Car Care Centre 5 James Street York YO10 3WW Data via plota.co.uk

25/01608/FULM - Major Full Application Refused

Proposal

Demolition of existing motor cycle showroom (sui generis) and erection of a purpose-built student accommodation (sui generis) with up to 102 student bedrooms and associated landscaping and parking Data via plota.co.uk

View original council record ↗Last checked

Application progress

✓
Received
13 Aug 2025
✓
Validated
20 Aug 2025
✗
Refused
17 Mar 2026
Appeal
Not lodged

Refused on 17 Mar 2026 · Planning Committee · Last checked 16 Oct 2026

Planning committee

Decided by York Planning Committee on 12 Mar 2026.

Refused unanimously

As officers recommended.

  • Officers advised refusal because employment-land requirements were not met and the scheme would provide poor-quality living conditions.
  • The planning panel and a resident objected to employment-land loss, oversaturation, overdevelopment and transport arrangements.
  • Members unanimously refused the application after debating the officer recommendation.
Read how the committee decided The proposed accommodation, site history, officers’ assessment, objections, speakers, debate, vote and reasons for refusal. Includes the meeting recording, from 0:07:46 where this application was taken

Source: Plota analysis of York's committee minutes of 12 Mar 2026.

Documents 120

Statements & assessments 43

PDF PLANNING STATEMENT - MARCH 2026 Report · 10 Mar 2026 View ↗ PDF FLOOD RISK ENGINEER & LLFA Internal Responses · 2 Mar 2026 View ↗ PDF LEAD LOCAL FLOOD AUTHORITY Internal Responses · 2 Mar 2026 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED DRAINAGE LAYOUT Revised Drawing · 6 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF DRAINAGE CONSTRUCTION DETAILS SHEET 2 Revised Drawing · 6 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF TRANSPORT STATEMENT ADDENDUM Report · 7 Jan 2026 View ↗ PDF ARCHAEOLOGICAL DESK-BASED ASSESSMENT - REV 1 Report · 24 Nov 2025 View ↗ PDF GEO-ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT Land Contamination Assessment · 30 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF ARCHAEOLOGICAL DESK-BASED ASSESSMENT Superseded Report · 30 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT TEAM Internal Responses · 20 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF ECOLOGY OFFICER Internal Responses · 7 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF ARCHAEOLOGICAL DESK-BASED ASSESSMENT REV 1 Superseded Report · 30 Sept 2025 View ↗ PDF FLOOD RISK & DRAINAGE STRATEGY - VERSION 1.2 Flood Risk Assessment · 24 Sept 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED DRAINAGE LAYOUT Superseded Drawing · 24 Sept 2025 View ↗ PDF DRAINAGE CALCULATIONS Drainage Documentation · 24 Sept 2025 View ↗ PDF FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT TEAM Internal Responses · 3 Sept 2025 View ↗ PDF BNG METRIC Report · 20 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF ARBORICULTURAL SURVEY AND IMPACT ASSESSMENT Report · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF BIODIVERSITY NET GAIN REPORT Report · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF BREEAM PRE-ASSESSMENT REPORT Report · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF DAYLIGHTING ASSESSMENT Daylight or Sunlight Assessment · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF ARCHAEOLOGICAL DESK BASED ASSESSMENT Superseded Report · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF ENERGY STATEMENT Report · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF EXISITING DRAINAGE PLAN LF Drainage Documentation · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF EXISITING DRAINAGE REPORT LF Drainage Documentation · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PRELIMINARY ECOLOGICAL APPRAISAL WITH PRELIMARY ROOST ASSESSMENT Report · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF SUSTAINABILITY STATEMENT Sustainability Appraisal · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF SUSTAINABLE DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION STATEMENT Sustainability Appraisal · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF TOPOGRAPHICAL SURVEY Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF TRANSPORT STATEMENT Transport Assessment · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF ASBESTOS REFURB AND DEMOLITION SURVEY Report · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF ENVIRONMENTAL NOISE STUDY Noise Impact Assessment · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF DESIGN AND ACCESS STATEMENT PART 1 Design & Access Statement · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF DESIGN AND ACCESS STATEMENT PART 2 Design & Access Statement · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF FLOOD RISK & DRAINAGE STRATEGY Superseded Report · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF AIR QUALITY ASSESSMENT Air Quality Assessment · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF DRAINAGE CONSTRUCTION DETAILS Drainage Documentation · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF STORM WATER STRATEGY AND MAINTENANCE PLAN Flood Risk Assessment · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED LEVELS Drainage Documentation · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED EXCEEDANCE PLAN Drainage Documentation · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED DRAINAGE LAYOUT Superseded Report · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF IMPERMEABLE AREA PLAN Drainage Documentation · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF DRAINAGE CONSTRUCTION DETAILS Drainage Documentation · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗

