Car Care Centre 5 James Street York YO10 3WW Data via plota.co.uk
Proposal
Demolition of existing motor cycle showroom (sui generis) and erection of a purpose-built student accommodation (sui generis) with up to 102 student bedrooms and associated landscaping and parking Data via plota.co.uk
Application progress
Refused on 17 Mar 2026 · Planning Committee · Last checked 16 Oct 2026
Planning committee
Decided by York Planning Committee on 12 Mar 2026.
Refused unanimously
As officers recommended.
- Officers advised refusal because employment-land requirements were not met and the scheme would provide poor-quality living conditions.
- The planning panel and a resident objected to employment-land loss, oversaturation, overdevelopment and transport arrangements.
- Members unanimously refused the application after debating the officer recommendation.
Source: Plota analysis of York's committee minutes of 12 Mar 2026.
Documents 120
Decision & officer reports 2
Statements & assessments 43
Plans & drawings 32
Application forms 1
Consultation & comments 21
Other documents 21
Site constraints 5
Checked on 1 November 2026. Historic England, the Environment Agency, Natural England and council datasets, Open Government Licence. A boundary can run through a site and the council holds the definitive record: confirm with the council before relying on this.
Every application in York - and every UK council - as a live feed, an API, or a bulk CSV export.
Other new applications on this street
Nearby new applications
2A James Street York
Change of use of mechanic storage building (use class B2) to pilates studio (use...
Willow House 34 Long Close Lane York YO10 4UP
Conditions 11 (CEMP), 24 (CEMP: Biodiversity), 29 (Sightlines) and 30 (CMP: High...
Perio News Warehouse Charlotte Street York YO10 3ET
Conditions 4 (Surface Water) and 9 (CEMP) of 24/01856/FUL
Important details
- Council
- York
- Application type
- Major Full Application
- Postcode
- YO10 3WW
- Received
- 13 Aug 2025
- Validated
- 20 Aug 2025
- Ward
- Guildhall
- Parish
- Guildhall Planning Panel
- Case officer
- Show
- Target decision
- 20 Feb 2026
- Decision
- Refuse
- Decision date
- 17 Mar 2026
- Decision level
- Planning Committee
- Applicant
- Show
- Agent
- Vista Planning Ltd
How this decision compares
Decided in 209 days from validation, 153 days slower than York's median of 56 for full applications. Refused, as 15% of full applications here are.
Plota live figures for full applications decided by York in the last twelve months, from validation. York decision record →
Public comments
80% object · above the UK average of 74%
39 neighbours consulted · Last counted 16 Oct 2026
Consultation & key dates
- Alt. reference
- PP-14229970
- Planning Portal ref
- PP-14229970
- Comments by
- 5 Oct 2026
- Committee
- 12 Mar 2026
- Statutory expiry
- 19 Nov 2025
- Env. assessment
- No
Historical activity at this location
25 nearby applications on record - archival context, not part of the live application.
Nearby activity
York is #156 of 296 councils on householder decision speed. Householder applications are slightly less likely to be approved here (87%) than the national average (90%).
Freehold boundary: © Crown copyright and database rights 2026, HM Land Registry. Polygons © Crown copyright and database rights 2026 Ordnance Survey 100026316. Conditions of use
Track this application
Car Care Centre 5 James Street York YO10 3WW
Tracking this application
Not there after a minute? Check your junk folder. It's from alerts@plota.co.uk.
Go to your dashboard →Sign in to view contact details
Applicant and case-officer names are hidden from public view for privacy. Create a free Plota account - or sign back in - and we'll show them, plus you get a dashboard for alerts and tracked applications.
Check your email
Sign in to see who commented
Councils publish the names of people who comment on an application. We keep them out of public view and search engines. Sign in free and we'll show them.
