One dwelling at Ivy's Meadow Treragin, Harrowbarrow
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by Cornwall East Sub-Area Planning Committee on 26 Oct 2026.
What was proposed
The application sought permission in principle for one dwelling on a field at the southern edge of Treragin.
“The application seeks permission in principle for the construction of 1 dwelling. The site consists of a field located at the southern extent of Treragin and is outlined in red on the submitted location plan below. Recently a medium sized motorhome, 2/3 small storage containers and a small polytunnel have been located within the field.”
Officer report
The site and its surroundings
The site sits beside existing homes, is enclosed by hedges and is considered outside the National Landscape.
“The site is enclosed by hedge on the Eastern boundary fronting the highway and to the North. To the West the site bounds an existing dwelling whilst other dwellings exist to the North. Taking these factors into account the proposal is considered to comply with the aims of Policy 3 of the CLP of appearing as a natural completion of the cluster that would not materially extend the built form of the cluster of houses into the open countryside.”
“The site is not located within the National Landscape (formerly Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty).”
Officer report
Earlier application
An earlier application for up to three dwellings was withdrawn in July 2026.
“PA26/04116 Application for Permission in Principle for the construction of up to 3 dwellings (minimum of 1, maximum of 3). Withdrawn 28.07.2026”
Officer report
What officers recommended
Officers recommended approval because the proposal was considered suitable as limited infill, contributed to housing supply and would not cause substantially outweighing harm.
“The proposal is not allocated for development and conflicts with the housing strategy of the NDP. However, the Council is currently unable to demonstrate a five-year supply of deliverable housing land and the relevant housing policies are therefore considered out of date. The proposal would make a modest contribution to local housing supply, which attracts additional weight in the planning balance.”
“Overall, although the proposal conflicts with the NDP's housing strategy, the weight to be given to that conflict is reduced by the current housing land supply position and the out-of-date status of the relevant housing policies.”
Officer report
Consultation responses
The parish council objected, while the National Landscape body made no comment and some supporters backed a home for a local working family.
“Support: • Residential need: Support is expressed on the basis that the proposal would provide a home for a local working family. • Relationship to existing development: It is considered that the site is surrounded by existing residential and other development and that a single dwelling would not appear out of place or materially affect the character of the area.”
Officer report
Concerns raised
Opponents raised concerns about countryside development, landscape, sustainability, highway safety, drainage, ecology, incremental growth and consultation.
“Oppose: • Planning history: No material change has occurred since previous advice/application and reducing the proposal to one dwelling does not overcome the previous objections. • Development plan: The site is outside the settlement boundary and within open countryside, contrary to the spatial strategy of the Calstock Neighbourhood Development Plan.”
“Information Classification: PUBLIC • Ecology and lighting: Potential impacts on biodiversity, wildlife and the area's dark rural character are raised. • Incremental development: Concern is expressed that previous physical changes to the site should not be used to justify further development of the countryside. • Housing need: Residents consider that housing need does not outweigh the site's planning, landscape and sustainability constraints.”
Officer report
Who spoke
A parish councillor spoke against the application, and a supporter spoke in favour; both answered committee questions.
The committee debate
Members discussed the settlement location, housing supply, planning policy and a similar appeal before concluding there were no valid reasons to refuse.
“8 1. This application had been brought to Committee as he felt that it needed a greater degree of scrutiny; 2. The main question was ‘Is this site suitable and a sustainable location for this type of development?’; 3. Does the site have reasonable access to shops/amenities, public transport, and not have a great dependency on a private vehicle; 4. Concern regarding the adequacy of the surrounding road network and the isolated nature of the site; 5.”
“This was the type of application that should be supported; 2. The application site was not within the National Landscape; 3. Due to changes in planning policy and the lack of housing supply, there were no valid planning reasons to refuse the application; 4. Members’ attention was drawn to a similar planning application that was approved on appeal by the Planning Inspector; 5. The application should be approved.”
Minutes
The vote
Members approved the motion by six votes to one, with three abstentions.
“Arising from consideration of the report and debate it was moved by Councillor Thomas, seconded by Councillor O’Keefe, and on a vote of 6 votes in favour, 1 against and 3 abstentions, it was:-”
Minutes
The decision
Permission in principle was granted, with the proposer’s reasons being those set out in the officer report.
“RESOLVED that Permission in Principle for Application No. PA26/05368 be granted.”
“The reasons given by the Proposer for wishing to grant Permission in Principle were as set out in the report.”
Minutes
Councillors at the meeting
- Adrian ParsonsChairLib Dem
- Mark GibbonsVice-ChairIndependent
- Angus BlackReform UK
- Jim CandyLib Dem
- Jim GaleReform UK
- Kevin GreyReform UK
- Andrew LongMebyon Kernow
- James O'KeefeLib Dem
- Jane PascoeConservative
- Joanna KennySubstitute for EmeryLib Dem
- John ThomasSubstitute for MoorcroftIndependent
Proposed by Councillor John Thomas, seconded by Councillor James O'Keefe.
Apologies Faye Emery Lib Dem, Robin Moorcroft Independent
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- Cornwall East Sub-Area Planning Committee minutes, 26 October 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of Cornwall's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- Cornwall
- Date
- Monday 26 October 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Approved
- Vote
- 6 for, 1 against, 3 abstained
- Councillors
- 11Lib Dem 4Reform UK 3Independent 2Conservative 1Mebyon Kernow 1Show councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- Cornwall committee decisions →
Source: Plota analysis of the minutes.
This committee's year
10 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 3 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.