The Old Smithy Main Street Elmley Castle Pershore WR10 3HS Data via plota.co.uk

W/25/01805/LB - Listed Building Consent Refused

Proposal

Two storey rear extension including retaining wall and steps and internal alterations (Listed Building Consent) Data via plota.co.uk

View original council record ↗Last checked

Application progress

✓
Received
26 Aug 2025
✓
Validated
15 Sept 2025
✗
Refused
18 Dec 2025
✗
Appeal dismissed
25 Jun 2026

Refused on 18 Dec 2025 · Committee · Last checked 13 Oct 2026

Planning committee

Decided by Wychavon Planning Committee on 11 Dec 2025.

Refused

Against officer advice: officers had recommended approval.

  • Officers advised approval because the extension was considered acceptable in size and scale and would not harm the listed building.
  • Objectors raised concerns about lost daylight, overbearing effects, heritage, materials, rooflights and overdevelopment.
  • The committee refused listed building consent because the application was not justified without consent for the previous application.
Read how the committee decided The proposed extension, site history, officers’ assessment, objections, committee debate and reasons for refusal. Includes the meeting recording, from 2:53:55 where this application was taken

Source: Plota analysis of Wychavon's committee minutes of 11 Dec 2025.

Documents 76

Consultation & comments 17

PDF Appellant's Final Comments - Interested Party Comments Rebuttal Document 32. Appeal Appellants Case · 16 Apr 2026 View ↗ PDF Appeal Interested Party Comments 6005291 31. Appeal Documents · 31 Mar 2026 View ↗ PDF Third Party Comments On Lbc Appeal At Old Smithy 31. Appeal Documents · 31 Mar 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show 31. Appeal Documents · 31 Mar 2026 View ↗
PDF Interested Party Comment 31. Appeal Documents · 31 Mar 2026 View ↗
PDF Commenter’s name hidden Show 31. Appeal Documents · 31 Mar 2026 View ↗
PDF Cost Appeal Rebuttal Costs D letter - Appeal 6005291 and 6005290 - APPELLANT COSTS FINAL COMMENT.pdf 32. Appeal Appellants Case · 4 Mar 2026 View ↗ PDF Appendix 9 - LPA Conservation Officer comments 32. Appeal Appellants Case · 19 Feb 2026 View ↗
PDF Objector’s name hidden Show Document · 10 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF 09. Response - Statutory Consultee Document · 14 Nov 2025 View ↗ PDF 09a. Response - Statutory Consultee Attachment Mr Andrew Robinson · 23 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF 09a. Response - Statutory Consultee Attachment Conservation Officer · 22 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF 08a. Response - Neighbour and Other Attachment D Harvey · 16 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF 08a. Response - Neighbour and Other Attachment Sarah Harvey · 15 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF 08a. Response - Neighbour and Other Attachment Stansgate Planning · 7 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF 08a. Response - Neighbour and Other Attachment Rebecca Staffolani · 3 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF Appendix 5 Neighbouring Daylight And Sunlight Assesswent 02. Supporting Information · 26 Aug 2025 View ↗

Other documents 25

PDF 31. Appeal Documents Appeal Note · 31 Mar 2026 View ↗ PDF 33. Appeal Councils Case Cost Rebuttal · 2 Mar 2026 View ↗ PDF 6005291 Lpa Questionnaire Submission 31. Appeal Documents · 27 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF START DATE - New planning listed building and conservation area appeal_ 6005291 31. Appeal Documents · 23 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF Costs letter B - 6005290 and 6005291 - Cost Award -The Old Smithy - redacted.pdf 32. Appeal Appellants Case · 23 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF Appendix 3 - Commitee Report - W2501806HP.docx 32. Appeal Appellants Case · 19 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF Appendix 4 - Planning Commitee Minutes - 11 December 2025.pdf 32. Appeal Appellants Case · 19 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF Appendix 6 - Knights, R On the Application Of v South Norfolk District Council [2025] EWHC 2205 (Admin) (22 August 2025).pdf 32. Appeal Appellants Case · 19 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF Appendix 10 - Enforcement Matters.pdf 32. Appeal Appellants Case · 19 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF Appendix 11 - LPA Correspondence.pdf 32. Appeal Appellants Case · 19 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF Elmley Castle, Bricklehampton and Netherton Parish Council Document · 11 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF Elmley Castle, Bricklehampton and Netherton Parish Council Document · 11 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF Elmley Castle, Bricklehampton and Netherton Parish Council Document · 10 Dec 2025 View ↗
PDF Name hidden Show Document · 23 Oct 2025 View ↗
PDF Conservation Officer - Conservation Officer Document · 22 Oct 2025 View ↗
PDF Name hidden Show Document · 16 Oct 2025 View ↗
PDF Name hidden Show Document · 15 Oct 2025 View ↗
PDF Name hidden Show Document · 13 Oct 2025 View ↗
PDF Name hidden Show Document · 7 Oct 2025 View ↗
PDF Stansgate Planning 4 The Courtyard, Timothy’s Bridge Road, Stratford-upon-Avon, CV37 9NP Document · 7 Oct 2025 View ↗
PDF Name hidden Show Document · 7 Oct 2025 View ↗
PDF Name hidden Show Document · 3 Oct 2025 View ↗
PDF Name hidden Show Document · 29 Sept 2025 View ↗
PDF Name hidden Show 02. Supporting Information · 27 Aug 2025 View ↗
PDF Appendix 9 Highway Consultant Report 02. Supporting Information · 26 Aug 2025 View ↗