Plans & drawings 32

PDF HEDGE PLANTING TO ELVINGTON TERRACE Drawing · 6 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED EAST AND WEST ELEVATIONS Revised Drawing · 20 Jan 2026 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED SOUTH ELEVATION Revised Drawing · 20 Jan 2026 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED FLOOR PLAN - LEVELS 1 AND 2 Revised Drawing · 20 Jan 2026 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED GROUND FLOOR PLAN Revised Drawing · 20 Jan 2026 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED GROUND FLOOR PLAN Superseded Drawing · 16 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED SITE PLAN Revised Drawing · 16 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED SOUTH ELEVATION Superseded Drawing · 16 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED THIRD FLOOR PLAN Revised Drawing · 16 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF LANDSCAPE GENERAL ARRANGEMENT Superseded Drawing · 16 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED FIRST AND SECOND FLOOR PLANS Superseded Drawing · 16 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED ELEVATIONS - EAST AND WEST Superseded Drawing · 16 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED ROOF PLAN Revised Drawing · 16 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED NORTH ELEVATION Revised Drawing · 16 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF EXISTING ELEVATIONS Drawing · 20 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF TRAVEL PLAN Travel Plan · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF OPERATIONAL WASTE MANAGEMENT PLAN Site Waste Management Plan · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED PLAN - LEVEL G Superseded Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED PLAN - LEVELS 1-2 Superseded Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED PLAN - LEVEL 3 Superseded Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED PLAN - ROOF Superseded Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED ELEVATION - SOUTH Superseded Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED ELEVATION - NORTH Superseded Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED ELEVATIONS - EAST AND WEST Superseded Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED BAY STUDY Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED SECTION 1 Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED SECTION 2 Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF REFUSE AND ASHP ENCLOSURE Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF LANDSCAPE GENERAL ARRANGEMENT Superseded Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF SITE LOCATION PLAN Location Plan · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF EXISTING SITE PLAN Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗ PDF PROPOSED SITE PLAN Superseded Drawing · 13 Aug 2025 View ↗

Consultation & comments 21

PDF Objector’s name hidden Show Objection Comment · 5 Mar 2026 View ↗
PDF Objector’s name hidden Show Objection Comment · 4 Mar 2026 View ↗
PDF Objector’s name hidden Show Objection Comment · 4 Mar 2026 View ↗
PDF LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT Internal Responses · 13 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF APPLICANT RESPONSE TO LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT CONSULTEE COMMENTS Report · 6 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATION OF COMPLETE DEVELOPMENT Photographs & Photomontages · 6 Feb 2026 View ↗ PDF HIGHWAYS DEVELOPMENT CONTROL Internal Responses · 7 Jan 2026 View ↗ PDF CONSERVATION OFFICER Internal Responses · 5 Jan 2026 View ↗ PDF LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT Internal Responses · 31 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF STRATEGIC PLANNING POLICY Internal Responses · 23 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF MARKETING SUMMARY COMMENTARY Report · 1 Dec 2025 View ↗ PDF ARCHAEOLOGY Internal Responses · 15 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF CONSERVATION ARCHITECT Internal Responses · 3 Oct 2025 View ↗ PDF STRATEGIC PLANNING POLICY Internal Responses · 25 Sept 2025 View ↗ PDF HIGHWAYS DEVELOPMENT CONTROL Internal Responses · 19 Sept 2025 View ↗ PDF LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT Internal Responses · 16 Sept 2025 View ↗ PDF NORTH YORKSHIRE POLICE Consultee Reponses · 11 Sept 2025 View ↗ PDF AFFORDABLE HOUSING Internal Responses · 8 Sept 2025 View ↗ PDF ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH OFFICER Internal Responses · 7 Sept 2025 View ↗
PDF Objector’s name hidden Show Objection Comment · 4 Sept 2025 View ↗
PDF CITY ARCHAEOLOGIST Internal Responses · 2 Sept 2025 View ↗

