Primary school at Former East Street Shopping Centre, Southampton
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Southampton Planning and Rights of Way Panel on 21 Jul 2026, in a recorded vote.
What was proposed
The application proposed a three-storey primary school for up to 420 pupils, with play areas, landscaping, access, parking and community facilities.
“The proposal would redevelop the site to provide a permanent home for Hope Community School, currently based in temporary accommodation at Central Hall opposite. It would comprise a two-form entry primary school for up to 420 pupils aged 4–11, in the form of a three-storey teaching block with a lower hall and kitchen element, external play and learning areas, landscaping, access and limited on-site parking.”
“Pedestrian access would be primarily from East Street, with Lime Street used for servicing, deliveries, refuse collection, emergency access and parking. A north-south route between Lime Street and East Street is proposed, with a condition included to secure its use for safety and security reasons.”
Officer report
The site and its surroundings
The vacant former shopping centre site is in the city centre and is surrounded by streets, commercial and residential buildings, student accommodation and heritage assets.
“The application site comprises the cleared southern part of the former East Street Shopping Centre. The shopping centre was demolished around 2012 and the site has remained vacant and hoarded since. It lies within the city centre boundary, forms part of the East Street secondary retail frontage, and sits within a mixed commercial and residential area.”
“The vicinity includes student accommodation to the north, comprising the converted thirteen-storey Capital House; five storey block fronting East Street; a four-storey development fronting Evans Street; and the Holyrood Housing Estate to the south, including Kings Court and Challis Court located on Lime Street.”
Officer report
Earlier applications and decisions
Earlier retail-led permissions lapsed, while a different city-centre school proposal was refused because flood safety arrangements were inadequate.
“A proposal for a city-centre school, from the same applicant, at 20–25 Chapel Road (application ref. 19/00361/FUL) was refused by the Planning and Rights of Way Panel on 11 February 2020. The application was refused on flood risk grounds, as the proposal failed the Exception Test by not demonstrating safe access and egress, safe occupation over the lifetime of the development, or suitable refuge arrangements for vulnerable users.”
“This decision is a material consideration and demonstrates the importance of robust flood risk mitigation and safe access/egress arrangements for school proposals in the city centre.”
Officer report
Why officers recommended approval
Officers considered the departure from the retail allocation acceptable because the site was long vacant, retail interest was absent, and the school benefits outweighed policy conflict.
“The proposal would provide a permanent, purpose-built home for Hope Community School, which has operated from temporary accommodation at Central Hall since 2017. The site is allocated under City Centre Action Plan Policy AP24, for retail-led, mixed-use redevelopment and the application therefore represents a departure from the development plan.”
“Overall, whilst the proposal does not accord with the site’s retail-led allocation, the following factors together outweigh the identified policy conflict and concerns regarding surplus school places: - the long-standing vacancy of a prominent city-centre site; - absence of retail interest; - changing character and function of this part of the city centre; - need for permanent school accommodation; - Local and National policy support for education provision.”
Officer report
Main planning concerns
Highways, residential amenity, design, drainage, flood risk, sustainability and biodiversity were considered acceptable subject to mitigation, obligations and conditions.
“Operational amenity impacts would mainly arise from arrivals and departures, external play, plant and any community use of the school facilities. Environmental Health raises no objection subject to conditions controlling the use of the Year R outdoor area, securing the hard play/PE area fencing, restricting plant and screening, and requiring music/drama room windows to remain closed during noise-generating activities.”
“The site lies in Flood Zone 1 but is at increased long-term tidal flood risk due to climate change and the proposed school is a more vulnerable use. The updated Flood Risk Assessment and Flood Emergency Plan have been accepted by the Lead Local Flood Authority, subject to a Site Flood Plan condition.”
Officer report
What consultees said
Highways and most council consultees raised no objection subject to safeguards, while Education supported a revised one-form-entry and SEND operating model rather than the submitted two-form entry.
“No objection subject to changes to the operational model Southampton City Council’s Education Service supports the Hope Community Free School planning application only on the basis of a revised operating model: retaining the school as one-form entry mainstream provision and using the additional accommodation to provide 60 specialist SEND places. In summary: • Hope currently operates as a one- form entry primary school from temporary premises at Central Hall.”
Officer report
What residents and others said
Most representations supported permanent school accommodation and community benefits, while objections questioned educational need, traffic, safety, flooding, parking, scale and construction impacts.
“Following receipt of the planning application, a publicity exercise, in line with departmental procedures, was undertaken. This included notifying adjoining and nearby landowners, placing a press advertisement advising of the application and its departure status on 06.03.2026, and erecting a site notice on 06.03.2026. At the time of writing the report, 117 representations have been received.”
“Lack of need for a new two-form entry school due to falling birth rates, surplus primary places and the school’s current under-occupation, with concern that it could draw pupils from nearby schools, furthermore the wider community benefits have not been clearly demonstrated, and that the proposal does not reflect wider education priorities. Response The proposal is for the permanent relocation of an existing school rather than a wholly new school.”
Officer report
Who spoke at the meeting
The agent and the school principal addressed the Panel, with the principal speaking in support.
The vote
The recommendation was carried, with five councillors voting for, two against and no abstentions.
“Upon being put to the vote the recommendation was carried.”
“FOR: Councillors Beaurain, Piatkiewicz, Pryce, Windle, Wood AGAINST: Councillors G Lambert, Shields ABSTAINED: None…”
Minutes
The decision
Authority was delegated to the Director of Transport and Planning to grant permission subject to the report’s conditions and completion of a legal agreement.
“RESOLVED That authority be delegated to the Director of Transport and Planning to grant planning permission subject to the conditions in the report and the completion of a s106 legal agreement.”
Minutes
Councillors at the meeting
- Vivienne WindleChairLabourFor
- Sarah WoodVice-ChairLib DemFor
- Jaden BeaurainConservativeFor
- Ginnie LambertLabourAgainst
- Richard PiatkiewiczReform UKFor
- Sam PryceGreenFor
- Dave ShieldsLab Co-opAgainst
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Southampton Planning and Rights of Way Panel minutes, 21 July 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Southampton's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- Southampton
- Date
- Tuesday 21 July 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Approved
- Vote
- 5 for, 2 against (recorded vote)
- Councillors
- 7Labour 2Conservative 1Green 1Lab Co-op 1Lib Dem 1Reform UK 1Show votes
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Southampton committee decisions →
Source: Plota analysis of the minutes.
This committee's year
48 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 4 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.