All documents on the council site ↗

Site constraints 9

Cotswolds National Landscape
Great weight to conserving the landscape; major development restricted.
Previously an area of outstanding natural beauty, which is still the designation in law. Since 2023 authorities must seek to further its purpose, not merely have regard to it.
Elmley Castle conservation area
Demolition needs planning permission and permitted development is restricted.
The council must give weight to preserving or enhancing the area's character and appearance. Not every council has published its boundaries as open data.
Council document ↗
Habitat network: Network Enhancement Zone 1
Where habitat is joined up enough to work as a network. Context, not a constraint on its own.
21 listed buildings within 150 m of the postcode pin
Nearest: Cottage North of Drakely Cottage Drakely Cottage Grooms Cottage, Grade II, about 36 m from the postcode pin · 21 Grade II
The site itself is not listed. Listed building consent is needed for work that affects the special interest of a listed building, inside or out, on top of planning permission. Setting can be a consideration for buildings nearby; there is no fixed radius.
Show all 21 with distances
Historic England ↗
Also on the record
Scheduled monument about 197 m away: Elmley Castle village cross; Special area of conservation about 410 m away: Bredon Hill; SSSI about 410 m away: Bredon Hill SSSI; Inside the Elmley Castle built-up area; Natural England's Provisional ALC map (1:250,000, 1970s) had this area as grade 3, but it predates the buildings here and the current map does not class it as farmland.
Not affected
Outside flood zones 2 and 3 · Not green belt

Checked on 2 November 2026. The pin for this application is the centre of its postcode rather than the building, so distances to nearby designations are measured from the postcode and can be out by the width of the postcode area. Historic England, the Environment Agency, Natural England and council datasets, Open Government Licence. A boundary can run through a site and the council holds the definitive record: confirm with the council before relying on this.

Sales history 1

Last sold for £605,000 in September 2022. Terraced house, freehold.

30 September 2022£605,000

Sale prices from HM Land Registry's price paid record, matched to this application by its address.

Work with planning data?

Every application in Wychavon - and every UK council - as a live feed, an API, or a bulk CSV export.

About Plota's data service

Important details

Council
Wychavon
Application type
Listed Building Consent
Postcode
WR10 3HS
Received
26 Aug 2025
Validated
15 Sept 2025
Ward
Bredon Hill Ward
Parish
Elmley Castle
Case officer
Show
Decision
Dismissed
Decision date
18 Dec 2025
Decision level
Committee
Appeal
Dismissed · 25 Jun 2026 · Written Representations · Inspectorate case 6005291 ↗
Applicant
Show
Agent
Fisher German LLP

How this decision compares

Decided in 94 days from validation, 11 days slower than Wychavon's median of 83 for listed building works. Refused, as 9% of listed building works here are.

32%decided within 8 weeks
91%approved
60decided in the last year

Plota live figures for listed building works decided by Wychavon in the last twelve months, from validation. Wychavon decision record →

Public comments

2comments received
1 objecting1 neutral

9 neighbours consulted · Last counted 13 Oct 2026

Read the comments on the council site ↗

Consultation & key dates

Consultation
16 Sept 2025
Comments by
16 Oct 2025
Committee
11 Dec 2025
Wychavon
Planning Authority Score
6.4/10
Average
#86 of 296 councils
Relevant to this application:
Other decisions

Wychavon is one of the fastest councils in England for householder decisions, ranking #19 out of 296. Householder applications are slightly more likely to be approved here (91%) than the national average (90%).

Among the fastest councils in England
for householder decisions
These figures are council-wide context, not a prediction for this application. View full council performance
Wychavon decision statistics
Based on MHCLG data, the year to March 2026
86%
Overall approval rate
Below avg (87%) #202 of 296
91%
Householder approved
Above avg (90%) #186 of 296
88%
Decided in 8 weeks
Above avg (63%) #19 of 296
36%
Extended time limit
Below avg (41%) #117 of 296
65%
Minor dwellings approved
220 decided (1-9 homes)
98%
Major dwellings approved
42 decided (10+ homes)
91%
Change of use approved
54 decided
1,082
Total decisions
151 refused in the year to March 2026

Sale prices: Contains HM Land Registry data © Crown copyright and database right 2026. This data is licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.