All documents on the council site ↗

Site constraints 5

Article 4 direction
HMO. Named permitted development rights are withdrawn here.
An Article 4 direction withdraws particular permitted development rights, so work that would normally need no application needs one here. Not every council has published its directions.
Local nature reserve 279 m away: St Nicholas Fields
Work nearby can need a habitats assessment.
Harm to a protected site is only accepted where there is no alternative and an overriding public interest.
Scheduled monument 147 m away: City Walls, gates, posterns (not including the section from Bootham Bar to Monk Bar, N of the Minster, now part of National Monument No 13280), moats, mounds, Bayle (or Baile) Hill, St Leonard's Hospi
Its setting is a consideration for work nearby.
Nationally important archaeology protected by the Secretary of State. Work that affects the monument or its setting is rarely permitted.
Historic England ↗
Also on the record
1 listed building within 150 m; Inside the York built-up area.
Not affected
Outside flood zones 2 and 3 · Not green belt

Checked on 1 November 2026. Historic England, the Environment Agency, Natural England and council datasets, Open Government Licence. A boundary can run through a site and the council holds the definitive record: confirm with the council before relying on this.

Work with planning data?

Every application in York - and every UK council - as a live feed, an API, or a bulk CSV export.

About Plota's data service

Important details

Council
York
Application type
Major Full Application
Postcode
YO10 3WW
Received
13 Aug 2025
Validated
20 Aug 2025
Ward
Guildhall
Parish
Guildhall Planning Panel
Case officer
Show
Target decision
20 Feb 2026
Decision
Refuse
Decision date
17 Mar 2026
Decision level
Planning Committee
Applicant
Show
Agent
Vista Planning Ltd

How this decision compares

Decided in 209 days from validation, 153 days slower than York's median of 56 for full applications. Refused, as 15% of full applications here are.

55%decided within 8 weeks
85%approved
901decided in the last year

Plota live figures for full applications decided by York in the last twelve months, from validation. York decision record →

Public comments

5comments received
4 objecting1 neutral

80% object · above the UK average of 74%

39 neighbours consulted · Last counted 16 Oct 2026

Read the comments on the council site ↗

Consultation & key dates

Alt. reference
PP-14229970
Planning Portal ref
PP-14229970
Comments by
5 Oct 2026
Committee
12 Mar 2026
Statutory expiry
19 Nov 2025
Env. assessment
No
York
Planning Authority Score
3.7/10
Below average
#213 of 296 overall
Relevant to this application:
Major dwellings

York is #156 of 296 councils on householder decision speed. Householder applications are slightly less likely to be approved here (87%) than the national average (90%).

These figures are council-wide context, not a prediction for this application. View full council performance
York decision statistics
Based on MHCLG data, the year to March 2026
82%
Overall approval rate
Below avg (87%) #255 of 296
87%
Householder approved
Below avg (90%) #237 of 296
64%
Decided in 8 weeks
Above avg (63%) #156 of 296
42%
Extended time limit
Above avg (41%) #168 of 296
69%
Minor dwellings approved
104 decided (1-9 homes)
71%
Major dwellings approved
17 decided (10+ homes)
63%
Change of use approved
68 decided
1,278
Total decisions
224 refused in the year to March 2026

Freehold boundary: © Crown copyright and database rights 2026, HM Land Registry. Polygons © Crown copyright and database rights 2026 Ordnance Survey 100026316. Conditions of use