50 dwellings at Site Of Duckmanton Lodge, Top Road, Calow
Summary of planning committee decision
Decided by North East Derbyshire Planning Committee on 3 Nov 2026.
The site and surroundings
The former lodge and grounds contained derelict buildings and hardstanding, with most of the site in countryside beyond Calow’s settlement limits.
“The application site is the former Duckmanton Lodge and grounds and lies partly within the defined settlement development limits (SDL) for Calow with the majority of the site lying within the countryside. The area of the site outside of the SDL is allocated as recreational use but is listed as ‘out of service’.”
“The site is currently occupied by a set of derelict buildings and associated hardstanding which are overgrown by vegetation. Beyond this the site extends to the north and east and is generally open in nature. It is well screened by trees and hedgerows with an existing access off Chesterfield Road.”
Officer report
Earlier planning history
Earlier applications for conversion, demolition, residential development and associated buildings at the site had been conditionally approved.
“NED/09/868/FL - Conversion and adaptation of existing buildings to form three dwellings and an office and erection of a cattery (revised scheme to NED/09/00562/FL) (Amended Plan) – conditionally approved.”
“NED/12/00725/FL - Part demolition of existing outbuildings and extensions, conversion of former lodge building to residential use and construction of a new detached dwelling with swimming pool and double garage (revised scheme to NED/12/00246/FL) (Departure from Development Plan) (Amended Plans/Amended Title) (Further Amended Plans/Additional Information) – conditionally approved.”
Officer report
What officers recommended
Officers recommended conditional approval because the benefits of housing, regeneration, open space and biodiversity outweighed identified policy and environmental harms.
“The proposal therefore conflicts with Local Plan Policy SS9 and does not fully accord with the spatial strategy of the development plan. Furthermore, the development would result in the loss of part of a designated recreation site and, whilst replacement open space, allotments and community facilities are proposed, the scheme does not fully satisfy the requirements of Policy ID10 in respect of equivalent quantitative replacement provision.”
“Significant weight is attached to the benefits of the development. The proposal would deliver 50 dwellings in a sustainable location adjoining a Level 2 settlement at a time when the Council cannot demonstrate a five-year supply of deliverable housing sites. The delivery of market housing in these circumstances carries substantial weight.”
Officer report
Consultees’ views
The parish council supported the proposal, while highways, flood, environmental, wildlife and other consultees raised no objections subject to conditions.
“Environmental Health have raised no objections subject to conditions in relation to contaminated land; sound insulation; and construction hours of working.”
“There are no objections subject to conditions relating to badger mitigation; bat mitigation; Construction Environmental Management Plan; Habitat Management and Monitoring Plan; species enhancement; wildlife kerbs; and lighting.”
Officer report
What residents said
Objectors raised concerns about traffic, drainage, mining, infrastructure, scale, countryside, allotments, ecology, security, heritage and supporting information.
“Significant concerns have been raised regarding the impact of the development on the local highway network, particularly Top Road (A632). • Residents state that Top Road already experiences high traffic volumes, congestion and periods where traffic comes to a standstill, particularly following recent housing developments and ongoing growth at Markham Vale.”
“Several representations reference the Coal Authority's objection and concerns regarding the site's mining legacy. [Officer note: The Coal Authority do not object to the proposals] • Objectors note that the site lies within a coal mining high-risk area and that mine entries and shallow workings are recorded within or close to the site. • Concerns have been raised that not all mine entries have been fully investigated. • Existing mining information may be incomplete.”
Officer report
Who spoke
The committee heard from an objector and the applicant before considering the application.
What members discussed
Members supported the site design but discussed early delivery of landscaping, hedgerow planting, the compound location, viability review and contribution shortfalls.
“Committee discussed the application, Members shared a general support for the for the design of the site plan, particularly the retention of older mature trees. Members also referred to risks that some developers had with liquidation problems having failed to deliver on schemes such as public open space and landscaping, and therefore asked officers if this could be something delivered early in the scheme rather than towards the end.”
“The Committee raised concerns regarding loss of some hedgerow and suggested it be conditioned that hedgerows could be put along the fencing that would border the allotments. Officers indicated that this could be specifically referenced in the landscaping condition. In discussion with officers, Members raised the introduction of a condition for an early viability review at 25% through the phasing of the development.”
Minutes
The vote
A motion to grant permission in line with the officer recommendation was proposed, seconded and approved.
“At the conclusion of the discussion Councillor W Jones and Councillor K Rouse moved and seconded a Motion to grant the application, in line with officer recommendation and subject to conditions regarding hedgerows, the location of the site compound, and an early viability review at the 25% stage of the phasing of the development. The Motion was put to a vote and approved.”
Minutes
The decision
Planning permission was conditionally approved subject to a legal agreement and additional requirements for hedgerows, the compound location and an early viability review.
“That planning permission be conditionally approved subject to the legal agreement to secure the contributions and the conditions and informatives set out in the report, with the final wording of the conditions delegated to the Planning Manager (Development Manager), subject to conditions regarding hedgerows, the location of the site compound, and an early viability review at the 25% stage of the phasing of the development.”
Minutes
Councillors at the meeting
- Lee HartshorneChairLabourFor(no vote against recorded)
- Neil BakerConservativeFor(no vote against recorded)
- Stephen CloughConservativeFor(no vote against recorded)
- Andrew CooperIndependentFor(no vote against recorded)
- Christine GareLabourFor(no vote against recorded)
- William JonesConservativeFor(no vote against recorded)
- Heather LiggettReform UKFor(no vote against recorded)
- Fran PetersenLabourFor(no vote against recorded)
- Kathy RouseLabourFor(no vote against recorded)
The minutes record this decision with no vote against, so each member present for this item is shown as voting for it.
Apologies Tony Lacey Labour, David Hancock NED IND
Source: Plota analysis of the council's minutes; parties from the council's list of councillors.
Sources
- North East Derbyshire Planning Committee minutes, 3 November 2026
- Agenda and papers (council website)
Source: Plota analysis of North East Derbyshire's committee minutes and officer report. Quotations are the council's own words; headings and summaries are Plota's.
Committee decisions and nationwide planning applications, in one API
The Plota API returns planning applications from every council we cover, each with its decision, whether a committee or officers decided it, and the committee date. Build it into your own tools.
See the API →At the meeting
- Council
- North East Derbyshire
- Date
- Tuesday 3 November 2026
- Recommendation
- Officers recommended approval
- Committee decided
- Approved
- Councillors
- 9Labour 4Conservative 3Independent 1Reform UK 1Show votes
- Minutes
- The council's minutes
- Meeting
- Agenda and papers (council website)
- Application
- View application →
- All decisions
- North East Derbyshire committee decisions →
This committee's year
13 decisions in the 12 months to this meeting.
Source: Plota analysis of the committee's minutes.