Accessible viewing area at The Oval Ground, Ynyshir

What was proposed

The application sought an accessible viewing platform with low retaining walls and a converted container providing sheltered viewing for disabled spectators.

“In addition, as denoted within the application description, the applicant proposes to install a converted shipping container upon the slab, to provide a sheltered viewing area for disabled spectators when required and in this regard, the applicant has advised that the new platform has been designed to support the static load of the container.”

Officer report

The site

The proposal was within The Oval Football Ground, part of Ynyshir Park, near residential properties, a children’s play area and a primary school.

“The application site relates to an existing football ground which forms part of a larger recreation area known as Ynyshir Park, which is located to the south of Church Terrace and William Street, Ynyshir.”

“Vehicular access is gained via a gated entrance which runs along the eastern boundary of the site and adjoins Church Terrace. The remainder of the park is occupied by a public children's play area (southern element), beyond which is Ynyshir Primary School.”

Officer report

Earlier planning decisions

Earlier applications at the football pitch included permissions for a football stand, information boards and a revised football-ground scheme that was withdrawn.

“23/0014/FUL: Ynyshir Park Football Pitch, Church Terrace, Ynys-Hir, Porth, CF39 0ET. Construction of clubhouse and extension of ground to create parking area (Revised description, redline boundary receive 03/10/23) (Amended plans received 23/11/23). Decision: Withdrawn, 23/10/24”

“22/1035/ADV: Ynyshir Park Football Pitch, Church Terrace, Ynys-Hir, Porth, CF39 0ET 2 x information board signs displaying future fixtures and scores. Decision: Grant, 10/11/2022”

Officer report

Main effects considered

The platform and container would be screened from public views, sit about 86 metres from homes and not significantly increase match-day parking impacts.

“In this regard, Members are advised that the application site is located to the south-west of the football ground, some distance away from the nearest residential properties. Furthermore, the existing playing field is enclosed and somewhat screened in nature, given the perimeter fencing and mature trees that define the site. As such, the new level platform and container would be largely screened from view from any public vantage points outside of the site.”

“Highways Summary The objectors to the proposed scheme have tendered that on on-street parking in the area has reached peak capacity and consider that the development would exacerbate existing parking issues experienced by residents on match days.”

Officer report

Advice from consultees

Highways, public protection, water, flooding, ecology and structural engineering consultees raised no objections, subject to specified conditions or advice.

“Highways and Transportation – No objection.”

“Public Health and Protection – No objection, conditions suggested.”

Officer report

What objectors said

Five objections raised on-street parking, insufficient parking, the container’s appearance and possible effects on neighbouring property values.

“The application has been advertised by direct notification to neighbouring properties and through the erection of site notices. Five letters of objection have been received as a result of this exercise, with the following concerns being raised:”

“On street parking issues. • The container would be unsightly and an eyesore. • Devaluation of neighbouring properties. • Lack of parking.”

Officer report

Who addressed the committee

The applicant did not attend to address members, while a local member supported the proposal and a late supporting letter was outlined.

The committee decision

After considering the application, the committee resolved to approve it in accordance with the recommendation.

“The Head of Planning presented the application to Committee and following consideration it was RESOLVED to approve the application in accordance with the recommendation of the Director, Housing and Regeneration.”

Minutes