an informative be added to encourage the applicant to maximise the energy efficiency of the proposed buildings; and that authority be delegated to the Head of Regulatory Services to grant planning permission, following completion of a S106 Agreement (securing the Heads of Terms set out at section 7.20 of the report including affordable housing provision, travel plan, contributions to infrastructure including education, healthcare and waste infrastructure and monitoring…”
Minutes
Councillors at the meeting
- Chris Whately-SmithChairLib Dem
- Elinor GazzardLib Dem
- Oliver CooperConservative
- Stephen CoxLabour
- Chris MitchellGreen
- Debbie MorrisConservative
- Tom SmithLib Dem
- Louise PriceSubstitute for Raj KhiroyaLib Dem
- Krutika PatelSubstitute for Reena RangerConservative
Apologies Raj Khiroya Lib Dem, Reena Ranger Conservative
Also attending Aidan Bentley Lib Dem, Vicky Edwards Conservative, Jon Tankard Lib Dem, Parish Councillor Andrew Gallagher, Parish Councillor Elizabeth Willetts, Vishal Patel
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Three Rivers Planning Committee minutes, 22 October 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Three Rivers's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Committee
- Three Rivers Planning Committee
- Council
- Three Rivers
- Date
- Thursday 22 October 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Approved
- Vote
- 5 for, 3 against, 1 abstained
- Councillors
- 9Lib Dem 4Conservative 3Green 1Labour 1Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Three Rivers committee decisions →
Source: Plota analysis of the minutes.
This committee's year
75 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 7 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.