Two rural houses at Land At Stoneside Of Dripps Farm Cartside Highway, Thorntonhall

Summary of planning committee decision

Decided by South Lanarkshire Planning Committee on 12 May 2026.

P/26/0029Refused

What was proposed

The application sought two single-storey houses, two new vehicular accesses and associated works, intended to accommodate agricultural workers.

“Description of Proposed Development 3.1. The proposal involves the erection of two single storey dwellinghouses. Both plots would take access from the existing farm access road, set back from the junction but before the recently installed access gate, with the field accesses being removed.”

“The applicant has advised that these houses are intended to serve as accommodation for agricultural workers.”

Officer report

The site and surroundings

The site comprises two agricultural areas on opposite sides of an access road, near existing houses, farmland and a vehicle-related business.

“Site Description 2.1. The application site is non-contiguous and is split into two areas of land on opposite sides of the access road to Stoneside of Dripps Farm, at its junction with Cartside Highway, approximately 1.6km south-west of Thorntonhall.”

“There are two existing houses on the east side of the access road, close to the road junction, behind a recently installed gate across the access road. The space between the existing houses and the public road would form part of the application site, for the proposed eastern plot, with the other part of the site mirroring this position on the opposite side of the access road (the proposed western plot).”

Officer report

Earlier applications and appeals

A similar two-house application was refused and its appeal dismissed, while other farm-related applications included refusals, approvals and a dwelling conversion.

“Relevant Planning History 4.1. There have been a number of recent planning applications submitted for Stoneside of Dripps Farm itself, including the planning refusals for the retrospective change of use of agricultural land to form an agricultural vehicle, plant and machinery sales yard, and the erection of two sheds (P/21/2155 and P/24/1049), and an approval for the erection of 7 new agricultural sheds in March 2024 (P/23/0789). Consent was also approved in January 2023 for the part-change of use and conversion of one of the existing agricultural buildings at the farm to form a new dwellinghouse (P/21/2133).”

“More specifically, planning consent was refused at the Planning Committee meeting of 20 May 2025 for a very similar application at this same site for the erection of two houses (P/24/1300). A subsequent appeal to the Planning and Environmental Appeal Division of the Scottish Government was dismissed (PPA-380-2131).”

Officer report

Why officers recommended refusal

Officers found insufficient evidence that the additional homes were essential, and considered the proposal unjustified in the green belt and contrary to development plan policies.

“It is considered that the proposal would not comply with NPF4 Policy 8, 15 or 17 or with SLLDP2 Policies 4, GBRA8, GBRA9 or GBRA10 and that it would represent an unjustified loss of green belt land. In this respect, in terms of the principle of the development, new housing is not generally supported in the green belt by the development plan unless it is on an identified site, or unless there is a specific locational justification provided for it.”

“As such, insufficient information has been provided to demonstrate that additional dwellings are essential to the operation of the farm. There are a number of nearby settlements, beyond those considered in the supporting information, which could offer a range of accommodation choices and prices.”

Officer report

Design and environmental concerns

The proposal was considered likely to increase car journeys, remove significant hedgerow habitat and provide plots whose size and layout did not respect nearby properties.

“In addition, there are existing buildings neighbouring the site, but it is not considered that this limited number of structures could be considered as a ‘building group’, and they do not form a clearly identifiable nucleus with strong visual cohesion given their limited numbers and the overall setting. The proposal would double the size of this ‘group’ and spread it to the opposite side of the access road without justification.”

“The overall size, scale and design of the proposed dwellinghouses are generally in keeping with the wider character of their rural setting, however, the house plots themselves are significantly larger in size than the adjacent existing properties. The proposed houses have been reduced in size from the previous application; however the plots are the same size for procedural reasons, and they do not respect or reflect the layout of the area.”

Officer report

Consultation responses

Roads, environmental services and Scottish Water raised no objections, subject to conditions or advisory matters where applicable.

“Consultations 6.1. Roads Development Management – have raised no objections to the proposal, subject to conditions on parking spaces, EV charging, and visibility splays being imposed, and the removal of the existing gated field accesses. Response: Noted. These matters could be addressed on the decision notice if the application was to be approved.”

“Environmental Services – have raised no objections to the proposal subject to conditions regarding dust management and construction noise, and the inclusion of relevant advisory notes. Response: Noted. These matters could be addressed on the decision notice if the application was to be approved.”

Officer report

Neighbour representations

No valid representations were received following neighbour notification and advertisement.

“Representations 7.1. Following the statutory period of neighbour notification and advertisement, no valid representations have been received.”

Officer report

The committee’s decision

The committee refused the application for the reasons detailed in the officers’ report, including insufficient justification, unsuitable location and inadequate evidence of essential worker need.

“P/26/0029 for Erection of 2 Houses, the Formation of 2 New Vehicular Accesses and Associated Works at Land at Stoneside of Dripps Farm, Cartside Highway, Thorntonhall A report dated 5 May 2026 by the Executive Director (Community and Enterprise Resources) was submitted on planning application P/26/0029 by Carnbroe Estates Limited for the erection of 2 houses, the formation of 2 new vehicular accesses and associated works at land at Stoneside of Dripps Farm, Cartside Highway,…”

“The Committee decided: that planning application P/26/0029 by Carnbroe Estates Limited for the erection of 2 houses, the formation of 2 new vehicular accesses and associated works at land at Stoneside of Dripps Farm, Cartside Highway, Thorntonhall be refused for the reasons detailed in the Executive Director’s report.”

Minutes

Councillors at the meeting

The minutes record this decision with no vote against, so each member present for this item is shown as voting for it.

Apologies Mary Donnelly SNP, Joe Fagan Labour, Cal Johnston-Dempsey SNP, Martin Patrick Lennon Labour, Richard Nelson Conservative, David Watson Independent

Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from Democracy Club.

Sources

  • South Lanarkshire Planning Committee minutes, 12 May 2026
  • Agenda and papers (council website)

Source: Plota analysis of South Lanarkshire's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.

Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API

The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.

See the API →

At the meeting

Date
Tuesday 12 May 2026
Recommendation
Officers recommended refusal
Committee decided
Refused
Councillors
18SNP 8Labour 5Conservative 2Lab Co-op 2Lib Dem 1Show votes
Minutes
The council's minutes
Meeting
Agenda and papers (council website)

This committee's year

53 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting.

Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.

Every decision by this council's committees →