Single storey detached dwelling at Land North East Of 70 St Johns Avenue, Newmarket
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by East Cambridgeshire Planning Committee on 6 May 2026.
No officer report was published for this decision; this summary is from the committee minutes.
A detached dwelling recommended for approval
Officers presented a report recommending approval of a two bedroom, single storey, detached dwelling, correcting the site area to 0.04 hectares.
“26/00009/FUL – North East of 70 St Johns Avenue Olivia Akroyd, Planning Officer, presented a report (AA187, previously circulated) recommending approval for the construction of a two bedroom, single storey, detached dwelling. She explained that the area of the site given in the report was incorrect, as it was actually 0.04 hectares or 0.09 acres.”
Minutes
An objector on land history and power cables
An objector said the land had public power cables running through it, had been the subject of earlier unbuilt permissions, and that the power network operator required access and had objected.
“[the objector], Objector, made the following statement: “I am grateful to speak to you on behalf of the residents most affected by this application. I want to provide some context before detailing our specific objections. This piece of land was left by the original developer as public land and the reason for this is because this land has public services running through it, including the main electricity cables for the surrounding houses.”
“The reason that no-one has built on this land before is because the developers realised that they needed to pay UK Power Networks to move the electricity cables that move across that land and doing so was going to add significant cost to the land and make the build non-viable financially. If you roll the clock forward to now, this latest application appears to be trying to avoid breaking the ground by placing a large static caravan on top of the land.”
Minutes
Councillors question the objector
Councillors asked the objector about the land's history, the power network's objection, parking and turning space, and why previous developers had not built on the site.
A councillor's written objection read out
A councillor's statement opposing approval was read out, citing the street scene, the power network's objection, and the development being non-standard.
“The Senior Democratic Services Officer read out the following statement from Cllr James Lay: “For the following reasons I oppose the recommendation to Approve: The Street Scene. This well-established development consists of two- story houses and not a single one-story property as suggested in the application. UK Power Network has objected due to the underground power cables. I agree, as this problem could be overcome with the power cables being re- sited. 3.”
“May I conclude by saying that as planners we have always considered how important retaining the street scene is to developments and on this occasion this applications design does not fit the bill.”
Minutes
Officers respond on construction and conditions
Officers explained the proposal was not a caravan in law but an alternative construction, that a condition on moving power cables was unnecessary, and that permission would not guarantee development.
“David Morren, Strategic Planning and Development Management Manager, explained that what was proposed was not a caravan, as defined in legislation, but an alternative construction. The Committee would need to consider if the proposed development was compatible with the current street scene. The Committee was also asked to note that the granting of planning permission was no guarantee of development.”
“In reply to Cllr John Trapp, the Strategic Planning and Development Management Manager, explained that there was no need to include a planning condition regarding the need to move the power cables, as this was covered by separate legislation. The National Planning Policy Framework was clear that conditions were unnecessary if the matter in question was covered by alternative legislation.”
Minutes
Earlier permission granted in 2016
The committee had previously granted planning permission for development on the land in October 2016.
“It was noted that the Planning Committee had agreed planning permission for development on the land in question in October 2016.”
Minutes
Members debate the application
Councillors disagreed over whether the design and size were compatible with the street scene, whether power cable access was a planning consideration, and whether more homes were needed.
“Cllr Alan Sharp asserted that the application contravened planning policies ENV1 and ENV2 of the Council’s Local Plan as it was incompatible with the street scene in St Johns Avenue, due to its design and size of front garden. He also expressed concern regarding road safety, as the proposed property was on a bend. UK Power Networks had also objected. He proposed that the planning application be rejected. Cllr Chika Akinwale agreed with Cllr Sharp and seconded this proposal.”
“Cllr Christine Ambrose Smith suggested that this was a suitable location for infill development and so she supported the application. Cllr John Trapp agreed, stating that not all the homes on St Johns Avenue were of the same design or on the same sized sites. He concluded that more homes were needed and this location had good links to public transport.”
Minutes
The members' reasons
The resolution gives these reasons:
“On the grounds that the alternative method of construction and the use of modern materials was considered to be out of character with the street scene and the character of the area in contravention of policy ENV2 in the East Cambridgeshire Local Plan 2015 (as amended 2023).”
Minutes
Source: the council's minutes, quoted word for word.
Councillors at the meeting
- Bill HuntChairConservative
- Mark GoldsackVice-ChairConservative
- Chika AkinwaleLib Dem
- Christine Ambrose SmithConservative
- Lavinia EdwardsConservative
- Martin GoodearlConservative
- Alan Gordon SharpConservative
- John Joseph TrappLib Dem
- Ross Trent
- Christine WhelanLib Dem
- Mary Helen WadeSubstitute for LayLib Dem
Apologies Christine Colbert Lib Dem, James Lay Conservative
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from Democracy Club.
Sources
- East Cambridgeshire Planning Committee minutes, 6 May 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of East Cambridgeshire's committee minutes. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- East Cambridgeshire
- Date
- Wednesday 6 May 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Refused, against officer advice
- Vote
- 8 for refusal, 3 against
- Councillors
- 11Conservative 6Lib Dem 41 otherShow councillors
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- East Cambridgeshire committee decisions →
Source: Plota analysis of the minutes.
This committee's year
8 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 1 against officer advice.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.