Chimney removal and porch at Carpenters Arms, Cosheston, Pembroke Dock

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by Pembrokeshire Planning Committee on 8 Sept 2026.

25/0924/PAApprovedAgainst officer advice

What was proposed

The application sought retrospective permission for two chimney removals and an open front porch, plus permission for a rear retaining wall.

“The application site is located to the north of Point Lane, Cosheston and consists of an irregularly shaped parcel of land, containing a two-storey detached dwelling, which is raised above the level of the adjoining highway.”

“The application seeks retrospective planning permission for the removal of two chimney stacks and the erection of an open porch on the front elevation of the dwelling. Also, the application seeks permission in respect of a retaining wall formed at the rear of the dwelling between the rear elevation and the raised garden behind.”

Officer report

What officers recommended

Officers recommended approving the porch and retaining wall but refusing chimney removal because it harmed the conservation area’s character, appearance and historic environment.

“It is recommended that in respect of the porch and retaining wall the application be APPROVED subject to the following conditions:”

“The removal of the chimney stacks fails to preserve or enhance the character and appearance of this part of the Cosheston Conservation Area, creating harm to visual amenity and failing to protect the historic environment. As such, this part of the application is contrary to the requirements of criterion 2 of policy GN.1 (General Development Policy), criteria 1 and 2 of policy GN.2 (Sustainable Design) and policy GN.38 (Protection and Enhancement of the Historic Environment) and the duty under Section 160 of the Historic Environment (Wales) Act 2023.”

Officer report

The main planning concern

Officers considered the porch and wall acceptable, but said removing the chimneys removed positive architectural detail and made the building discordant in the street scene.

“Whilst the originally submitted elevation plan showed a front door wider than existing, this was an error and an amended plan showing the correct width has been submitted. The amended plans also include a note to confirm that the retaining wall will be faced in stone to match that of the front boundary wall.”

“The simplification of the appearance of this building makes it a discordant feature in this part of the street scene and this is harmful to the visual amenity and to the quality of this part of the Conservation Area.”

Officer report

Consultation and objections

The community council had no objection, while two letters objected to the chimneys, porch, retaining wall, landscaping, visual effects and other matters.

“Two letters of objection have been received raising the following concerns:”

“- Impact of proposal on historic character and Conservation Area - Unauthorised changes - Site is the subject of an ongoing enforcement investigation - Inaccuracies in the submitted plans - Retaining walls and visual impact - Landscaping and environmental impacts - Installation of a subsurface structure - Determination of the application should be by Planning Committee…”

Officer report

Who spoke

The applicant said a builder advised that the chimneys were unsafe, and that a rear chimney was rebuilt for a working log burner.

What members debated

Members debated conservation duties, the visual effect of removing two chimneys, Building Control advice, possible replicas and the risk of setting a precedent.

“In response to a comment raised by Councillor Tony Wilcox that the removal of the chimney stacks was de minimis, the Chief Planning Officer highlighted that it was for Members to decide if a development was harmful and that the term de minimis was for something defined as being of no consequence. The loss of two chimneys was not de minimis as they were an important part of a roof of a building.”

“Councillor Wilcox highlighted that Building Control Officers had agreed that the chimneys could be demolished and that Cosheston Community Council had no objections to the demolition. However, the Chief Planning Officer emphasised that building regulations and planning regulations were completely different.”

Minutes

The votes

Members first rejected the motion to approve the officer recommendation, then carried a motion to approve chimney removal by seven votes to six, with one abstention.

“Councillor John Cole then Moved that the application for removal of the Chimney stacks be approved as there was no significant harm to the conservation area by removal of the chimneys; Seconded by Councillor Tony Wilcox. The Chief Planning Officer clarified that it was a valid reason.”

“Councillor Cormack then declared that the reasons for going against the Officer Recommendation were unclear. Cosheston was a conservation area and that Members should be able to understand why it would not affect the conservation area and queried whether this could be the end of chimneys in the area.”

Minutes

The members' reasons

The minutes do not record the members' reasons for departing from the officers' recommendation.

Sources

  • Pembrokeshire Planning Committee minutes, 8 September 2026
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of Pembrokeshire's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Date
Tuesday 8 September 2026
Recommendation
Officers recommended refusal
Committee decided
Approved, against officer advice
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)

This committee's year

50 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting, 4 against officer advice.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →